International Journal of Current Engineering and Technology E-ISSN 2277 – 4106, P-ISSN 2347 – 5161
©2018 INPRESSCO
®
, All Rights Reserved Available at http://inpressco.com/category/ijcet
Research Article
313| International Journal of Current Engineering and Technology, Vol.8, No.2 (March/April 2018)
New Methods to Resisting Punching Shear Stress in Reinforced
Concrete Flat Slabs
Fatma M. Eid
#*
, Tayel Magdy
^
and Ebada Ahmed^
#
Civil Engineering Department, Faculty of Engineering, Menoufia University, Shebein Alkom, Egypt
Received 01 Feb 2018, Accepted 01 April 2018, Available online 02 April 2018, Vol.8, No.2 (March/April 2018)
Abstract
Punching shear failure is a major problem encountered in the design of reinforced concrete flat slabs. The utilization
of shear reinforcement via shear studs or other means has become a choice for improving the punching shear
capacity. In this study, a new alternative of reinforcement modalities were tested and demonstrated the effect of self-
compact concrete on the punching shear capacity, beside that compared between the difference codes to identify the
suitable one for determining the position of critical section of punching shear. Nevertheless, in this investigation, the
proposed reinforcement system is examined for interior columns only. An experimental work consisting of six
specimens: five of them were cast with normal reinforced concrete and one was cast with self-compact strength
concrete. The obtained results indicate that the proposed shear reinforcement system has a positive effect in the
enhancement of the punching shear capacity of interior slab–column connection of self-compact strength concrete.
Keywords: Flat slab; Punching shear; Crack pattern; Ductility; Self-compact concrete.
Introduction
1
Punching shear is a critical design factor of reinforced
concrete flat slabs since it is associated with brittle
failure. The punching shear strength and deformation
capacity are strongly influenced by the type and
characteristics of the shear reinforcing system. Ruiz
and (Muttoni et al, 2010) carried out a series of a six
full scale slab tests (3.0 x 3.0 x 0.25 m) with the same
flexural and shear reinforcing ratio. The slabs were
different punching shear reinforcing systems; e.g.,
separated stirrups, continuous stirrups, bonded
reinforcement with anchorage plates, vertical studs
and inclined studs. The improvement in punching
shear strength and ductility as a result of these systems
increased with the same order as they have been
mentioned, with the vertical and inclined studs giving
the best results; 77% and 119% improvement,
respectively. Bent-up bars also improve the punching
shear strength and deformation capacity as reported
by (Tassinari et al, 2011). (Lips et al, 2012; Muttoni et
al 2010) demonstrated the positive effect of both shear
studs and continuous stirrups on the punching shear
strength and deformation capacity of slab–column
connection. The same conclusion was achieved by
(Pilakoutas et al, 2003) for inclined shear band
reinforcement. The shear strength is proportional to
the flexural reinforcement ratio; in contrast, the
rotation capacity is inversely proportional to the
*Correponding author’s ORCID ID:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.14741/ijcet/v.8.2.19
flexural reinforcement (Kinnunen et al, 1960). This
study explored the possibility of enhancing the
punching shear strength by introducing horizontal
mesh reinforcement at the middle of the depth of slab–
column connection zone. This reinforcement
arrangement is easy to apply and economic in
comparison with the other reinforcement types.
(Kueres et al, 2017) evaluated the punching shear
design provisions according to Eurocode 2 by means of
comparisons with test results.
To verify the changes in the current design
provisions, the new design method was evaluated
using large databanks for flat slabs and column bases
without and with shear reinforcement as well as
systematic test series. The evaluation of the large
databanks indicates a well-balanced level of safety of
the proposed design method for all investigated types
of members. (Mabrouk et al, 2017) asses the
contribution of horizontal flexural reinforcement and
vertical shear reinforcement on the punching behavior
of reinforced concrete flat slabs. The result from this
study showed that the failure of all the tested
specimens was a brittle punching failure, adding
vertical shear reinforcement in the form of stirrups
improved the punching capacity of the slabs, increasing
the width of stirrups caused a slight increase in the
punching strength, also as the flexural reinforcement
ratio was increased, the punching capacity was
increased. Finally the current Egyptian code is more
conservative than the ACI code in estimating the
punching shear capacity.