International Journal of Innovative Research in Advanced Engineering (IJIRAE) ISSN: 2349-2163
Volume 2 Issue 1 (January 2015 ) www.ijirae.com
_________________________________________________________________________________________________
© 2014, IJIRAE- All Rights Reserved Page - 67
Seismic Capacity of the Stone Masonry Lighthouse at
Paphos, Cyprus
Triantafyllos Makarios
*
Milton Demosthenous
Department of Civil Engineering Department of Civil Engineering
Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Greece Frederick University, Cyprus
Abstract—This paper deals with the evaluation of the seismic capacity of a stone masonry lighthouse at Paphos in
Cyprus using various levels of earthquake actions, according to seismic performance-based procedure that has been
proposed by Eurocode EN 1998. Two-dimensional shell finite elements with suitable strength were used for the
simulation of this lighthouse. In order to obtain an evaluation of the envelope of the stresses and the displacements of
the lighthouse under strong earthquake excitations, a number of models were examined. In order to estimate the
seismic response of this special case of lighthouse, the linear response history analysis and the response spectrum
analysis have been considered as the most suitable procedures for use, because the using of various non-linearity (and
plasticity) 2D-shell elements often lead to doubt results. It is worthy note that the strain-state of the structure is
defined by the simultaneously two principal normal stresses on the shell elements and for this reason a suitable failure
criterion has to introduce. One such failure criterion is the known Von-Misses failure criterion that has been
introduced to calculate the response numerical results. Finally, by the evaluation of these results, the vulnerability of
this lighthouse is studied under various levels of earthquake excitations.
Keywords— Lighthouse at Paphos, IYALA, Stone Masonry Structure, Von Misses failure criterion for stone masonry
wall, Microzonation Study of the Paphos
I. INTRODUCTION
From the ancient era until now, the major part of the communication and the trade were taking place both via sea. For
leading of ships, particularly during the night, it was common to set fires to coastlines. Such references exist from
Homer’s ancient era. According to historical evidences, the first torch-tower built by Ptolemy at island Pharos, opposite
to Alexandria town in Egypt, about 280-247 BC, and for this reason it was called “Lighthouse of Alexandria” or in
ancient Greek “Pharos of Alexandria”. This lighthouse was one of the Seven Wonders of the ancient World, while its
traces had been lost by 1300 AD. Afterwards of the construction of the “Lighthouse of Alexandria”, many others
lighthouses have been built until nowadays, which were called “Pharos” in various languages (Pharos, Phare, etc). From
the structural point of view, lighthouses are classified in the two following categories: (a) Independent lighthouses, which
have circular or rectangular cross-section reduced in elevation gradually. Inside, these lighthouses possess a stone or a
metal staircase that leads to upper part of the lighthouse. External, the aforementioned lighthouses possess small
windows. At the upper part of these lighthouses, a metal canopy that is filled with pane, where inside the mechanism of
flame or shine has been protected. (b) Lighthouses where are connected (along one horizontal direction) with a single-
storey (or a two-storey more rarely) stone masonry building or other stone masonry walls; thus, from this point of view,
these lighthouses do not consider as independent structures, since consist of a structural set of structures (lighthouses
with adjacent buildings and the stone masonry walls). It is worth noting that, the lighthouse-keepers stayed into these
buildings and they care for the continuous operation of the lighthouse, as well as the preservation of all structural groups.
During the last thirty years, automatic systems have been inserted gradually into lighthouses to operate them, so
employers at lighthouses have been stopped to employ, in the majority of those. Simultaneously, the support of these
automatic systems was not frequent, as was in the past; thus an accumulation of attritions and damages are appeared
today. Besides the inserting of various electronic systems in the field of navigation (such as GPS etc), where the
importance of the lighthouses has been reduced gradually, the international organization IYALA, which protects the
international network of lighthouses, decided that all lighthouses have to remain at full operation under care by the
national countries. Moreover, lighthouses with their buildings should be exploited for various others activities such
shelter, observation station, guest-house, area of cultural events etc. Therefore, important relevant actions have been
taken place in the frame of the European Research Program, entitled “Holistic Strategy for the Restoration, Preservation
and Integration in the life of the modern societies of Old European Masonry Lighthouses – PHAROS (2004-2007)”,
which is placed between the Culture/2000 [1]. Indeed, an international attempt for the systematic study (marking of
various problems, structural pathology/integrity of lighthouses, proposals for preservation and strengthening/retrofit) of
the European lighthouses has been developed recently, where five European countries have been participated into the
above-mentioned research program; Greece, Cyprus, Italy, Great Britain and Norway.
Into the frame of the abovementioned research program, the present paper deals with the evaluation of the seismic
capacity of the Lighthouse of Paphos in Cyprus. This lighthouse is an independent structure, without connection with
others adjacent buildings or stone masonry walls. In order to collect the necessary information and characteristics about
the construction of this lighthouse, many local/personal inspections had been taken place by authors and other
collaborators [2].