Phonological vowel reduction in four Catalan varieties
Dylan Herrick
University of California, Santa Cruz
E-mail: herrick@ling.ucsc.edu
Figure (1)
ABSTRACT (a) Central Catalan (b) Western Catalan
Stressed Unstressed Stressed Unstressed
To test predictions made by theories of phonological vowel
reduction, we require quantitative data to verify and make
more precise impressionistic descriptions. Catalan, with
phonological vowel reduction in several regional varieties,
provides an ideal case study. This paper offers a
quantitative description of the stressed and corresponding
unstressed vowels of female speakers representing four
distinct regional varieties of Catalan – that of Berguedà
(representative of Central Catalan – the standard variety),
Lleida (Western Catalan), Girona (a northern variety), and
Palma (Balearic Catalan). Target vowels appeared in
nonsense words which were uttered within a carrier phrase.
The formant values for F1-F3 are reported here and
compared to impressionistic descriptions.
(c) Girona Catalan (d) Balearic Catalan
1. INTRODUCTION
Regional varieties of Catalan differ with respect to the
makeup of their stressed and unstressed vowel inventories.
Central Catalan allows seven vowels (/ /)
in stressed position and three vowels (/ /) in
unstressed position ([7], [8], [10]). The vowel inventories
of the other varieties are shown in figure (1) which also
indicates the mapping relationships between stressed and
unstressed vowels (based on diagrams and descriptions in
the work of Mascaró [7], [8], and Recasens [10]).
schwa in Central and Girona Catalan? Or are there
significant differences between [ ] which corresponds to
stressed [ ] or [ ] compared with [ ] which corresponds to
stressed [a]? In addition to descriptive questions such as
these, this study serves as the initial building block for a
larger research project ([4]) which aims to test for a
correlation between vocalic inventory size and position of
vowels within the vowel space (see also Adaptive
Dispersion Theory [5], [6]). The remainder of this paper
describes the methodology and results for a phonetic study
of Catalan vowels designed to verify impressionistic
descriptions and serve as a base for further inquiries into
phonological vowel reduction.
The Catalan varieties in figure (1) exhibit vowel reduction
in the phonological sense – the number of phonemes found
in unstressed position is reduced relative to the number of
vowel phonemes found in stressed position. Phonology has
no trouble describing vowel reduction, but it does have
trouble explaining it. Recent phonological models which
incorporate phonetic information directly into the theory
(such as Dispersion Theory [3], [9] as well as work by
Crosswhite [2] and Herrick [4]) have had greater
explanatory success compared with previous theories.
However, such phonetically based theories cannot be tested
without quantitative phonetic data. Thus, the primary goal
of this paper is to contribute quantitative data which can be
used to help develop and test a more phonetically oriented
theory of phonological vowel reduction. An additional
interest is verifying the extent to which the quantitative data
matches the phonological descriptions. How accurate are
the mapping relationships shown in figure (1)? For example,
do the unstressed versions of [ ] really converge on
2. METHODOLOGY
For each of the different regional varieties studied, three
native speakers were recorded uttering nonsense verbs
containing the stressed (and corresponding unstressed)
vowels of their variety. All recordings were made in
Catalonia, all speakers were female college students, and a
‘native’ was defined as someone who spoke Catalan as their
primary language and came from a family in which both
parents spoke primarily Catalan. For the recordings,
speakers were shown several verbs – one for each of the
vowels allowed in stressed position in their variety (seven
for Central and Western, six for Girona, and eight for
Balearic Catalan), and they were asked to conjugate each
15th ICPhS Barcelona
1679 ISBN 1-876346-48-5 © 2003 UAB