Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Thin-Walled Structures
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/tws
Full length article
Experimental testing and numerical analysis of FDM multi-cell inserts and
hybrid structures
Stefan Tabacu
a,
⁎
,1
,Cătălin Ducu
b,1
a
Automotive Department; Faculty of Mechanics and Technology, University of Pitesti, 1, Târgu din Vale, 110040 Pitesti, Romania
b
Manufacturing Department, Faculty of Mechanics and Technology, University of Pitesti, 1, Târgu din Vale, 110040 Pitesti, Romania
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Fused deposition modelling
Sample testing
Axial crushing
Multi-cell structures
Hybrid structures
ABSTRACT
Modern transportation systems require light materials with an increased level of protection thus thin walled
structures are in the focus of structural engineers. The latest developments in the field of manufacturing pro-
cesses allow the use of Rapid Prototyping technologies for custom safety devices and Additive Manufacturing is a
candidate that already captured some attention. In this work Fused Deposition Modelling method was used to
manufacture samples for material characterization and multi-cell insert designed as safety devices and the
material is ABS. Traction tests were performed and some SEM images complete the specimens’ analysis. From
this analysis, in order to define a simple material model for numerical analysis, a stacking configuration -45°/0°/
45°/90° was selected. A model for material damage is also presented in this paper. Circular structures with
rectangular multi-cell were manufactured and tested in compression. In order to improve the performances a
hybrid structure was investigated. Aluminium tubes were added in order to enhance the performances of the
printed structures. For each step of the experimental work a numerical companion is presented. Modelling
techniques and parameters are presented and discussed in this paper. By adding the aluminium tube there is an
increase in the performances of the structure. A progressive profile for the crushing force is obtained. By ad-
justing the support (outer aluminium tube) and designing multi-cell insert, structures for safety enhancement can
be developed.
1. Introduction
Modern transportation systems require an increased level of pro-
tection thus, due to the increased number of add-on devices fitted on
board the mass of the supporting structure should be as low as possible
but at the same time it must provide the maximum level of protection
during a collision. As a consequence, thin walled structures are in the
focus of structural engineers especially when crashworthiness is ad-
dressed. These structures demonstrate a high energy absorption capa-
city for a relatively reduced mass, thus being a reliable solution when
the total mass of the construction is critical. The modern analysis of thin
walled structures with circular section has a strong background in work
of Abramowicz and Jones [1], Hsu and Jones [2], Wierzbicki et al. [3]
and Reid [4], while the structures with a rectangular cross-section were
investigated by Abramowicz and Jones [5] and Wierzbicki and Abra-
mowicz [6]. In order to improve the structural performance,multi-cell
structures were designed and studied by Alavi Nia and Parsapour [7],
Costas et al. [8], Jusuf et al. [9] Qiu et al. [10] and Zhang and Zhang
[11–13]. A recent review paper of Baroutaji et al. [14] outlines the
findings in field of thin-walled structures designed as energy absorbing
devices. The use of multi-cell structure is an effective method to in-
crease the energy absorption while keeping a reduced mass of the fin-
ished part. These structures can be manufactured by extrusion or, for
research purposes, by cutting from a solid block. This work is focused
on the investigation of circular multi-cell structures, previously in-
vestigated by developing a theoretical model for the evaluation of the
crushing force [11,15]. The latest developments in the field of manu-
facturing processes allow the use of Rapid Prototyping technologies for
custom safety devices. Rapid Prototyping includes sets of technologies
used to produce complex parts [16] in limited series. The parts can be
used for design and functional analysis and in some cases as structural
components, like multi-cell structures that are in the focus of the pre-
sent study. The performances of the finished parts are however de-
pendent on the technology employed for the manufacturing process
[17–19].
Among Rapid Prototyping technologies is Additive Manufacturing
which consists in building parts layer by layer. Due to the relatively
simplicity of the equipment, 3D Printers are widely used as Rapid
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tws.2018.04.009
Received 26 November 2017; Received in revised form 6 April 2018; Accepted 10 April 2018
⁎
Corresponding author.
1
web page: http://www.upit.ro
E-mail addresses: stefan.tabacu@upit.ro, stefan.tabacu@gmail.com (S. Tabacu), catalin.ducu@upit.ro, catalinducu@yahoo.com (C. Ducu).
Thin-Walled Structures 129 (2018) 197–212
0263-8231/ © 2018 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
T