PRICE COMPETITION VS. QUALITY COMPETITION:
THE ROLE OF ONE-WAY TRADE
Š. BOJNEC – I. FERTÕ
(Received:1 May 2007; revision received: 8 August 2007;
accepted: 24 January 2008)
This paper investigates trade balances and unit values focusing on Hungarian–Slovenian bilateral
agri-food trade flows to distinguish types of one-way and two-way trade flows, categories of price
competition and categories of quality competition. We combine Gehlhar – Pick’s (GP) (2002) pro-
cedure of four trade categories with knowledge from literature on intra-industry trade (IIT) to disen-
tangle one-way trade, which can be significant when trade between two countries is imbalanced,
from two-way matched trade flows with unit values as proxies for price. By comparing the empirical
results obtained using the additional categories of one-way trade and disentangled IIT types in
two-way matched trade by product was found that GP’s two price and two quality competition cate-
gories and IIT types complement each other. The decomposition of GP non-price competition cate-
gories on quality competition and one-way trade illustrates that one-way trade is the most significant
component of agri-food trade between Hungary and Slovenia, a finding relevant for agri-food trade
of several small countries. One-way trade cannot be associated by the simultaneous export and im-
port unit values by the product, but by some other factors of trade specialisation and comparative
trade advantages of relevance for public policy makers and private business.
Keywords: one-way trade, price competition, quality competition
JEL classification index: F130, F140, F150, Q130, Q170
1. INTRODUCTION
Different theoretical and methodological approaches are available to investigate
trade types, which all classify trade types into various components. The combina-
0001-6373/$20.00 © 2008 Akadémiai Kiadó, Budapest
Acta Oeconomica, Vol. 58 (1) pp. 61–89 (2008)
DOI: 10.1556/AOecon.58.2008.1.3
Corresponding author: I. Fertõ, Institute of Economics, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Budaörsi
u. 45, H-1112 Budapest, Hungary. E-mail: ferto@econ.core.hu