1910 JOURNAL OF FOOD SCIENCE—Vol. 68, Nr. 6, 2003 © 2003 Institute of Food Technologists
Further reproduction prohibited without permission
Food Chemistry and Toxicology
Effect of 1-Methylcyclopropene
on the Quality of Fresh-cut Apple Slices
C.O. PERERA, L. BALCHIN, E. BALDWIN, R. STANLEY, AND M. TIAN
ABSTRACT: The objective of this project was to treat fresh-cut apple slices with the ethylene inhibitor 1-
methylcyclopropene (1-MCP) to retard ethylene-induced deterioration and senescence and to prolong the shelf
life of such products. Intact Braeburn and Pacific Rose apples were treated at different times with 1-MCP, cut, and
stored at 0 ° C. Samples were analyzed initially and then weekly for ethylene, respiration, flesh firmness, tissue
color, titratable acidity, and soluble solids content during 5 wk of storage. 1-MCP treatment was effective in reduc-
ing ethylene production, respiration, and loss of firmness and color of slices when applied to whole apples directly
after harvest. Total sugar and acidity levels were not affected significantly.
Keywords: braeburn apple, Pacific Rose apple, ethylene, respiration, firmness, solids, malic acid
Introduction
I
N RECENT YEARS, THERE HAS BEEN A CONSIDERABLE INCREASE IN DE-
mand for high quality fruit and vegetables, coupled with conve-
nience and safety. Consumers are indicating a strong preference for
fresh fruits and vegetables over their processed counterparts (Bolin
and Huxsoll 1989). Furthermore, changes in consumer lifestyles
have led to an increased desire for ready-to-eat or ready-to-use
products, and therefore, interest in “minimally” or “lightly” pro-
cessed products. Despite popularity, the production of minimally
processed (MP) fruit is limited because of rapid deterioration and
senescence. The plant tissues incur damage during processing,
leading within minutes to increased rates of respiration and ethyl-
ene production (Brecht 1995), and essentially a “wound response”
is initiated. Injury stresses caused by minimal processing result in
mechanical plant cell rupture and cellular decompartmentation,
leading to delocalization and intermixing of enzymes and sub-
strates. Because of removal of the protective peel, microbial prolif-
eration and desiccation are accelerated. Quality is reduced because
of associated degradative processes, and even under ideal storage
conditions, the shelf life of these products is limited.
Although the shelf life of fresh-cut vegetables and salads is longer,
marketing of fresh-cut fruit has been limited to 4 to 7 d (Ahvenainen
1996). The industry, however, would much prefer a 21-d marketing
window. One major challenge is to develop techniques that will effec-
tively extend the shelf life of these products while ensuring product
quality and safety. The gaseous plant hormone ethylene induces syn-
thesis of enzymes that lead to fruit ripening, senescence, and degra-
dation. Therefore, one strategy to retard deterioration and senescence
of MP fruit would be to remove this hormone and/or block its effects.
Browning reactions are the main factors that limit acceptance
and storage of any type of cut apple (Malus domestica Borkh)
product. Apples contain a complex mixture of phenolic com-
pounds, catalyzed by phenylalanine ammonia-lyase (PAL), and
enzymatic browning involves the oxidation of these phenolics. MP
causes these oxidation rates to increase up to 25-fold over the
normal physiological rate (Bolin and Huxsoll 1989). Agents used
to control enzymatic browning include sulfur dioxide, ascorbic
acid, and derivatives, L-cysteine, ethanol, and 4-hexylresorcinol
with varying results. Wounding is generally followed by a lag pe-
riod preceding a rise in the activities of PAL and PPO. It is known
that ethylene plays an important role in this metabolic activation
response.
The development of flavor and fruit eating quality is determined
in large part by the relative amounts of sugars, acids, and astrin-
gents. In general, the rate of deterioration (perishability) of harvest-
ed commodities is proportional to their rate of respiration. There-
fore, regulation of respiration rates has become a common target
for the biochemical manipulation of shelf life. Both sugars and acids
in apple serve as respiratory substrates (Knee 1993). Malic acid is
the major organic acid in apples and can be reduced by 50% dur-
ing the life of the fruit (Knee 1993; Tucker 1993).
Ethylene production increased in segments excised from apple
flesh, reaching a maximum value 24 h after cutting (Rollin 1999).
This “wound ethylene” then accelerates deterioration and senes-
cence as shown by Brecht (1995) when ethylene produced by the
physical action of MP was sufficient to accelerate softening of ba-
nana and kiwifruit. Essentially, wounding induces ethylene produc-
tion, which in turn, induces ripening. The 1.2- to 7-fold increase in
“wound” respiration commonly seen in MP tissue is also thought
to be a direct consequence of elevated ethylene levels resulting from
the induced production of volatile long-chain aldehydes due to lipid
peroxidation (Watada and others 1990).
A number of technologies have been used to reduce ethylene
synthesis or action, including antisense gene technology (Hamil-
ton and others 1990) and application of compounds such as silver
in the form of thiosulfate (STS) and diazocyclopentadiene (DACP)
(Blankenship and Sisler 1993; Sisler and Serek 1997). However, few
of these compounds have been fully successful or their use has been
limited to nonfood products. Recently, a new organic molecule, 1-
methylcyclopropene (1-MCP), has been discovered that can block
the ethylene receptor for extended periods (Blankenship and Dole
2003). This molecule is a cyclic olefin analogous to the photodecom-
position product of DACP (Tian and others 1997), is a gas at room
temperature, and is relatively stable (compared with the explosive
DACP) (Sisler and Serek 1997).
Autocatalytic ethylene production requires upregulation, by eth-
ylene, of 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylate (ACC) synthase and
ACC oxidase activity (Lelievre and others 1997a, 1997b). They dem-
onstrated that treatment with 1-MCP resulted in reduced accumu-
lation of ACC synthase/oxidase transcripts and ethylene produc-
tion in pears, during chilling. The majority of the climacteric rise
in ethylene production was prevented in carnation flowers follow-
ing treatment with low concentration (0.5 nL/L) 1-MCP (Sisler and
others 1996a). In addition, 1-MCP vapors have also been shown to
JFS: Food Chemistry and Toxicology