Vol 12, Issue 5, 2019
Online - 2455-3891
Print - 0974-2441
EVALUATION OF GRAPE SEED EXTRACT (VITIS VINIFERA) AS A CROSSLINKER ON THE
STABILITY OF DENTINE COLLAGEN IN TOTAL-ETCH ADHESIVE SYSTEMS: AN IN VITRO STUDY
D DENNIS, FENIKA MAITARI
Department of Conservative Dentistry, Faculty of Dentistry, Center of Excellence, Green Chitosan and Advanced Material, Universitas
Sumatera Utara, Indonesia. Email: dennis_dionisius@yahoo.co.uk
Received: 10 February 2019, Revised and Accepted: 30 March 2019
ABSTRACT
Objective: The bond strength between resin and dentine is determined by the integrity of collagen, dentine, and resin monomers. The susceptibility of
the dentine bond results from the instability of the bonding structure that adheres to the bonding material. This can be achieved using collagen cross-
linker, synthetically and naturally in dentine substrates which are effective in protecting collagen fibrils from degradation, as proanthrocyanidin. The
aim of this study was to see the effect of grape seed extract as a crosslinker on the stability of dentine collagen and see the differences between groups.
Methods: This study used 27 fresh premolars or third molars which were divided into three Groups, namely Group I giving grape seed extract 6.5%, Group II
giving chlorhexidine 2%, and Group III only giving bonding ingredients. Samples were analyzed using scanning electron microscopy with ×1000 magnification.
Results: Data were analyzed using kappa statistic, Kruskal–Wallis, and Mann–Whitney. The result of the study significant differences between
treatment groups (p<0.05) and the 2% chlorhexidine group showed the highest value compared to the grape seed extract group and without treatment.
Conclusion: Grape seed extract can be used as an alternative to chlorhexidine as a crosslinker to maintain bone strength of the composite restoration.
Keywords: Bond strength, Proanthocyanidine, Grape seed extract, Crosslinker
INTRODUCTION
The use of composite resins for dental restorations in the past decade
to restore carious teeth has greatly increased. The need for esthetics
and low toxicity makes popular composite resins. The initial problem
in using composite resins is low durability due to the use and loss of
anatomical shape after use [1]. Composite resins contain bonds that
are not stable, so they are easily degraded by acid or low pH. Acid
causes polymer degradation and filler components which can affect the
hardness and roughness of the composite resin surface [2].
Various studies have shown that there is a decrease in composite resin
bonds in dentine which in this case can be attributed to the complexity
of dentine structures such as increasing tubular numbers and diameter
with intertubular dentine matrix which is much less than superficial
dentine [3]. Successful adhesion to enamel with a strong adhesive value
height cannot be achieved equivalent to dentine. Dentine has a higher
water and organic content than enamel, which causes dentine to be
moist, so that the adhesion system must be hydrophilic [4].
Dentine has a composition of 70% minerals (apatite crystals), 18% is
in the form of organic components, namely collagen type 1 and non-
collagen proteins, while 12% is water [4]. Dentin collagen is needed to
form a cross bond that can provide strength and stabilization, so it is
needed as a biomaterial [5].
Infiltration of resin monomers into dentinal tubular tissue and intertubule will
form micromechanical retention areas called hybrid layers. Micromechanical
retention between resin and dentin is the main mechanism of resin–dentine
bond. The bond strength between resin and dentine is determined by the
integrity of collagen, dentine, and resin monomers [6,7].
The resistance of the hybrid layer depends on the stability of each
component, such as collagen fibrils and polymer chains. However, collagen
fibrils which are not fully infiltrated by resin monomers when exposed to
acid etching inhibit optimal protection against denaturation. Unprotected
collagen is more susceptible to creep and cyclic fatigue ruptures after
functioning for a long time. In the fibril collagen, resins are filled and
surrounded by water, which participates in the matrix hydrolysis of resin
by esterases and collagen by collagenolytic enzymes [8].
The susceptibility of the dentine bond results from the instability of
the bonding structure that adheres to the bonding material. This is due
to physical and chemical factors including hydrolysis and enzymatic
degradation by matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) which can increase
the risk of degradation of collagen dentine in hybrid layers.[8,9] In the
degradation of hybrid layers by MMPs, MMPs inhibitors act to protect
collagen in the hybrid layer. Chlorhexidine 2% can inhibit MMP-2, -8,
and -9 and, even at low concentrations, can maintain the integrity
of the hybrid layer. The role of chlorhexidine is to delay dentine
demineralization but does not stop the degradation of the bonds
permanently. However, chlorhexidine also has deficiencies in the form
of discoloration and bitter taste [10,11].
Mechanical properties of collagen and its resistance to enzymatic
degradation can be improved by increasing the formation of intra-
and inter-molecular and intermicrofibrillar cross-links. This can be
achieved using synthetic and natural collagen cross-linker in the
dentine substrate before bonding procedures [12].
The use of collagen cross-linking agent is proposed to improve the
mechanical properties of the dentine matrix, reduce the level of
biodegradation of collagen, increase the nature of dentine resin
bonding, and extend the life of adhesive restoration [5]. One natural
collagen cross-linker is proanthocyanidin. Proanthocyanidin, called
condensed tannins, is a structure of flavan-3-ol [13]. Proanthocyanidin
is found in fruits, vegetables, nuts, seeds, and flowers [14].
Grape seed compounds include flavonoids, polyphenols,
anthocyanins, proanthocyanidins, procyanidins, and the stilbene
© 2019 The Authors. Published by Innovare Academic Sciences Pvt Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY license (http://creativecommons.
org/licenses/by/4. 0/) DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.22159/ajpcr.2019.v12i5.32506
Research Article