© 2015 Wichtg Publishing
JVA
ISSN 1129-7298
J Vasc Access 2015; 16 (5): 367-371
Original article
Several studies over the last decade have confrmed that
antbiotc catheter lock solutons are efectve in reducing
the frequency of CRBSIs, but they may be associated with
bacterial antbiotc resistance (4-11). Ethanol is a prom-
ising catheter lock soluton, since it is an antseptc agent
that demonstrates bactericidal actvites against both gram-
positve and gram-negatve bacteria and fungal organisms.
It works by protein denaturaton and thus development of
resistance is not a concern (12). Its use as a sterilizing agent
for hemodialysis catheters was frst described in 2006 (13)
and a few studies since have evaluated the safety of such
a soluton on the mechanical integrity of diferent types of
peripheral and central lines. Since many dialysis patents
undergo treatment using the same catheter for months or
years, it is important to test the long-term efects of ethanol
on both silicone- and polyurethane-based catheters.
Crnich and colleagues evaluated 10 weeks of exposure
in both polyurethane and silicone catheters to 70% ethanol
in vitro. They suggested that both silicone-based and carb-
othane-based catheters can maintain integrity afer ethanol
DOI: 10.5301/jva.5000397
Efects of prolonged ethanol lock exposure to
carbothane- and silicone-based hemodialysis catheters:
a 26-week study
Daniel L. Landry
1,2
, Randa A. Jaber
1,2
, Nandheesha Hanumanthappa
1,2
, George S. Lipkowitz
1,2
, Michael H. O’Shea
1,2
,
Harry Bermudez
3
, Adam P. Hathorne
3
, Gregory L. Braden
1,2
1
Baystate Medical Center, Springfeld, MA - USA
2
Tufs University School of Medicine, Boston, MA - USA
3
University of Massachusets Polymer Science & Engineering, Amherst, MA - USA
Introducton
Central venous catheters (CVCs) remain the “Achilles heel”
of hemodialysis, and are used in the majority of patents ini-
tatng hemodialysis (1). However, vascular catheters remain
potental sources of catheter-related bloodstream infectons
(CRBSIs) and are associated with a 2- to 3-fold increased risk
in mortality, and a 10- to 20-fold higher risk of bacteremia
when compared to fstulas (2, 3).
ABStRAct
Purpose: Antbiotc locks in catheter-dependent chronic hemodialysis patents reduce the rate of catheter-relat-
ed bloodstream infectons (CRBSIs), but may be associated with the development of resistant bacteria. Ethanol-
based catheter locks may provide a beter alternatve; however, there are limited data on the long-term integrity
of dialysis catheters exposed to ethanol.
Methods: We performed in vitro testng of two types of hemodialysis catheters—silicone (SLC) and carbothane
(CBT) based—with a 70% ethanol lock (EL) versus heparin lock (HL) for 26 weeks. Lock solutons were changed
thrice weekly to mimic a conventonal hemodialysis schedule. We tested mechanical propertes of the catheters
at 0, 13 and 26 weeks by examining stress/strain relatonships (SS400%) and modulus of elastcity (ME). Electron
microscopy was performed to examine catheter ultrastructure at 0 and 26 weeks.
Results: Catheter integrity for HL versus EL in SLC (SS400%: 4.5 vs. 4.5 MPa, p = NS; ME: 4.6 vs. 4.7 MPa, p = NS)
or CBT-based catheters (SS400%: 7.6 vs. 8.9 MPa, p = NS; ME: 9.6 vs. 12.2 MPa, p = NS) were all similar at 13 and
26 weeks. Scanning electron microscopy revealed no structural changes in the central and luminal wall internal
surfaces of EL- versus HL-treated catheters.
conclusions: There were no signifcant diferences in catheter integrity between SLC or CBT catheters exposed
to a 70% EL for 26 weeks. Given its low cost, potental to avoid antbiotc resistance and structural integrity afer
6 months of high-dose ethanol, ELs should be studied prospectvely against antbiotc locks to assess the efcacy
and safety in hemodialysis patents.
Keywords: Catheters, Ethanol, Hemodialysis, Lock
Accepted: March 14, 2015
Published online: May 29, 2015
corresponding author:
Daniel L. Landry, DO
Division of Nephrology
Baystate Medical Center
759 Chestnut Street
Springfeld, MA 01107, USA
daniel.landry@bhs.org