Transactions of the ASABE
Vol. 56(1): 155-166 © 2013 American Society of Agricultural and Biological Engineers ISSN 2151-0032 155
THRESHOLDS FOR IRRIGATION MANAGEMENT OF
PROCESSING TOMATOES USING SOIL MOISTURE SENSORS
IN SOUTHWESTERN ONTARIO
F. Jaria, C. A. Madramootoo
ABSTRACT. Processing tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.) is an economically important vegetable crop in
southwestern Ontario. Processing tomato (cultivar H9553) fruit yield and quality were evaluated in field experiments in
southwestern Ontario over a three-year period (2008-2010). A split-plot randomized complete block design with four
blocks was used in 2008 and 2010. Irrigation types (buried and surface drip) served as the main plots, while four moisture
depletion levels constituted the split plots. In 2009, a 2×4 factorial complete randomized block design with four blocks
was used, with the same two factors. The moisture treatments represented the lower soil moisture triggers, which initiated
irrigation scheduling. Irrigation was terminated for each treatment when field capacity was reached. Continuous soil
moisture status over the growing season was monitored with a combination of volumetric and tensiometric sensors. Seven
fruit quality parameters were monitored: fruit weight, color, pH, size, firmness, Brix yield, and soluble solids. In each
year, the most stressed treatment produced the highest soluble solids (6.0, 4.8, and 5.2 °Brix for 2008, 2009, and 2010,
respectively). Total and marketable fruit yields ranged from 91.9 to 121.1 Mg ha
-1
and from 91.4 and 119.7 kg ha
-1
,
respectively. Statistical significance was obtained among treatments and irrigation types in 2008 only. Irrigation water use
efficiency was also not statistically significant over the three years. Seasonal irrigation depth ranged from 58 to 196 mm,
and statistical significance among the moisture treatments was obtained in 2008 and 2010.
Keywords. FDR, Irrigation scheduling, Irrigation thresholds, TDR.
griculture is a key driver for the Canadian
economy, providing one in seven jobs within the
country. The agri-food sector accounts for 8.3%
of Canada’s gross domestic product, USD $26.5
billion of which comes from exports and employing nearly
2.1 million persons (AAFC, 2006). Canadian vegetable
growers reported sales of USD $659 million in 2010, with
two provinces (Ontario and Quebec) accounting for more
than 80% of the vegetable sales (Statistics Canada, 2011).
Vegetable and dry bean production is a critical part of the
food and agriculture industry in Ontario. Virtually all of the
tomatoes grown in Canada for processing are produced in
Ontario, with the counties of Essex and Kent being the
main producing areas. In 2008, 0.62 million tons of
processing tomatoes were produced by 150 growers,
generating over USD $60.5 million (OHCRSC, 2006). In
most years, rainfall during the growing season is
insufficient to attain optimum production (Warner et al.,
2007). Tan et al. (2003) noted that, through the 1990s,
rainfall during the growing season decreased by about
25 mm year
-1
. The 30-year (1971 to 2000) climate normal
rainfall for Windsor and London averaged 254.3 and
251.3 mm, respectively. Over the growing season, an
average cultivar requires 400 mm of water (LeBoeuf et al.,
2007). Thus, intensive tomato production in these two
counties necessitates the use of supplemental irrigation to
offset the deficiencies in rainfall to maintain high levels of
production (Warner et al., 2007).
There is increasing pressure for more judicious
utilization of limited water resources to reduce negative
environmental impacts. Shock et al. (2001) identified
economic competition in marketing produce, competition
for water, and political pressure as the three forces to
minimize off-site impacts of irrigation-induced runoff and
leaching. It is desirable to optimize crop yield and quality
under the constraints of reducing water use and increasing
the efficiency of the use of agricultural chemicals.
Irrigation scheduling is a technique for timely and
accurately application of water to a crop and is key to
conserving water, improving irrigation performance, and
ensuring the sustainability of irrigated agriculture
(Thompson et al., 2007b). Several irrigation scheduling
methods based on water budget, soil, and plant indicators
have been used for different crops, with the water budget
method probably the most widely used technique (Fareres
et al., 2003). However, over the past decade, a new
generation of soil moisture sensors based on electrical
properties, such as resistance, capacitance, and time
Submitted for review in June 2012 as manuscript number SW 9792;
approved for publication by the Soil & Water Division of ASABE in
January 2013.
The authors are Felix Jaria, ASABE Member, Graduate Student, and
Chandra A. Madramootoo, Professor and Dean of Agricultural and
Environmental Sciences, Department of Bioresource Engineering,
McDonald Campus of McGill University, Ste. Anne de Bellevue, Quebec,
Canada. Corresponding author: Felix Jaria, Department of Bioresource
Engineering, McDonald Campus of McGill University, 21111 Lakeshore
Rd, Ste. Anne de Bellevue, Quebec, Canada H9X 3V9; e-mail:
felix.jaria@mail.mcgill.ca; phone: 514-398-8785.
A