Copyright © IFAC 12th Triennial World Congress.
Sydney. Australja. 1993
GENERATION OF OPTIMAL STRUCTURED RESIDUALS IN
THE PARITY SPACE
M. Staroswleckl, J.P. Cassar and V. Cocquempot
LAIL URA 1440D. llniversiti des Sciences et Technologies tU Lille. 59655 Villeneuve d'Ascq Cedex, France
ABSTRACT
This paper proposes an approach for the
improvement of the performances of
Failure Detection and Isolation (FDI) sys-
tems.
Structural speci ficat ions of the expected
results lead to optimize the robustness of
the system with respect to the modelling
uncertainties and unknown inputs. Most
of the solutions of this optimization
problem have been developed through
the transformation of an observer - based
or a parity space approach.
We show in this paper how the parity
space approach allows the di rect
generation of residuals which respond to
the given speci fications.
KEYWORDS:
Fault detection and isolation; muIticrite-
ria optimization; robustness; sensitivity.
I - INTRODUCTION
Modern indutrial plants become more and
more complex and as a consequence more
and more sensitive to failures. Component
failures may degrade the overall system
performances and have serious
consequences on the security. Thus, it
becomes important to detect quickly and
accurately any occurence of a failure and
to identify its nature. This is the aim of
the Failure Detection and Isolation (FOI)
systems, whose design becomes a
necessary complement to the design of
the control algorithms .
The classical FDI system scheme [11 makes
appear a characterization and a decision
step.
Using a model based method [21[31[41. the
first step generates a set of residuals
which express the di fference between
the information provided by the system
and that delivered by its model in normal
operation. Then, the residuals
characterize the system's operating mode:
535
close to zero in normal operation, diffe-
rent from zero in faulty situations.
Whatever the approach used to generate
the residuals from a linear state space re-
presentation, their values will be func-
tions of the system's failures, but also of
the measurement noises, unknown inputs
and modelling errors.
The aim of the decision procedure is to
decide, from the residuals values, whe-
ther the no fault hypothesis may be for-
mulated or not.
In order to insure a minimal false alarm
rate, the residuals have to be robust
whith respect to unknown inputs and
modelling uncertainties. In order to in-
sure better detection conditions, they
have to be sensitive whith respect to fai-
lures [2][5J.
Isolation considerations lead to add
structural constraints [6][7] on each resi-
dual in order to insure that each faulty
element can be identified from the set of
residuals. The structural specifications
associate the detection conditions of two
sets of residual deviations causes [8][9]:
the first set includes the elements whose
failures must be detected and the second
set the modelling errors and the elements
which must weakly influence the results.
For a given residual, the robustness
concept is thus extended to failures whose
occurence must not affect its value.
Classical approaches to robustness lead to
create residuals which are insensitive to
the unknown inputs. This insensitivity is
geometricaly traduced by orthogonality
conditions which are obtained by the de-
sign of specific observers (unknown in-
put observer, or eigenvalue assignement
methods [10]) or by structural approaches
[Ill. In all cases, that leads to a decrease
of the number of design parameters,
since the orthogonality condition creates
links between them . For some cases, no
solution can be found, or the sensitivity
of the obtained residuals to failures may
be low.