© Schattauer 2017 Methods Inf Med 2/2017
1 Review Articles
Assessing the Coverage of E-Health
Services in Sub-Saharan Africa
A Systematic Review and Analysis
Davies Adeloye
1,2
; Taiwo Adigun
3
; Sanjay Misra
3,4
; Nicholas Omoregbe
3
1
Demography and Social Statistics, and the e-Health Research Cluster, Covenant University, Ota, Nigeria;
2
Centre for Global Health Research, University of Edinburgh Medical School, Usher Institute, Edinburgh, UK;
3
Department of Computer and Information Sciences, Covenant University, Ota, Nigeria;
4
Department of Computer Engineering, Atilim University, Ankara, Turkey
Keywords
E-health, telemedicine, mhealth, sub-saha-
ran, africa
Summary
Background: E-Health has attracted grow-
ing interests globally. The relative lack of
facilities, skills, funds and information on
existing e-Health initiatives has affected
progress on e-Health in Africa.
Objectives: To review publicly available lit-
erature on e-Health in sub-Saharan Africa
(sSA) towards providing information on
existing and ongoing e-Health initiatives in
the region.
Methods: Searches of relevant literature
were conducted on Medline, EMBASE and
Global Health, with search dates set from
1990 to 2016. We included studies on
e-Health initiatives (prototypes, designs, or
completed projects) targeting population
groups in sSA.
Results: Our search returned 2322 hits, with
26 studies retained. Included studies were
conducted in 14 countries across the four
sub-regions in sSA (Central, East, South and
West) and spreading over a 12-year period,
2002–2014. Six types of e-Health interven-
tions were reported, with 17 studies (65 %)
based on telemedicine, followed by mHealth
with 5 studies (19 %). Other e-Health types
include expert system, electronic medical
records, e-mails, and online health module.
Specific medical specialties covered include
dermatology (19 %), pathology (12 %) and
radiology (8 %). Successes were ‘widely re-
ported’ (representing 50 % overall accept-
ance or positive feedbacks in a study) in 10
studies (38 %). The prominent challenges re-
ported were technical problems, poor inter-
net and connectivity, participants’ selection
biases, contextual issues, and lack of funds.
Conclusion: E-Health is evolving in sSA, but
with poorly published evidence. While we call
for more quality research in the region, it is
also important that population-wide policies
and on-going e-Health initiatives are contex-
tually feasible, acceptable, and sustainable.
Correspondence to:
Dr. Davies Adeloye
Demography and Social Statistics, and the e-Health
Research Cluster
Covenant University
Ota
Nigeria
E-mail: Davies.Adeloye@covenantuniversity.edu.ng
Methods Inf Med 2017; 56: ■■–■■
https://doi.org/10.3414/ME16-05-0012
received: November 9, 2016
accepted: January 7, 2017
epub ahead of print: ■■■
1. Introduction
Over the last two decades, increasing ef-
forts to effectively deploy information and
communication technologies (ICTs) in
health service delivery have been observed,
and attracted varying interests globally [1,
2]. A 2009 forecast suggested that e-Health
service, including digitalization of health
records and cloud applications, may in-
crease from 71 million to about 1 billion
subscribers in 2014 [3]. The European Net-
work and Information Security Agency
(ENISA) reported that ICT, incorporating
health records, data science and cloud
computing, was set to attract massive glo-
bal investment, with expenditure estimated
at US $44 billion in 2013 [4]. This has
relatively increased expectations of im-
proved quality, efficiency and effectiveness
of health information systems and health
care delivery in developing countries [5].
Health experts have emphasized the
growing importance of a comprehensive
e-Health system among the top needed
measures towards improving national
health systems [6]. This has further raised
awareness on the ‘big data’ approach to col-
lation and analysis of health data across
world countries, as a measure to bridge gap
between health care delivery, policy re-
sponse and population health outcomes [1,
7].
The introduction of e-Health services
has reportedly reduced health care costs
and increased efficiency of health service
delivery in many low- and middle-income
countries (LMICs), where weak govern-
ance, poor funding, and recurrent health
workforce crisis, among others, have been
major health system challenges [2]. Ac-
cording to Kgasi and Kalema, e-Health has
also relatively addressed prevailing in-
equalities in health care provision across
many LMICs, bridging the ‘urban versus
rural’, and ‘rich versus poor’ gaps, respect-
ively [8]. Following the 2005 World Health
Assembly (WHA) 58 resolution to imple-
ment e-Health systems globally, the World
Health Organization (WHO) has provided
technical support to member states, es-
pecially in the WHO African region, to as-
sist in the full implementation of e-Health