196 / SEPTEMBER–OCTOBER 2017, VOL. 62, NO. 5
1
Corresponding author. Tel: +2758-3073439; Fax: +2758-3073518; E-mail: lindequerc@arc.agric.za
http://dx.doi.org/10.1094/CFW-62-5-0196
©2017 AACC International, Inc.
Can Protein Quantity and Quality
Predict the Breadmaking Quality
of South African Wheat?
R. Lindeque
1
Agricultural Research Council–Small Grain
Bethlehem, South Africa
M. Labuschagne and A. van Biljon
University of the Free State
Bloemfontein, South Africa
T
he climates of the primary wheat production regions of
South Africa are diverse, and each requires specific produc-
tion practices for sustainable wheat production (Fig. 1). In the
irrigated wheat region (IRR), wheat is produced under center-
pivot irrigators along the Oranje and Crocodile Rivers in the
moderate to warmer northern areas of South Africa. Production
consists of spring-type wheat varieties seeded at high densities,
with a total of 280 kg of N ha
–1
split between 160 kg of N at
seeding, 60 kg of N between tillering and stem elongation, and
60 kg of N between flag leaf and anthesis. The central Free State
Province produces the majority of dryland wheat in the summer
rainfall region (Dryland SRR). Wheat produced in this region has
strong rheological qualities (15) that are attributed to high tem-
perature and rainfall conditions, which benefit winter- and inter-
mediate-type wheat varieties with longer growth periods. Low
seeding densities (25–30 kg ha
–1
) are applied with 60 kg of N ha
–1
during seeding (2). The critical rainfall period affecting grain
yield and quality in this region occurs shortly before anthesis
(Fig. 2) (12). Dryland wheat production in the winter rainfall
region (Dryland WRR), which has a Mediterranean-type cli-
mate, occurs in the Rûens and Swartland regions of Western
Cape Province. Spring-type wheat varieties are seeded with
≈130 kg of N ha
–1
split between 100 kg of N during seeding
and the remaining 30 kg of N applied between tillering and
stem elongation (3).
Complexities of the South African Wheat Industry
Commercial Bread Baking. Commercial bread baking in
South Africa has grown considerably since the 1960s with the
advent of use of the Chorleywood bread process (CBP) stem-
ming from the inclusion of South Africa in the British Common-
wealth. The primary advantage of the CBP is the use of lower
protein flours integrated with intensive, high-speed dough mix-
ing, which reduces fermentation time and results in a flour-to-
loaf rate of ≈3.5 hr. Weaker flours are generally less expensive,
and protein content is not considered a primary factor in deter-
mining the energy input level required for the CBP (5,6). With
implementation of free-market principles in the South African
wheat industry in the early 2000s, significant economic profits
became possible for the commercial bread baking industry due
to the availability of imported wheats that often had lower pro-
tein contents. Unfortunately, this left the door wide open for wheat
price manipulation, which has been detrimental to South Afri-
can wheat producers and the wheat industry in general.
Wheat Grain Yield and Flour Quality. A major misconcep-
tion among wheat farmers globally is that grain yield is the sole
factor responsible for long-term sustainability of wheat produc-
tion. The reality is that grain yield is only one of several param-
eters determining the price a farmer receives for a shipment of
wheat delivered to a storage silo. In South Africa three primary
parameters are used to determine the wheat grade after delivery:
hectoliter mass (kg hL
–1
), protein content (%), and falling num-
ber (sec). Protein content is an indicator of dough development
time and water absorption of flour but frequently is a poor pre-
dictor of baking quality. In a study on Swedish wheat, Fossati et
al. (8) recommend selection of genotypes with lower protein con-
Fig. 1. Rainfall patterns and primary wheat production regions in
South Africa.
Fig. 2. Dryland wheat production conditions in the northwestern Free
State Province of South Africa.