Succeeding with Building Information Modeling: A Case Study of BIM
Diffusion in a Healthcare Construction Project
Christoph Merschbrock
University of Agder
Norway
christoph.merschbrock@uia.no
Bjørn Erik Munkvold
University of Agder
Norway
bjorn.e.munkvold@uia.no
Abstract
Technological innovations such as Building
Information Modeling (BIM) offer opportunities to
improve collaborative work and integration in the
architecture, engineering and construction industry.
However, research to date has documented how many
organizations struggle with how to work based on this
new technology, and many implementations fail. In this
paper we present a case study of a major healthcare
construction project in which the use of BIM was
paramount, and where designers claim to have
succeeded in integrated design. The designers
organized their digital collaboration by establishing 1)
change agents; 2) a cloud computing infrastructure; 3)
new roles and responsibilities; 4) BIM contracts; 5) an
IS learning environment; and 6) by involving software
developers. These factors have been identified as
influential for the successful diffusion of BIM in this
project, and may serve as an example for
implementation of BIM in other projects for supporting
integrated design.
1. Introduction
Today’s major construction projects could not be
completed at the necessary speed without the use of
advanced Information Systems (IS). Especially,
Building Information Modeling (BIM) solutions have
proven their value for construction design. BIM is both
a new technology and a new way of working providing
a common environment for all information defining a
building, facility or asset, together with its common
parts and activities [29]. Leading architectural and
engineering firms use BIM to collaboratively develop
virtual ‘prototypes’ of buildings before they are built
[14,19]. When used properly, BIM can aid the
architecture, engineering and construction (AEC)
industry to become a more innovative sector of the
economy [5,6].
Construction designers wanting to use BIM in their
project need to develop new processes for their
collaborative work [15], and many of today’s
construction firms hesitate to undertake the necessary
organizational changes [24]. Even when firms seek to
establish a collaborative environment in their projects,
a variety of individual, environmental and
technological challenges prove to be difficult to
overcome [9,14,30]. Consequently, many firms
continue to work in ‘siloed’ environments instead of
encouraging a more collaborative culture. Thus, many
of the crucial advantages of collaborative BIM design
remain unexplored in wider practice [15].
Recognizing that only a few leading firms
collaborate effectively based on BIM technology,
recent R&D outlook publications by institutions such
as the Council for Research and Innovation in Building
and Construction (CIB) argue for the need to further
define collaborative processes between the actors in
design [7]. This is echoed by literature reviews arguing
for the need to strengthen the research on the inter-
organizational work surrounding the modeling activity
[20,32]. We contribute to this discussion by inquiring
into the reasons for why some AEC firms succeed in
their collaborative work while others fail. The research
question guiding our work is:
How can individual, environmental, managerial
and technological challenges be addressed to achieve
improved design collaboration through the use of
BIM?
The article presents a case study of advanced BIM-
based collaboration in a major healthcare construction
project in Norway. The desired outcome of the
collaborative BIM work was to create “[the] biggest,
most complete and best digital model in the world.”
(BIM manager client)
We present the findings of a series of interviews
conducted with the key players in the design team in
order to understand how they approached their work.
Diffusion of Innovations (DOI) theory [31] serves as a
starting point for our analysis of the factors leading to
collaboration. The case study approach applied in this
study allowed for operationalizing diffusion factors
presented in prior work in the empirical setting of a
construction project [26], and for building practical and
conceptual knowledge about BIM’s diffusion as a
collaborative system useful for other projects [8].
2014 47th Hawaii International Conference on System Science
978-1-4799-2504-9/14 $31.00 © 2014 IEEE
DOI 10.1109/HICSS.2014.490
3959