Finite-Size Effect and Wall Polarization
in a Carbon Nanotube Channel
Deyu Lu, Yan Li, Slava V. Rotkin,
†
Umberto Ravaioli, and Klaus Schulten*
Beckman Institute for AdVanced Science and Technology, UniVersity of Illinois at
Urbana Champaign, 405 N. Mathews, Urbana, Illinois 61801
Received September 4, 2004; Revised Manuscript Received October 7, 2004
ABSTRACT
The electronic structure and dielectric screening of finite-length armchair carbon nanotubes are studied in view of their technical applications.
For this purpose, a self-consistent tight-binding method, which captures the periodic oscillation pattern of the finite band gap as a function
of tube length, is applied. We find the parallel screening constant E
|
to grow nearly linearly with the length L and to show little dependence
on the band gap. In contrast, the perpendicular screening constant E
⊥
is strongly related to the band gap and converges for L > 10R (radius)
to its bulk value. Our description is employed to study the wall polarization in a short (6,6) nanotube filled with six water molecules, a
situation that arises with technical uses of carbon nanotubes as channels.
Single-walled carbon nanotubes (SWNTs) can be classified
as metallic, quasi-metallic, or semiconducting, depending on
how they are wrapped up from graphene layers.
1
When
SWNTs are shortened, their energy levels become quantized,
which makes them suitable for applications such as quantum
dots and single-electron transistors.
2
It has also been proposed
that the small size and stable structure make short SWNTs
good candidates for artificial nanoscale channels for transport
of water,
3-6
protons,
7,8
ions,
9
or polymers.
10
Recent experi-
ments using X-ray diffraction
11
and neutron scattering
12
provided insight into the properties of nanotube-confined
water. The observations revealed a chain of water molecules
wrapped by a shell of water, all encapsulated inside SWNTs
with diameter around 1.4 nm.
12
These experiments confirm
an earlier prediction that water can enter the hydrophobic
interior of narrow SWNTs.
3-6
From the modeling point of view, artificial SWNT
channels have been studied by means of molecular dynamics
(MD) simulations, focusing on both filling and transport
properties.
3-6
In the previous simulations, the interaction
between water and the SWNT was usually treated through
a short-range van der Waals potential, and little attention
was paid to the polarizable nature of the SWNT. Unlike many
biological channels, SWNTs are highly polarizable due to
their delocalized π-electrons, which respond strongly to
external fields. A study of screening effects of infinitely long
SWNTs to an external point charge impurity has revealed
that metallic nanotubes can effectively screen out the long-
range Coulomb potential along the axial direction, while
screening effects in semiconducting tubes are weaker.
13
Neglecting the polarization of SWNTs could be misleading
because the filling and transport properties of water are
sensitive to the water-SWNT interaction.
3
Therefore, knowl-
edge of the dielectric response of finite-size SWNTs is
essential for an understanding of water/ion/polymer perme-
ation and for designing efficient SWNT channels.
In recent studies,
7,8
density functional theory (DFT)
calculations have been carried out in MD simulations to take
into account the electronic degrees of freedom. However,
the finite-size effect on the dielectric response is not well
characterized in these studies, and further applications are
prohibited by the high computational cost. In this work, we
used a self-consistent tight-binding (TB) method to study
the electronic properties of finite-length armchair nanotubes
and observed how the screening behavior evolves from 0D
to 1D as the tube length increases. We believe that our
method can be efficiently combined with MD simulations
to investigate nanotube-based channels.
An infinitely long armchair nanotube is metallic, but a
HOMO (highest occupied molecular orbital)/LUMO (lowest
unoccupied molecular orbital) gap opens in finite-length
tubes. First principle results from different groups
2,14,15
agree
in that the gap oscillates as a function of tube length with a
period of three sections. Interestingly, the obtained gap
minima are nonzero, contrary to the prediction from TB
theory with only nearest neighbor interactions.
In the following we show that the period of oscillation
can be explained by imposing the quantum box boundary
condition and that the nonzero band gap minima can be
reproduced by including third-nearest-neighbor (NN) inter-
actions. For armchair SWNT segments with ideal geometry,
* Corresponding author. E-mail: kschulte@ks.uiuc.edu.
†
Present address: Department of Physics, Lehigh University, 16
Memorial Drive East, Bethlehem, PA 18015.
NANO
LETTERS
2004
Vol. 4, No. 12
2383-2387
10.1021/nl0485511 CCC: $27.50 © 2004 American Chemical Society
Published on Web 10/26/2004