366 n www.ajmc.com n MAY 2014
CLINICAL
© Managed Care &
Healthcare Communications, LLC
T
he 5-year survival rate for patients with melanoma
detected at the earliest stages is approximately
95%,
1
but falls precipitously to 15% for patients di-
agnosed with metastatic disease.
2
Melanoma also places a
signifcant economic burden on society and patients.
3
The
estimated annual cost of melanoma care in the United States
is $249 million and the average lifetime disease-associated
cost for a patient from the time of diagnosis with melanoma
until death is approximately $28,210.
3
Furthermore, 40% of
the annual cost is attributed to stage 4 melanoma, which
includes only around 3% of melanoma patients.
3
Since stage 4 melanoma is rarely curable, most medical
treatment for these patients—including surgery, radiation
therapy, chemotherapy, and biologic therapy—is prescribed
with limited expectations for long-term survival, and often
with palliative intent. Increasingly, hospice care has become
an acceptable alternative for patients with metastatic cancer.
Hospices provide the necessary care, pain management, and
emotional support to provide a comfortable end-of-life experi-
ence. The use of hospice also likely results in a decrease in uti-
lization of surgery, radiation therapy, and chemotherapy,
4
thus
likely leading to a decrease in medical costs, although this has
not been studied among patients with metastatic melanoma.
Other investigators have shown that hospice utilization does
not result in shortened survival for other terminal illnesses
such as advanced lung cancer and pancreatic cancer.
5,6
How-
ever, no studies have examined whether survival is reduced
when patients elect hospice care for metastatic melanoma.
Our goal is to examine the associations of use of hospice care
with survival and costs among patients with metastatic mela-
noma and to analyze the cost-efectiveness for diferent dura-
tions of hospice care in patients with this disease.
METHODS
Data Source and Cohort Definition
We conducted this study using data from the National
Cancer Institute’s Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Re-
Survival and Cost-Efectiveness of Hospice Care
for Metastatic Melanoma Patients
Jinhai Huo, PhD, MD, MPH; David R. Lairson, PhD; Xianglin L. Du, MD, PhD; Wenyaw Chan, PhD;
Thomas A. Buchholz, MD; and B. Ashleigh Guadagnolo, MD, MPH
Objectives
We analyzed the association of hospice use with survival and
healthcare costs among patients diagnosed with metastatic
melanoma.
Methods
We used the Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results (SEER)-
Medicare-linked databases to identify patients 65 years or older
with metastatic melanoma who died between 2000 and 2009. We
analyzed claims data to ascertain cancer treatment utilization and
costs. Survival, end-of-life costs, and incremental cost-effective-
ness ratio were evaluated using propensity score methods. Costs
were analyzed from the payer perspective in 2009 dollars.
Results
Of 862 patients, 225 (26%) received no hospice care, 523 (61%)
received 1 to 3 days of hospice care, and 114 (13%) received 4
or more days of hospice care. The median survival time was 6.1
months for patients with no hospice care, 6.5 months for patients
enrolled in hospice for 1 to 3 days, and 10.2 months for patients
enrolled for 4 or more days (P <.001). The hazard ratio for survival
among patients with 4 or more days of hospice use was 0.66;
95% confidence interval, 0.54-0.81, P <.0001 in the propensity
score–matched model. Patients with 4 or more days of hospice
care incurred lower end-of-life costs than the comparison groups
($14,594 vs $22,647 for the 1-to-3-days hospice care, and $28,923
for patients with no hospice care; P <.0001).
Conclusions
Patients diagnosed with metastatic melanoma who enrolled in 4
or more days of hospice care had longer survival than those who
had 1 to 3 days of hospice or no hospice care, and this longer
overall survival was accompanied by lower end-of-life costs.
Am J Manag Care. 2014;20(5):366-373