Biodegradation potential of aquaculture
chemotherapeutants in marine sediments
Jonathan P Benskin
1
, Michael G Ikonomou
1
, Blair D Surridge
2
, Cory Dubetz
1
& Erik Klaassen
1
1
Institute of Ocean Sciences, Fisheries and Oceans Canada (DFO), Sidney, BC, Canada
2
Applied Chemistry and Biotechnology, Camosun College, Victoria, BC, Canada
Correspondence: M G Ikonomou, Institute of Ocean Sciences, Fisheries and Oceans Canada, 9860 West Saanich Road, P.O. Box
6000, Sidney, BC, Canada V8L 4B2. E-mail: michael.ikonomou@dfo-mpo.gc.ca
Abstract
The commercial chemotherapeutant formulations
SLICE
â
and AlphaMax
â
[active ingredients ema-
mectin benzoate (EB) and deltamethrin respectively]
are used in fin fish aquaculture to control parasitic
sea lice. In some regions, the use of these substances
has drawn concern from the commercial fishing
industry regarding potential adverse effects on non-
target organisms. In the present work, biodegrada-
tion of EB and deltamethrin, and their commercial
formulations, was investigated over 135 days at 4
and 10°C in fresh marine sediments collected from
underneath an active open net-pen salmon farm. EB
incubated as either pure substance or commercial
formulation was recalcitrant at both temperatures
under abiotic and biotic conditions. Deltamethrin
incubated alone or as its commercial formulation
degraded slowly at 10°C(t
1/2
= 330 Æ 107 and
201 Æ 27.1 days respectively). At 4°C, deltameth-
rin degradation was only significant following incu-
bation as commercial formulation (t
1/2
= 285 Æ
112 days). Degradation rates of EB and deltameth-
rin as pure substances versus their commercial for-
mulations were not statistically different. Depletion
of deltamethrin was observed in 10°C inactive sedi-
ments indicating that transformation occurred (at
least in part) via an abiotic pathway. Overall, these
data provide further insight into the fate and persis-
tence of EB from the ongoing use of SLICE
â
in British
Columbia’s salmon aquaculture industry. Alpha-
Max
â
is not registered in Canada but is used in other
salmon farming countries to control sea lice.
Keywords: biodegradation, chemotherapeutants,
sediment, emamectin benzoate, deltamethrin, sea
lice
Introduction
In 2010, ~80 open net-pen salmon farms were in
operation in British Columbia (B.C.), Canada, mak-
ing this province the fourth largest producer of
farmed salmon in the world, after Norway, Chile
and the United Kingdom (Province of B.C. 2010).
Among the challenges facing B.C.’s aquaculture
industry is the susceptibility of cultured fish to
infection from bacterial, viral and parasitic patho-
gens. Sea lice (primarily the Lepeophtheirus salmonis
species) are the most common naturally occurring
parasitic threat to farmed salmon raised in open
net-pens (Burridge, Weis, Cabello & Pizarro 2010).
Sea lice feed on surface tissue, leading to a range
of deleterious health effects, including disruption of
osmoregulation, secondary infections, behavioural
changes, and eventually, mortality (Torrissen,
Jones, Asche, Guttormsen, Skilbrei, Nilsen, Hors-
berg & Jackson 2013).
In B.C., the most common treatment for sea lice
infestation is SLICE
â
, a feed-based commercial
chemotherapeutant consisting of 0.2% (by weight)
of emamectin benzoate (4″-deoxy-4″-epi-methyla-
minoavermectin; EB) (Bright & Dionne 2004). EB
belongs to a class of substances known as aver-
mectins, which are particularly toxic to nerve cells
(Burridge et al. 2010). Once absorbed, EB is dis-
tributed throughout the salmon’s peripheral tis-
sues and is subsequently ingested by the louse,
resulting in paralysis and, eventually, death. Con-
cerns around the use of this chemotherapeutant
have centred primarily on its effects on non-target
organisms, in particular crustaceans (Bright &
Dionne 2004). Premature moulting has been
reported in lobsters exposed to a single gavage
dose of 1 lgg
À1
bodyweight of EB (Waddy,
© 2014 John Wiley & Sons Ltd 1
Aquaculture Research, 2014, 1–16 doi: 10.1111/are.12509