International Journal of Recent Technology and Engineering (IJRTE)
ISSN: 2277-3878, Volume-8 Issue-3, September 2019
1708
Published By:
Blue Eyes Intelligence Engineering &
Sciences Publication
Retrieval Number: C4452098319/19©BEIESP
DOI:10.35940/ijrte.C4452.098319
Abstract: The paper presents computational fluid dynamics
study of non-conventional insert vortex generator using
Commercial software, to analyze the effect of vortex generator
insert on heat transfer augmentation and fluid flow behavior.
The study was done for Reynolds number 10000, 15000, 25000,
35000 and 45000 with working fluid as air flowing through a
tube with a constant heat flux of 1000 w/m2. Current study
validates the experimental results from the literature study. The
heat transfer of these inserts with various geometrical
arrangements viz. pitch to projected length ratio, angle of attack
and height to inner diameter ratio are investigated here with the
help of computational fluid dynamics software. The physical
mechanism of formation and development of vortex flow from
the leading edge to trailing edge of the insert is studied and it is
observed that Nusselt number increases as an increment in
Reynolds number. The ratio of augmented Nusselt number to
smooth tube Nusselt number is found to be decreasing with
increase in Reynolds number.
Index Terms: Ansys Fluent, Computational Fluid Dynamics,
Heat Transfer Enhancement, Vortex Generator Insert.
I. INTRODUCTION
The heat transfer characteristics of any heat exchanger
can be enhanced by certain techniques that are active
techniques and passive techniques. In active technique, help
of some external power supplying unit is taken and the
passive technique involves heat transfer enhancement
without external power supplying unit. The passive
technique uses various types of inserts which are reported in
the literature survey. Deshmukh et al. [1] studied the use of
delta wing vortex generator as an insert in a tube. In this
study effect of vortex generator on heat transfer performance
is analyzed. They have studied thermohydraulic
characteristics of vortex generator for various geometrical
parameters viz. height to inner tube diameter ratio, pitch to
projected length ratio (p/pl) and angle of attack. The working
fluid is used as air. The ratio of Nusselt number (Nua/Nus)
with insert and without insert is found to be ranging from 1.3
to 5.0. Promvonge et al. [2] studied conical-shaped ring
turbulator insert and their effects on heat transfer and friction
factor are analyzed. The result of experiment shows that
Revised Manuscript Received on September 15, 2019
*
Shrinivas C. Deshmukh, School of Mechanical and Civil Engineering,
MIT Academy of Engineering Alandi (D), Savitribai Phule Pune University,
Pune, India, 412105. Email: scdeshmukh@mitaoe.ac.in
Dr. Prashant W. Deshmukh, Department of Mechanical Engineering,
College of Engineering, Pune, India. 411005. Email:
pwdeshmukh25@gmail.com
Prafulla R. Hatte, School of Mechanical and Civil Engineering, MIT
Academy of Engineering Alandi (D), Savitribai Phule Pune University, Pune,
India. 412105. Email: dean.smce@mitaoe.ac.in
there is a large effect of the ring to tube diameter ratio and
ring arrays on thermal performance. Salam et al. [3] did an
experimental investigation on rectangular cut twisted tape of
stainless steel. They observed increment in the heat transfer
efficiency in the range 1.9 to 2.3, with increment in Reynolds
number. Eiamsa-ard et al. [4] used twisted tape inserts with
peripherally cuts on it and conducted an experiment with
uniform flux condition with Reynolds number ranging in
between one thousand to twenty thousand. They found that
the tube with his insert shows significantly higher heat
transfer rate and friction factor mainly due to vorticity
generated due to the cuts on the insert. Wongcharee et al. [5]
investigated the effect of twisted tape insert placed inside a
tube with alternate axes that is clockwise and
counterclockwise with Reynolds number range of 830 to
1990 for different twist ratios with uniform heat flux and
water as a working fluid. The results of the research show
that the smallest twist ratio as very efficient in the
enhancement of heat transfer.
To study the effect of various types of inserts on heat
transfer enhancement with this experimental work certain
numerical study is carried out. Salman et al. [6] did
numerical investigation on parabolic cut twisted tape and
classical twisted tape with working fluid as water-copper
oxide Nanofluid and it was observed that parabolic cut
twisted tape shows better performance. Bhuyan et al. [7]
studied heat transfer enhancement using full length twisted
tape insert in a tabular shaped u loop pipes at a uniform flux.
Results show that full length twisted tape shows better heat
transfer enhancement in comparison with short length tapes.
Eiamsa-ard et al. [8] did the study on loose fit twisted tape
and tight fit twisted tape. It is found that at smallest clearance
ratios there is a better performance in comparison with other
all clearance ratio in terms of swirl flow generation and heat
transfer rate.
Sharifi et al. [9] had done a CFD study on wire coiled
insert in laminar flow using hexahedral mesh. The result
shows maximum Nusselt number and lowest performance
drop for coiled wire for a pitch of 69mm. Guo et al. [10] had
done investigation on heat transfer enhancement of laminar
flow with center cleared twisted tape insert. In this study they
compared the results from conventional, short width and
center cleared twisted tape, concluding that twisted tape with
center cleared tape shows augmentation in thermal
performance factor showing best performance among all
twisted tape stated. Park et al. [11] studied CFD analysis of
Heat Transfer Enhancement and Flow Physics
Behavior of Fluid in Circular Tube with Insert
Shrinivas C. Deshmukh, Prashant W. Deshmukh, Prafulla R. Hatte