2310 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON NEURAL NETWORKS, VOL. 22, NO. 12, DECEMBER 2011
Improved GART Neural Network Model for
Pattern Classification and Rule Extraction with
Application to Power Systems
Keem Siah Yap, Member, IEEE, Chee Peng Lim, and Mau Teng Au, Member, IEEE
Abstract— Generalized adaptive resonance theory (GART) is
a neural network model that is capable of online learning and is
effective in tackling pattern classification tasks. In this paper, we
propose an improved GART model (IGART), and demonstrate its
applicability to power systems. IGART enhances the dynamics of
GART in several aspects, which include the use of the Laplacian
likelihood function, a new vigilance function, a new match-
tracking mechanism, an ordering algorithm for determining the
sequence of training data, and a rule extraction capability to
elicit if-then rules from the network. To assess the effectiveness of
IGART and to compare its performances with those from other
methods, three datasets that are related to power systems are
employed. The experimental results demonstrate the usefulness
of IGART with the rule extraction capability in undertaking
classification problems in power systems engineering.
Index Terms— Fuzzy inference systems, generalized adaptive
resonance theory, pattern classification, rule extraction.
I. I NTRODUCTION
O
VER the last two decades, artificial neural networks
(or simply neural networks) have been developed for
solving pattern classification problems in many different
domains [1]–[4]. In power systems engineering, a number
of successful applications using neural networks have been
reported. These include the use of neural networks for
short-term power load or price forecasting [5], [6], and fault
diagnosis for transformers. The fuzzy ARTMAP (FAM)
neural network was used for fault diagnosis of an operational
transformer [7]. Other neural network-related fault detection
models for transformers include an abductive network model
(a hybrid fuzzy logic and neural network model), a hybrid
genetic algorithm and wavelet neural network, and a multilayer
feedforward neural network [8]–[10]. In [11], a neural network
was used to provide an early warning of combustion-related
faults in a diesel engine. In [12] and [13], the fuzzy min-max
and the FAM networks were used for condition monitoring
of the circulating water system in a power generation plant.
A fault detection method in circuit breakers using wavelet
Manuscript received December 4, 2010; revised August 11, 2011; accepted
October 16, 2011. Date of publication November 4, 2011; date of current
version December 13, 2011.
K. S. Yap is with the College of Graduate Studies, Universiti Tenaga
Nasional, Kajang 43009, Malaysia (e-mail: yapkeem@uniten.edu.my).
C. P. Lim is with the School of Computer Sciences, University of Science
Malaysia, Penang 11800, Malaysia (e-mail: cplim@cs.usm.my).
M. T. Au is with the Power Engineering Centre, Universiti Tenaga Nasional,
Kajang 43009, Malaysia (e-mail: mtau@uniten.edu.my).
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TNN.2011.2173502
packet and the multilayer feed-forward neural network with
the backpropagation learning algorithm was described in
[14]. Other applications of neural networks in power systems
engineering include assessment of power quality [15], load
shedding [16], power system stabilizers [17], and active power
filters [18].
While there are many different types of neural networks,
not many of them have the ability of knowledge extraction.
Most neural networks suffer from the limitation whereby their
reasoning process is considered as a “black box” [19]–[21],
and there is no logical explanatory facility to justify their
predictions. To overcome this limitation, researchers have pro-
posed neural network models with rule extraction capabilities
[12], [13], [21], [22]. According to [12], a neural network
with a rule extraction capability has two major advantages:
1) explanation of results—the extracted rules can be used
as a self-explanatory module to its predictions, and 2) data
exploration and feature revelation—the ability of extracting
rules into the if-then form [21] that may help users to identify
if an input attribute has been always (or seldom) assigned to
the same linguistic value (e.g., big, small, etc.).
The objectives of this paper are twofold. First, a new
improved generalized adaptive resonance theory (GART)
neural network with a rule extraction capability is proposed.
In our previous work, the theoretical development of GART
neural network has been reported [23]. It is a hybrid neural
network model combining the adaptive resonance theory
(ART) [24], [25] network and the generalized regression neural
network (GRNN) [26] that is capable of incremental learning.
In this paper, the capability of GART is further improved
(hereafter denoted as IGART) with several features that are
essential for practical applications. These include improved
dynamics of GART with a Laplacian likelihood function [27],
a new vigilance function, and a match-tracking mechanism. An
ordering algorithm for determining the presentation sequence
of the training samples, and a series of post processing
procedures, i.e., network pruning and rule extraction, are also
incorporated into IGART.
The second objective is to demonstrate the effectiveness
of IGART for solving problems related to power systems
engineering. Three case studies in three main areas of the
power engineering industry, i.e., generation, transmission, and
distribution, are examined. It is envisaged that researchers and
practitioners from different areas in the power engineering
industry can obtain ideas and techniques from this paper,
1045–9227/$26.00 © 2011 IEEE