92 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON PROFESSIONAL COMMUNICATION, VOL. 56, NO. 2, JUNE 2013
Introduction to the Special Section: Designing a Better User
Experience for Self-Service Systems
—THEA VAN DER GEEST,JUDITH RAMEY,STEPHANIE ROSENBAUM, SENIOR MEMBER, IEEE, AND LEX VAN VELSEN
Index Terms—Best practices, communication effectiveness, consumer behavior, design for quality, human-computer
interaction, online services, self-service systems, sociotechnical systems, usability, user-centered design, user
experience, user experience design, user interfaces, user research.
In one of our first meetings as editors of this special
section on “Designing a Better User Experience
for Self-Service Systems,” we started listing some
of the self-service systems that we had used that
very day. Our list included an automatic teller
machine (ATM), an online banking site, a driving
license renewal application, a ticketing machine, a
check-in terminal for the train, a vending machine,
a site where you could sign up for government
health insurance, parking meters, and different
web stores.
We had used those self-service systems through
websites on our desk computers and through
applications on our mobile phones, but also
through terminals and kiosks that we had
encountered in public places. The systems were
designed with many intended functions in mind:
presenting information, enabling transactions, and
selling various products and services. However, the
essential and critical function we address in this
special section is that self-service systems must
help us to help ourselves.
LIVING IN A SELF-SERVICE SOCIETY
We are increasingly living in a self-service society.
Many organizations are making the shift to
self-service systems as an alternative to their
“traditional” service provided in face-to-face contact
with an employee or telephone contact with a call
center agent. The benefits of self-service to the
organization are often clear; self-service is more
efficient for them and, hence, cheaper. Also, with
Manuscript received March 04, 2013; accepted April 03, 2013.
Date of current version May 20, 2013.
T. van der Geest is with the University of Twente,
Cubicus, Enschede 7500 AE, the Netherlands (email:
T.M.vanderGeest@utwente.nl).
J. Ramey is with the University of Washington, Seattle, WA
98195 USA (email: jramey@uw.edu).
S. Rosenbaum is with TecEd, Inc., Ann Arbor, MI 48108 USA
(email: stephanie@teced.com).
L. van Velsen is with Roessingh Research and Development,
Telemedicine Group, Enschede 7500 AH, the Netherlands
(email: l.vanvelsen@rrd.nl).
IEEE 10.1109/TPC.2013.2258731
self-service, they can expand their business hours
and target a much larger customer audience.
The business advantage of the self-service
alternative can be considerable. A Dutch bank
calculated that a complete redesign of their website,
with the aim of making it completely accessible
and entirely self-service, reduced the number
of contacts with their telephone call center by
15%–30%. With about 20,000 calls per week, and
organizational costs of 7.50–12.50 per call, the
focus on web-based self-service brought the bank
a cost reduction of more than 1.7 million Euro per
year [1].
But what about the benefits for users and
customers, who often have no choice but to use
the self-service system? Both public and private
organizations seem to assume that we—the
average citizen, client, or customer—can cope with
ever-changing self-service systems, and are willing
to do so. Self-service systems offer us the benefit of
24/7 access to an ever-growing range of services
and perhaps also a strong sense of autonomy
and fulfillment. In exchange, we—rather than the
service providers—have to put in extra effort, as
well as losing “the human touch” in the service
encounter. We can no longer call on a “real” human
but find ourselves face-to-face with a system, and
we are on our own to make the darned thing work
for us!
What does that scenario mean for experiences
designed and created for the users of these systems,
and how do self-service system developers take the
premise of self-service into account in the design of
such systems? That is the question that led to the
work for this special section.
PLACING SELF-SERVICE COMMUNICATION IN THE
FIELD OF PROFESSIONAL COMMUNICATION
The field of professional communication rests
on decades of research and practice in the
design of information products—print and
online documentation, training, software user
0361-1434/$31.00 © 2013 IEEE