This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INTELLIGENT TRANSPORTATION SYSTEMS 1
Powered Two-Wheelers Critical Events Detection
and Recognition Using Data-Driven Approaches
Ferhat Attal, Abderrahmane Boubezoul , Allou Samé, Latifa Oukhellou , and Stéphane Espié
Abstract— Driving errors are considered to be the greatest
contributory cause in all road accidents and an important
contributory cause of most fatal accidents. This is particularly
the case for the users of powered two-wheeled vehicles (PTWs),
perhaps because PTW riders play a greater role in the control of
their vehicles’ stability than four-wheeled vehicle drivers. Thus,
observing and analyzing the evolution of riders’ behavior in a
real-life context is an important step in the identification of the
road environment characteristics that constitute a risk factor
for PTW riders. A relevant research issue in naturalistic studies
is related to the detection and identification of critical riding
events from among the vast amount of data recorded during the
experiment. In this paper, two approaches were used to auto-
matically detect such critical riding events. First, we formalized
this problem in terms of detecting changes in the mean and
variance of the signals generated by the acceleration and angular
velocity sensors. For this purpose, two steps were performed:
1) a data segmentation and feature extraction step in which
the multidimensional time series of accelerometer and angular
velocity data were segmented and modeled using a Gaussian
mixture model with quadratic logistic proportions; and 2) a clas-
sification step in which each detected segment was assigned to the
appropriate riding sequence, whether “naturalistic” or “critical”
(i.e., fall or near fall), using the k-nearest neighbor algorithm.
The second approach was based on online fall detection. This
methodology used control charts (a multivariate cumulative sum),
an approach that has been traditionally employed for sequential
detection. These two algorithms were applied to a database
composed of data from a real-life driving experiment. The
obtained results show the effectiveness of both methodologies.
Index Terms— Powered two-wheelers, critical events detection
and recognition, data mining approaches.
I. I NTRODUCTION
I
N RECENT years, the public authorities have been making
considerable efforts to reduce the number of road fatalities.
This has resulted in the implementation of a number of
enforcement measures not only for speed (fixed and mobile
radars) but also for alcohol. Although these measures have led
Manuscript received January 2, 2017; revised June 27, 2017 and
November 23, 2017; accepted January 8, 2018. The Associate Editor for this
paper was Y. Gao. (Corresponding author: Abderrahmane Boubezoul.)
F. Attal is with the Laboratory of Images, Signals and Intelligent Sys-
tems, University of Paris-Est Cr ´ eteil, 94400 Vitry-Sur-Seine, France (e-mail:
abderrahmane.boubezoul@ifsttar.fr).
A. Boubezoul and S. Espié are with UPE-IFSTTAR/TS2/SIMU&MOTO,
F-77447 Marne la Vallée Cedex, France.
A. Samé and L. Oukhellou are with UPE-IFSTTAR/COSYS/GRETTIA,
F-77447 Marne la Vallée Cedex, France.
Color versions of one or more of the figures in this paper are available
online at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org.
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TITS.2018.2797065
to a considerable reduction in road mortality, all categories of
road users have not benefited equally from this improvement.
In 2013 for example, the statistics for the riders of powered
two-wheelers (PTWs) were alarming: although they repre-
sented just 2% of road traffic, they accounted for almost a
quarter of all fatalities. Road safety statistics also show that
PTWs account for 43% of severely injured road users, and
what makes matters worse is that the injuries they sustain have
serious consequences. Overall, the statistics highlight the high
vulnerability of PTW riders compared with other road users.
This group accounts for 24% of road mortality in France, but
accounts for only 2% of the traffic: in other terms, a PTW
rider is at 20 times greater risk of being killed on the road
than a car driver [1].
In spite of this excess risk, the PTWs market has grown
considerably in recent years. Individuals choose to use a
PTW for their home-to-work trips mainly because of shorter
journey times and the implementation of new sustainable urban
transport policies which aim to reduce private car use in urban
areas, especially city centres. Within this context of increasing
PTW traffic, the safety of PTW users is assuming considerable
importance.
It should also be noted that the majority of PTW accidents
occur because of interactions with other road users, most
noticeably the refusal of car drivers to give the right-of-way.
However, single-vehicle accidents, such as falls, are also an
important factor. In 2013 in France, one-third of the fatal PTW
accidents occurred without an identified third party (37.7%).
The loss of PTW control is common largely because of the
complexity of PTW dynamics and the intrinsic instability of
such vehicles. The analysis of accidents related to this mode
of transport led us to classify these accidents into two classes:
(1) single-vehicle accidents, such as falls and (2) accidents
involving other road users. Thus, for the study of the first
type of accident, we were interested in the development of an
online fall detection algorithm, for the deployment of airbag
jacket or any other alert system. As far as the accident with
other road users is a complex and multi-factorial problem,
the understanding of the factors that contribute to crashes is a
hard and time consuming task for safety researchers. Usually,
epidemiological and empirical methods have been used to
assess driving safety. Many large-scale research programs
have been enacted in Europe and elsewhere to understand
the factors that contribute to crashes [2]. During the last few
years, thanks to the developments in the embedded electronics
and sensors domains, instrumented vehicles are increasingly
1524-9050 © 2018 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission.
See http://www.ieee.org/publications_standards/publications/rights/index.html for more information.