Tailoring Carbon Nanotube N‑Dopants while Designing Metal-Free
Electrocatalysts for the Oxygen Reduction Reaction in Alkaline
Medium
Giulia Tuci,
†
Claudio Zafferoni,
‡
Primiano D’Ambrosio,
†
Stefano Caporali,
‡
Matteo Ceppatelli,
†,§
Andrea Rossin,
†
Theodoros Tsoufis,
†
Massimo Innocenti,*
,†,‡
and Giuliano Giambastiani*
,†
†
Institute of Chemistry of OrganoMetallic Compounds, ICCOM-CNR and INSTM Consortium, 50019 Sesto F.no, Florence, Italy
‡
Department of Chemistry, University of Florence, 50019 Sesto F.no, Florence, Italy
§
LENS - European Laboratory for Nonlinear Spectroscopy, 50019 Sesto F.no, Italy
* S Supporting Information
ABSTRACT: A straightforward, energy- and atom-saving process to
the production of tailored N-doped and catalytically active metal-free
carbon nanostructures, has been set up. Our ex situ approach to the
N-decoration of the carbon nanotube sidewalls contributes to
elucidate the complex structure-reactivity relationship of N-doped
carbon nanomaterials in oxygen reduction reactions, providing
fundamental insights on the nature of the N-active sites as well as
on the role of neighboring carbons.
KEYWORDS: ex situ N-doping, doped carbon nanotubes, aryl-diazonium salt chemistry, electrocatalysts,
oxygen reduction reaction (ORR)
I
ntensive research efforts have been devoted in the past few
years to the development of efficient, durable, and
inexpensive alternatives to precious-metal-based electrocatalysts
(typically containing Pt and its alloys) for the oxygen reduction
reaction (ORR) in fuel cell (FC) cathodes.
1
Typically, the ORR
can proceed either through a four-electron process to combine
oxygen with electrons and protons into water as the final
product or through a less efficient two-step, two-electron
pathway involving the formation of the hydroperoxide ions as
intermediates.
1
On this basis, nitrogen-doped 1D and 2D
carbon nanomaterials (occasionally combined with non-noble
metal nanoparticles) have recently emerged as valuable
candidates capable of promoting this reaction efficiently.
2
It is
generally accepted that N-doped carbon nanostructures can
favor the surface O
2
chemisorption/activation improving their
catalytic performance in the ORRs remarkably.
2a,3
Although a relatively high number of N-doped carbon
nanostructures showing catalytic activity in ORRs have been
prepared by the in situ CVD approach,
2
much less work has
been done for the obtainment of catalytically active N-
decorated carbon nanomaterials using milder and easily tunable
ex situ (exohedral) organic functionalization techniques. The
latter imply a number of important issues whose achievement
may represent a real breakthrough in the development of novel
nanostructured, metal-free catalysts. Indeed, in addition to
leading to a fine-tuning of the chemical identity of the N-
dopants, an ex situ approach better matches the requirements
for energy- and atom-saving processes than the classical CVD
approach. In addition, N-dopants are entirely present at the
nanotube surface, where the catalytic process takes place.
Finally, an ex situ approach can contribute to answering the
widely debated question related to the intrinsic ability of
different N-containing groups, randomly embedded in the sp
2
CNT network, at promoting ORRs.
4
Although the real nature of the active sites in N-doped
carbon nanomaterials still remains unclear, it is generally
accepted that pyridine and pyrrole nitrogen atoms contribute
differently to the ORR, the former playing a key role in
promoting the process.
4
In this regard, a puzzling question
arises: What is the effect of the neighboring atomic environ-
ment on the ability of pyridine nitrogen atoms to promote
ORR? To answer this question, we took advantage of the well
consolidated aryldiazonium salt (Tour) functionalization
protocol
5
as a convenient synthetic methodology for the ex
situ N-doping of MWCNTs with pyridine- and pyrrole-
containing dangling groups (Scheme 1).
As shown in Scheme 1, 4-aminopyridine (1), 9-amino-
acridine (3), and 3-aminocarbazole (5) are selected as N-
containing candidates, 3 and 5 being selected as mimics of
pyridine and pyrrole frameworks, respectively, embedded in a
conjugated Csp
2
network. All reactions proceed smoothly
under mild conditions, providing the expected functionalized
samples 2, 4, and 6. Careful workup procedures and parallel
blank tests (carried out in the absence of the isopentylnitrite
reagent) have been used to rule out any possible reagent
Received: May 22, 2013
Revised: July 17, 2013
Letter
pubs.acs.org/acscatalysis
© XXXX American Chemical Society 2108 dx.doi.org/10.1021/cs400379h | ACS Catal. 2013, 3, 2108-2111