Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Intermetallics
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/intermet
Oxidation mechanism of W substituted Mo-Si-B alloys
Tuba Karahan
a,1
, Gaoyuan Ouyang
b,c,1
, Pratik K. Ray
b,c,*
, M.J. Kramer
b,c
, Mufit Akinc
b,c
a
Department of Metallurgical and Materials Engineering, Gedik University, Istanbul, Turkey
b
Department of Materials Science and Engineering, Iowa State University, Ames, IA, USA
c
Ames Laboratory, USDOE, Ames, IA, USA
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Silicide
Transient oxidation
Glass
Silicate
Mo-Si-B
ABSTRACT
The oxidation mechanism of a Mo
55
W
15
Si
15
B
15
alloy was established, and the effects of W content, oxidation
temperature and microstructural length scale were determined. In addition to influencing the oxidation
mechanism, the addition of W also destabilized the A15 phase which is consistent with our previous experiments
in ternary Mo-W-Si alloys [1]. Microstructural investigation of the oxidized alloy revealed entrapped tungsten
oxides at temperatures below 1300 °C, which volatilize above 1400–1500 °C. The presence of WO
3
in the oxide
scale interrupts the surface coverage by the glassy borosilicate, thereby adversely affecting the oxidation
behavior. In order to determine the effects of length scale, the microstructural evolution during the transient
oxidation of cast and sintered alloys, with different microstructural length scales, was studied at 1100 and
1400 °C. Finer microstructure promoted faster borosilicate surface coverage at 1400 °C.
1. Introduction
Designing tough oxidation resistant refractory metal silicides is a
key technological challenge that needs to be overcomed in order to use
these alloys for high temperature structural applications. High tem-
perature oxidation behavior, mechanical properties and phase stability
of Mo-Si-B based alloys have been extensively investigated over the last
few decades [2–5]. However, no single alloy studied so far has
demonstrated a combination of strength, toughness and oxidation
resistance, which is essential for high temperature applications. This
is a result of the conundrum posed by the Mo-Si-B ternary phase
diagram. Alloys in the Mo-T2-A15 (Mo-Mo
5
SiB
2
-Mo
3
Si) phase field
show excellent fracture toughness [6] while alloys in the intermetallic
rich regions show good oxidation resistance. Ideally, an alloy compris-
ing of a Mo rich phase, the T1 phase and the T2 phase will offer a
combination of excellent fracture toughness due to the Mo rich solid
solution [7,8], creep resistance due to the presence of the T1 phase [9],
and oxidation resistance due to the presence of B doped T1 [10] as well
as the T2 [11] phases. The A15 phase, which lies between the metal rich
solid solution and the T1 phase neither affords significant oxidation
resistance [11], nor does it impart fracture toughness, as a result of only
four active slip systems at room temperature [12]. Therefore, it was
anticipated that the removal of the deleterious A15 phase will help in
forming the desired three-phase microstructure consisting of Mo rich
solid solution, the T1 phase and T2 phase.
The Mo
3
Si (A15) phase can be destabilized with controlled alloying
additions of Nb and W, as demonstrated by Ray et al. [1,13]. The
addition of elements such as Nb and W results in the Fermi surface
moving out of the pseudo-gap in the density of states, thereby creating
an electronic structure instability [1]. Furthermore, a multi-phase
assembly containing Nb or W is more stable than the single phase
A15 structure [13,14]. While the experiments and theoretical calcula-
tions reported in the literature were carried out in ternary systems,
without boron, it is expected that the addition of W will have a similar
effect on the alloy phase assemblage even in the presence of boron due
to its extremely low solubility in the A15 structure [15]. However,
while the removal of the brittle A15 phase through W substitutions is
expected to be beneficial for mechanical properties, the resulting effect
on oxidation has not been established. W substitutions could increase
the pesting range of the alloy at lower temperatures, resulting in poorer
oxidation resistance at lower temperatures (T < 1300 °C). However,
the removal of the A15 phase – which has poor oxidation resistance
[11] – results in the formation of the T1 phase, which has better
oxidation resistance [5]. This could conceivably improve the oxidation
resistance above the pesting regime. Hence, it is important to investi-
gate the oxidation behavior with W substitutions at different tempera-
tures – in the pesting regime, as well as above the pesting regime.
The oxidation behavior of Nb modified Mo-Si-B and Nb-Si-B alloys
have been extensively studied by a number of researchers [16–19].
Unlike Mo, which oxidizes to form a volatile MoO
3
, the oxidation of Nb
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.intermet.2017.04.005
Received 9 November 2016; Received in revised form 16 February 2017; Accepted 7 April 2017
*
Corresponding author. Department of Materials Science and Engineering, Iowa State University, Ames, IA, USA.
1
Equal first authors.
E-mail address: prat@iastate.edu (P.K. Ray).
Intermetallics 87 (2017) 38–44
0966-9795/ © 2017 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
MARK