Elastic critical moment of beams with sinusoidally corrugated webs
Gonçalo Correia Lopes, Carlos Couto ⁎, Paulo Vila Real, Nuno Lopes
RISCO, Department of Civil Engineering, University of Aveiro, Portugal
abstract article info
Article history:
Received 20 June 2016
Received in revised form 10 October 2016
Accepted 4 November 2016
Available online xxxx
This paper approaches the elastic critical moment of web-corrugated beams (WCB), either subjected to a uniform
bending moment, gradient bending moments, or a uniformly distributed load. Previous research on the subject of
lateral-torsional buckling (LTB) of WCB is presented and critically reviewed. Based on earlier studies on the cross-
section properties of beams with trapezoidal corrugations, a new method is proposed to obtain the warping or
torsional constant of WCB with sinusoidal corrugation. Furthermore, based on an extensive numerical study
for a wide range of different corrugation profiles and lengths, it is demonstrated that the present design formulae
for the moment modification factor for flat web beams (FWB) could be improved, in order to predict satisfactorily
the buckling capacities of WCB under non-uniform bending distributions. Therefore, a new closed-form expres-
sion for the moment modification factor is proposed and successfully verified. Finally, by comparing the analyt-
ical results with those obtained from a linear buckling analysis (LBA) carried out using shell finite elements, it is
demonstrated that the proposed modifications lead to an accurate prediction of the buckling strength of WCB.
© 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords:
Steel structures
Corrugated web beams
Lateral-torsional buckling
Elastic critical moment
1. Introduction
The use of web-corrugated beams (WCB) has been increasing con-
siderably during the last years for various structural applications, espe-
cially in industrial/commercial buildings and bridges, due to their high
load-carrying capacity in relation to the material usage. The major
asset of this structural solution lies in taking advantage of the increase
of rigidity provided by the corrugated web, that leads to an higher resis-
tance against local buckling and to an improved shear capacity, com-
bined with a weight reduction up to 30% [1], when compared to
beams with flat webs. Furthermore, due to their intrinsic properties, it
is possible to achieve adequate out-of-plane stiffness and lateral tor-
sional buckling (LTB) resistance without the need to increase the thick-
ness of the web plate [1] or the need to use additional transversal and/or
longitudinal stiffeners.
Since the first developments of WCB, especially in Germany and
Austria in the 1990's, a considerable number of researchers have per-
formed experimental, analytical and numerical studies on the behav-
iour of these beams under different loading conditions to investigate
their response against shear, bending and compressive patch loads.
Concerning the flexural and torsional behaviour of WCB, the most
cited studies could be summarized as follows; Elgaaly et al. [3], found
that the web could be neglected in the calculation of the bending resis-
tance and that the load-carrying capacity should be based on the flange
yield strength. Abbas et al. [4,5], stated that the flexural capacity of WCB
cannot be analysed by the conventional beam theory alone, since under
in-plane loading an additional torsional moment is produced resulting
in an out-of-plane twist simultaneously with the in-plane deflection.
Lindner [6], based on the study of the lateral-torsional behaviour of
these beams, has developed a formula to calculate the warping constant
of WCB, letting the remain cross-sectional constants considered equal to
those used for flat web beams (FWB). In the same publication, it was
concluded that, for such conditions, the interaction between local
plate buckling and overall LTB needs to be taken into account. Moon
et al. [7], have proposed approximated methods for locating the shear
centre and calculating the warping constant; Nguyen et al. [2,8] pro-
posed new general formulae for the cross-sectional properties (mo-
ments and product of inertia), also for locating the shear centre and to
calculate the warping constant, as well as for the determination of the
moment modification factors of WCB under moment gradients.
Since the corrugated web is not supposed to resist axial forces due to
the so-called accordion effect [7], WCB subjected to bending are de-
signed considering that only the flanges resist to the bending moment.
On the other hand, such beams have a considerably higher LTB capacity
than that of FWB, owing to an increased rigidity, which translates into a
higher elastic critical moment for lateral-torsional buckling, M
cr
. How-
ever, Eurocode 3 [9,10] does not provide information on how to com-
pute M
cr
, only stating that it should be based on the gross cross-
sectional properties and take into account the loading conditions, the
real moment distribution and the lateral restraints without further ref-
erence for WCB. Therefore, it is paramount to find an analytical expres-
sion to predict the buckling strength of WCB. In this context, the main
difference in the existing expressions to calculate M
cr
for I-beams with
flat webs, is the influence of the torsion and warping constants, which
Journal of Constructional Steel Research 129 (2017) 185–194
⁎ Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: gclopes@ua.pt (G. Correia Lopes), ccouto@ua.pt (C. Couto),
pvreal@ua.pt (P. Vila Real), nuno.lopes@ua.pt (N. Lopes).
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jcsr.2016.11.005
0143-974X/© 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Journal of Constructional Steel Research