Contributions to the History of Concepts Volume 12, Issue 2, Winter 2017: 76–110
doi:10.3167/choc.2017.120205 © Berghahn Books
FEATURED ARTICLE
Appropriations and Contestations
of the Islamic Nomenclature
in Muslim North India
Elitism, Lexicography, and
the Meaning of The Political
JAN-PETER HARTUNG
University of Goettingen
ABSTRACT
Tis article comprises a twofold attempt: the frst is to establish a semantic
feld that revolves around the concept of siyāsat—roughly equivalent to the
political—in Muslim South Asia; the second is to trace semantic shifs in this
feld and to identify circumstances that may have prompted those shifs. It is
argued here that the terms that constitute the semantic feld of the political
oscillate between two sociolinguistic traditions: a strongly Islamicate Arabic
one, and a more imperially oriented Persian one. Another linguistic shif is
indicated with the replacement of Persian by Urdu as the dominant literary
idiom in and beyond North India since the eighteenth century. Te aim is to
serve only as a starting point for a more intensive discussion that brings in
other materials and perspectives, thus helping to elucidate the tension be-
tween normative aspirations by ruling elites and actual political praxes by
variant socioeconomic groups.
KEYWORDS
ādāb, Arabic, farhang, Hindustani, lexicography, mawsūʿāt, Persian, siyāsat
Tis article has evolved from a working paper presented frst to the “History of Concepts in
South Asia—Initiative” at the Centre for the Study of Developing Societies in New Delhi,
28 September 2012, and to the “Symposium on Literature and History in Persianate South
Asia” held at the University of Oxford, 15 May 2015. I am most grateful to all the input I have
received from those present on either occasion, as well as to the referees of Contributions to
the History of Concepts.
Te Romanization of the various relevant languages in non-Latin scripts follows largely
the ALA-LC conventions for each respective language; an “h” struck out (ħ) indicates
aspiration of the preceding consonant. Life dates of Muslim authors are given according to
the Islamic lunar calendar, also known as the Hijri calendar, and in some places labeled with
“sh” (shamsī), as well as the solar Common Era.