Evaluation of an Inexpensive Depth Camera for
Passive In-Home Fall Risk Assessment
Erik E. Stone
Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering
University of Missouri
Columbia, MO, USA
ees6c6@mizzou.edu
Marjorie Skubic
Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering
University of Missouri
Columbia, MO, USA
skubicm@missouri.edu
Abstract— We present an investigation of a new, inexpensive
depth camera device, the Microsoft Kinect, for passive fall risk
assessment in home environments. In order to allow older
adults to safely continue living in independent settings as they
age, the ability to assess their risk of falling, along with
detecting the early onset of illness and functional decline, is
essential. Daily measurements of temporal and spatial gait
parameters would greatly facilitate such an assessment. Ideally,
these measurements would be obtained passively, in normal
daily activity, without the need for wearable devices or
expensive equipment. In this work, we evaluate the use of the
inexpensive Microsoft Kinect for obtaining measurements of
temporal and spatial gait parameters as compared to an
existing web-camera based system, along with a Vicon motion
capture system for ground truth. We describe our techniques
for extracting gait parameters from the Kinect data, as well as
the advantages of the Kinect over the web-camera based system
for passive, in-home fall risk assessment.
I. INTRODUCTION
o allow older adults to continue living longer in
independent settings, and thus reduce the need for
expensive care facilities, low-cost systems are needed to
detect not only adverse events such as falls, but to assess the
risk of such events, in addition to the early onset of illness
and functional decline. Continuous, ongoing assessments of
physical function would help older adults live more safely in
independent settings, while also facilitating targeted medical
interventions when needed. Ideally, such measurements
would be obtained passively, in the course of normal daily
activity [1].
This work focuses on developing a robust, low-cost,
vision based monitoring system for assessing fall risk,
detecting falls, and detecting the early onset of illness and
functional decline. Research has shown the importance of
measuring a person’s gait, including identifying stride-to-
stride variability as a predictor of falls [2-4]. Vision based
monitoring systems have the resolution needed to yield the
detailed measurements of physical function necessary for
fall risk assessment (and early illness detection) passively, in
the home environment, on a continuous basis. Furthermore,
research has shown that the privacy concerns of older adults
to video based monitoring systems can be alleviated through
appropriate handling and processing of the video data, e.g.,
in the form of silhouettes [5].
Recently, Microsoft has released a new, inexpensive
device, called the Kinect, to allow controller free game play
on their Xbox system. The device uses a pattern of actively
emitted infrared light to produce a depth image (the value of
each pixel depends on the distance of what is being viewed
from the device) which is invariant to visible lighting; and,
thus, allows for a 3D representation using a single Kinect.
This technology offers a number of potential benefits for
low-cost, vision based monitoring systems.
This paper presents an investigation of the Kinect as a
sensor for fall risk assessment. Specifically, techniques for
acquiring spatial and temporal gait parameters from the
depth data of the Kinect are presented; along with a
comparison between the measurements obtained from the
Kinect, to those obtained from an existing web-camera based
system, and a Vicon marker based motion capture system.
II. BACKGROUND
Recent research in activity monitoring of older adults has
focused on the use of passive infrared (PIR) motion sensor
suites in the home [6-7]. These sensor suites yield
information about the daily activity levels of monitored
subjects, and arrays of such sensors have been used to obtain
velocity measurements on a continuous basis in home
settings [8]. While such systems don’t raise privacy concerns
among older adults, they typically do not produce
measurements of the detail necessary for assessment of fall
risk; specifically, spatial and temporal gait parameters (other
than walking speed), timed up and go (TUG) time, sit to
stand time, etc [9]. Existing systems for capturing such
measurements are typically wearable, accelerometer based
devices, expensive gait or motion capture systems, or direct
assessment by a health care professional [2].
Wearable accelerometer based devices for obtaining
detailed measurements of physical activity, specifically gait
parameters, is an area that has been the focus of much
research [10]. Efforts have even included utilizing
accelerometers in existing smart devices, which individual’s
may already own and potentially carry with them. However,
many elderly adults are reluctant to use wearable devices
because they consider them to be invasive or inconvenient
[1]. Thus, wearable devices may not be reliable for capturing
movement in the home for continuous monitoring and
T
PervasiveHealth 2011, May 23-26, Dublin, Republic of Ireland
Copyright © 2012 ICST
DOI 10.4108/icst.pervasivehealth.2011.246034