Report
New Cinemas: Journal of Contemporary Film Volume 5 Number 1 © 2007 Intellect Ltd.
Report. English language. doi: 10.1386/ncin.5.1.75/4
Film-making in Bhutan: The view from
Shangri-La
Sue Clayton Royal Holloway, University of London
Abstract
Bhutan until the last decade drastically restricted its contact with the outside
world, and recent media interest has focussed only on Bhutan’s late reception of
global satellite TV and the Internet. To date there has been no scholarly account of
its indigenous DV film industry; one that has produced nearly a hundred feature-
length films, none of which have yet been screened outside Bhutan. The author of
this report has had unique access to the country and, as a screenwriter and direc-
tor herself, has by working in collaboration with Bhutanese colleagues gained
added insights into the creative and practical dilemmas faced by film-makers there.
She also highlights areas of concern to film theorists with regard to questions of
spectatorship, as well as narrative strategies around the notion of the dream.
Present-day perceptions of Bhutan
Until 1999, the Western world paid little attention to the small Buddhist
kingdom of Bhutan in the eastern Himalayas. As well as its geographical
remoteness, Bhutan was isolated politically as first its ally Tibet was
annexed by the Chinese (1949–1951), and then the neighbouring inde-
pendent kingdom of Sikkim was subsumed into India (1975). The govern-
ment of Bhutan also discouraged foreign visitors, and culturally the
country’s existence only sporadically impinged on us through texts such
as James Hilton’s 1933 novel Lost Horizon, which first coined the term
‘Shangri-La’ to connote a remote, lost paradise.
1
However, inside Bhutan since the mid-1990s there have been moves to
engage with global culture, culminating in the country’s becoming, in
1999, the last on earth to receive international satellite TV, negotiating
a 48-channel satellite package, which included CNN, MTV and a variety of
Hollywood and Bollywood movie channels. This event cued a spate of
world press coverage, which opined that sudden access to global electronic
media would spell ‘trouble in paradise’ in a stable society that, on its
outward surface, seemed to retain essentially feudal characteristics (David
1999; Scott-Clark and Levy 2003). This coverage overlooked two important
points. Firstly, that Bhutan is not a passive victim of new media as they
suggest: The introduction of these media and their likely effects has been,
1 Lost Horizon was later
adapted into the
1937 Frank Capra
film of the same
name.
75 NCJCF 5 (1) 75–89 © Intellect Ltd 2007
Keywords
Bhutan
emerging cinemas
South East Asian
cinema
spectatorship
narrative strategies
dreams
screenwriting
independent
film-making