J. Basic. Appl. Sci. Res., 2(9)9616-9625, 2012
© 2012, TextRoad Publication
ISSN 2090-4304
Journal of Basic and Applied
Scientific Research
www.textroad.com
*Corresponding Author: Kamal Miandari, Department of Management, Payam Noor University, 19395-3697 Tehran, Iran
Designing a Model for Pathology of Personnel Performance Appraisal in
Zanjan Bureaucracies
Kamal Miandari
1
, Mehdi Ajalli
2
, Bahareh Mohammadi
3
1
Department of Management, Payam Noor University, 19395-3697 Tehran, Iran
2
Department of Accounting, Zanjan Branch, Islamic Azad University, Zanjan, Iran
3
M.A in MBA of Department of Management, University of Tehran, Kish International Campus, Kish, Iran
ABSTRACT
Performance appraisal is base of management decision making in bureaucratic system. The present essay is
attempting to distinguish effectual and under affection variables in performance system.
The research method is data gathering method is a combination of questionnaire and library methods. The
results of the research shows that effectual variables are appraiser characteristics, who will be appraisal errors,
performance appraisal criteria, performance appraisal techniques, performance appraisal interview,
communications, instrumentality, Organizational culture, and environmental factors. Under affection variables
are: compensation system, designation of training needs, employee transitions and promotions, employment
equity, and employee motivation. The final model concluded from library and theoretical studies and second
part is conclude from correlation analysis and .
KEY WORDS: Pathology of performance appraisal, Effectual variables, Under affection variables,
comprehensive model of performance appraisal, Personnel performance appraisal system.
1. INTRODUCTION
Today, the management field has become very important due to its universal applications in advancement
of societies. Managers, as the directors of organizations, must be perfectly familiar with scientific and applied
techniques in management and learn skills in this field. With a wide range of the related branches, management
also includes the management of human resources that has been improved a lot in promotion of organizational
members and plays roles in this context. Research about the causes and shortcomings resulted from the
deficiency of appraisal and using human resources management correctly in solving failures of the organizations
has become very important today and it is refereed to as "pathology of human resources management". For
survival and growth of any set including an organization, it is necessary to identify the weaknesses and the
negative effects of its activity, and for eliminating its ineffectiveness, serious actions must be taken. Expedient
examination of the damages of human resources management can play an important role for optimizing the
activity of this unit and prepare it for an effective emergence in the organization. The staff appraisal system in
human resources management is so important, that it can make an organization fail or succeed. A correct and
effective appraisal of the staff is very important in encouraging qualified people and punishment of those not
paying enough attention to the affairs. The appraisal system has its specific techniques, purposes and
characteristics in any organization that have a high effect on the performance of the staff in achieving a
comprehensive appraisal system. One of the ways for economic, social and cultural development and
independency of any society is the governance of a comprehensive appraisal system in administrative
organizations, i.e. if in examining the performance of the staff and promoting them, correct and comprehensive
criteria are used, an administrative efficiency will be surely obtained in the whole country.
In summary, we can say that this research will emphasize on this point that which variables affect on
planning a comprehensive valuation system. Of course, these variables are considered after pathology, i.e.
examining which variables can prevent one from achieving a comprehensive appraisal system and what can be
done to address the tasks of responsibilities of the managers of human resources and directing applied
researches toward it due to its importance in achieving a comprehensive appraisal system. As Vankata [20]
stated [20], the variables effective in performance appraisal must be examined and this can be done from inter-
organizational dimensions including organizational texture and from dimensions outside of the organization
including the culture and expedient factors.
2. Problem description and the importance of the subject
Due to the increasing necessity of addressing the human resources management, examining the criteria
effective in specialized staff is currently very important, especially managers of the organizations. Appraisal of
9616