COCHRANE NURSING CARE CORNER
Summaries of Nursing Care-Related Systematic Reviews from the Cochrane Library
Interventions for treating anxiety after stroke
Question
The question that the review originally attempted to answer
is whether an intervention to treat for anxiety after stroke will
decrease the proportion of patients who suffer from these
co-morbid anxiety disorders after suffering a stroke. Further,
it wished to determine what effect such treatment would
have on the quality of life, disability, depression, social par-
ticipation, risk of death or caregiver burden experienced by
these patients. Because of the lack of studies that dealt solely
with anxiety, the review was expanded to include the
co-morbid conditions of depression and anxiety, instead of
just anxiety.
Relevance to nursing care
According to the review, stroke is the leading cause of adult
disability (age-adjusted prevalence of stroke ranges from
1.3% to 3.2% for Americans aged 20 and older).
1
Addition-
ally, following a physical stroke, 20% to 25% of stroke sur-
vivors will also suffer from one of several types of mental
anxiety. While there are several distinct types of anxiety
disorders (general anxiety disorder, panic disorder, social
phobia, obsessive compulsive disorder and post-traumatic
stress disorder), they do share several common characteris-
tics of excessive and irrational fear, subjective apprehension
and difficulty and distress in managing daily tasks. These
conditions can affect the patient even several years following
the initial stroke event. Whether in a stroke unit, in a reha-
bilitation setting or a medical/surgical unit following any
hospital readmission, a percentage of patients will be post-
stroke, and it is necessary to be aware of these likely
co-morbid conditions, and the most appropriate interven-
tion to employ to best aid the patient. When employing an
intervention, it is also necessary to be aware of and examine
the side effects and total benefits of the intervention. Side
effects of the studied medications included minor nausea or
stomach distension, dizziness, vomiting and heart palpita-
tions. Whether this Cochrane review will lead to any
changed interventions is questionable.
Study characteristics
Using the exclusion criteria, the reviewers were not able to
include any studies that solely looked at anxiety as a com-
plication of stroke. The only studies that they were able to
include in the review were of stroke with co-morbid condi-
tions of anxiety and depression. The intervention studied
was the use of any therapy, whether pharmacological, psy-
chological or complementary or alternative therapies. The
therapy’s primary purpose needed to be treatment of the
disorder or anxiety symptoms.
First, there were only two studies that met all of the
researchers’ criteria for evaluation; second, a total of only
175 patients were involved in the chosen studies; and finally,
neither of the two included studies used a study arm of
placebo intervention. Both studies used standard treatment
(routine treatment) as their common control arm. The
studies used the Hamilton Anxiety Scale (HAM-A) to assess
anxiety and the Hamilton Depression Scale (HAM-D) to
assess depression.
Both included studies were conducted in China. Neither
study article is indexed in the US MEDLINE database. The
search strategies used to find the articles are detailed in the
Appendices of the review. Significantly, the searches were
NOT limited to the English language. Extensive searches
were conducted, using trials register of the Cochrane Stroke
Group, CENTRAL, MEDLINE, EMBASE, PsycINFO, Allied and
Complementary Medicine Database (AMED), Cumulative
Index to Nursing and Allied Health (CINAHL), Proquest
Digital Dissertations and Psychological Database for Brain
Impairment Treatment Efficacy (PsycBITE). Database
searches ranged from a start date of 1806 to 2004, with an
end date of October 2010. Additional searches were con-
ducted using hand searching, networking, conference pro-
ceedings, expert reviews, etc. of published and unpublished
literature and sources.
This is a summary of a Cochrane Review. The full citation and the
names of the researchers who conducted the Review are listed in the
Reference section below.
doi:10.1111/j.1744-1609.2012.00259.x Int J Evid Based Healthc 2012; 10: 82–83
© 2012 The Author
International Journal of Evidence-Based Healthcare © 2012 The Joanna Briggs Institute