COMPARISON OF COMMERCIALLY AVAILABLE DRUGS FOR TYPE 2 DIABETES WITH
NATURAL MOLECULE FROM TINOSPORA
Original Article
NISHTHA PANDEY
1#
, RAVI KANT PATHAK
1#
, NEETA RAJ SHARMA
School of Biotechnology and Biosciences, Lovely Professional University, Phagwara, Punjab, 144402
Email: neeta.raj@lpu.co.in
1*
Received: 22 Jan 2016 Revised and Accepted: 17 May 2016
ABSTRACT
Objective: Efficacy of natural molecule from Tinospora cordifolia versus commercially available drugs to control diabetes 2.
Methods: Twelve different drug molecules were selected to study drug properties, bioactivity and detailed mode of action. A comparative study was
carried out among the drugs and plant metabolite to understand the putative mechanism of metabolite action and its potential to be developed as
an herbal drug. PharmaGist Server was used to carry out pharmacophore modeling. The sequence of the target molecule (Q09428) was retrieved
from UniProtKB/SwissProt, and structure prediction was carried out using ITASSER. The best model generated was further refined by energy
minimization using Deep View. Validation of the structure was performed by Ramachandran plot analysis using PDBSum. Interaction analysis of the
docked complex was done using LigPlot+.
Results: The potential of natural plant metabolite to target ATP-binding cassette sub-family C member 8 seems probable based on docking and
interaction analysis results. The natural molecule showed comparable binding energy (-5.57) in four out of seven drugs.
Conclusion: Natural molecule from Tinospora cordifolia may serve as a potential lead drug molecule after modification and optimization for
enhanced interaction.
Keywords: Diabetes mellitus, Natural molecule, Tinospora, Type 2 diabetes
© 2016 The Authors. Published by Innovare Academic Sciences Pvt Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/)
INTRODUCTION
The type 2 diabetes is a chronic metabolic disorder triggered by
insulin insensitivity and reduced level of insulin secretion. Insulin is
a hormone that plays a key role in the transport of glucose to organs
like the liver. Deficit production of insulin enhances the level of
glucose in blood [1]. Type 2 diabetes, unlike type 1, is independent
insulin disorder [2]. As per WHO 2014 factsheet, diabetes is
prevalent in approximately 9% of adults. Though there is no cure for
diabetes, drugs that stimulate insulin release are often used to
regulate glucose absorption in type 2 diabetes patients.
Sulphonylureas constitute a major group of insulin secreting anti-
diabetic drugs [3]. Sulphonylureas function by targeting ATP-
potassium channels in the membrane of pancreatic beta cells and
inhibiting potassium efflux. Inhibition of efflux leads to
depolarization and calcium influx. The influx enhances calcium-
calmodulin binding, kinase activation, and release of insulin-
containing granules by exocytosis. The drugs mimic the activity of
glucose [4-7].
However, some findings associated use of sulphonylurea based
drugs with hypoglycemia and increased risk of heart diseases [8].
Natural remedies and nutraceutical are hence preferred these days
because; they provide the added advantage of minimum adverse
effects. Tinospora cordifolia (Guduchi) is a medicinal plant that has
been used since ancient times in the Ayurveda, for the treatment of
multiple ailments including diabetes [9]. Secondary metabolites and
active compounds of Tinospora cordifolia have been isolated from
the plant and, the functions of these molecules have been reported.
While both stem and root extracts of Tinospora regulate diabetes
mellitus type 2; stem extract also functions in the regulation of
diabetic neuropathy [10-13]. However, the detailed mode of action
of active compounds has not been explored completely. This study
focused on potential target identification for the insulin secretion
stimulating active compound of Tinospora cordifolia. A
comparative analysis has been carried out among the natural
compound and some marketed sulphonylurea drugs to evaluate
the applicability of Tinospora as a formulation for the
development of an effective drug. Drugs used for the treatment of
diabetes mellitus type 2 were searched in drug bank and
annotations of the records were compiled.
Twelve different drug molecules were selected to study drug
properties, bioactivity (http://www. molinspiration. com) and
detailed mode of action. Properties viz., Drug Bank accession
number, log P, polar surface area, the number of atoms, molecular
weight, the number of polar groups with potential to form Hydrogen
bonds, the number of violations, rotatable bonds, volume, and target
of the drugs have been reported below (table1). Out of the twelve
drugs studied, sulphonylurea class drugs function by blocking ATP-
dependent K
+
efflux channel. The blockage leads to depolarization and
activation of voltage-dependent calcium ion channel and Ca
2+
Structures (http://www.molinspiration.com) of the sulphonylurea
molecules were compared [fig.1] for pharmacophore identification;
pharmacophore modeling was also carried out using the Pharma
Gist Server [15]. Features of drug molecule reported by Pharma Gist
were compared with plant metabolite. The sequence of the target
molecule (Q09428) was retrieved from UniProtKB/SwissProt [16].
As the structure of target molecule has not yet been solved and,
suitable templates with full-length query coverage were not
identified, structure prediction was carried out using ITASSER [17].
In one run, ITASSER accepts query proteins are having less than 1500
residues so, structure prediction of the target was carried out in two
separate jobs (position 1-1380 and 1290-1581) with an overlapping
segment of 90 residues. Care was taken to ensure that regions are
forming domains based on ProRule annotations [18] were intact as a
query in one of the jobs. The best models generated by ITASSER were
used as a template for Modeller9v14 [19] and, one intact model
involving all the 1581 residues was generated. The best model generated
was further refined by energy minimization using DeepView [20].
influx,
which eventually stimulates insulin release. A metabolite of Tinospora
cordifolia has also been reported to stimulate insulin secretion [11] so;
the comparative study was carried out among the drugs and plant
metabolite to understand the putative mechanism of metabolite action
and, potential to be developed as a drug. Properties of the drugs were
analyzed, DB01251 has molecular weight 527.643Dalton which is not
desirable according to Lipinski’s rule of five [14].
International Journal of Pharmacy and Pharmaceutical Sciences
ISSN- 0975-1491 Vol 8, Issue 7, 2016