International Journal of Engineering and Advanced Technology (IJEAT)
ISSN: 2249 – 8958, Volume-9 Issue-3, February, 2020
3399
Published By:
Blue Eyes Intelligence Engineering
& Sciences Publication
Retrieval Number: C6259029320 /2020©BEIESP
DOI: 10.35940/ijeat.C6259.029320
Abstract: In vehicle design, safety of occupants is one of the
most important criteria. During side collisions, space between
vehicle body and occupants is very less as compared to frontal
collision. Hence, scope for energy absorption due to deformation
of vehicle body in side collisions is less. The strength of side door
plays important role in the framework of vehicle side body. The
strength of side doors during side collision depends upon the
impact beam, vehicle construction, layout of doors etc. Among
the mentioned parameters, strength of impact beam is a crucial
parameter. The impact beam absorbs notable amount of impact
energy by deforming during side collision. Design of side impact
beam should be optimum as it is limited by weight of vehicle.
Parameters like material, dimensions, shape and mountings of
beam inside the door are affecting the strength of side impact
beam. In this work parameters of circular cross-section impact
beam like diameter of beam, thickness of beam and angle of
mounting inside the door are studied. Finite element simulation of
side impact beam is done in ABAQUS software and its relative
effects on Specific Energy Absorption (SEA) capacity of beam is
studied. The simulation results are validated with available
literatures. The ANOVA analysis followed by Design of
Experiments is used to determine contribution of each parameter
on SEA. Further various parameters of circular impact beam are
studied by examining the result analysis for crashworthiness of
side door.
Keywords: Side impact beam; Side intrusion beam; vehicle side
door; Taguchi method; ANOVA; crashworthiness of side door,
Specific Energy Absorption
I. INTRODUCTION
Road accidents are major causes of premature deaths in
India. It also leads to severe injuries, permanent disabilities
and financial losses to the occupants. In 2018, India had
4, 67,044 road accidents. Out of total accidents 1, 51,417
occupants were dead and 4, 69,418 were severely injured [1].
The data also shockingly shows that in year 2018, in India per
day 1279 road accidents occurred and 414 peoples died. Out
Revised Manuscript Received on February 26, 2020.
* Correspondence Author
Sanjay D. Patil*, Autombile Engineering Department, Government
College of Engineering and Research, Avasari (kh), Pune, India. Email:
sanjaypatil365@gmail.com
Dheeraj S. Lengare, Autombile Engineering Department, Government
College of Engineering and Research, Avasari (kh), Pune, India. Email:
lengare27@gmail.com
Arvind J. Bhosale, Autombile Engineering Department, Government
College of Engineering and Research, Avasari (kh), Pune, India. Email:
pawandeep94@gmail.com
Kiran B. Bansode, Autombile Engineering Department, Government
College of Engineering and Research, Avasari (kh), Pune, India. Email:
kiran261282@gmail.com
Rashtrapal B. Teltumade, Autombile Engineering Department,
Government College of Engineering and Research, Avasari (kh), Pune,
India. Email: rashtrapal_teltumade@rediffmail.com
of these total accidents, 58,774 accidents were side impact
collisions and 15,477 people’s had lost their lives [1]. This
study also shows that in year 2018, average 10.2% lives are
lost due to side impact collision. All this data shows that, the
effects of side collision on vehicle design should be properly
analyze. Generally in cars, active and passive safety systems
are installed to protect the occupants. Active system
technologies like traction control system, antilock-brake
system etc. assists in prevention of collision. There are also
passive systems like side air bag, seat belt, side impact beam
etc. which prevent the occupants from severe injuries during
collisions [2-3]. During side impact collisions, only side door
is in between the occupant and the external object. Hence, the
crashworthiness of car side door is crucial parameter during
side impact collision.
Crashworthiness is ability of the side door to absorb the
impact energy during collision. Side impact beam also known
as side intrusion beam, installed inside the side door is the key
element in side door for crashworthiness [4-6]. During the
side impact collision, the side impact beam gets deformed and
it absorbs the impact energy of collision. As the Space
between occupant and side door is less compared to the space
between the frontal vehicle body, side impacts have the less
scope for large deformations and leads in less amount of
impact energy absorption [6-7]. Due to above concerns,
proper study of design of an effective side impact beam is
important.
Currently vehicle sold in various countries around the
globe are tested for various vehicle compliance like side crash
safety, United state regulation Federal Motor Vehicle Safety
Standards (FMVSS) No. 214, European Union regulation
ECER95, China Regulation GB20071-2006 and Indian
standards IS 12009-1996 etc. Homologation to the vehicles is
given only after the vehicle successfully meets regulatory
standards and specifications prescribed by the respective
countries [8-11]. As per the Indian standards IS 12009, a long
cylindrical or semi cylindrical rigid steel bar of 300mm
diameter is intruded along the circumferential surface on the
side door from outside. The initial crush resistance,
Intermediate crush resistance and peak crush resistances are
measured at 150mm, 300mm and 450mm of crush distance
respectively. As per the standards, the initial crush resistance
should not be less than 10kN or 0.6 times of kerb weight of
vehicle, the Intermediate crush resistance should not be less
than 20kN or 1.2 times of kerb weight of vehicle and peak
crush resistances should not be less than 55kN or 2 times of
kerb weight of vehicle [10, 12].
Parameters Affecting the Specific Energy
Absorption of Circular Side Impact Beam
Sanjay D. Patil, Dheeraj S. Lengare, Arvind J. Bhosale, Kiran B. Bansode,
Rashtrapal B. Teltumade