JONA
Volume 49, Number 1, pp 42-47
Copyright B 2019 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved.
THE JOURNAL OF NURSING ADMINISTRATION
An Exploratory, Descriptive Study of
Nurse Leaders’ Personal and Work
Experiences During Union Negotiations
and Strike Events
Jaynelle F. Stichler, DNSc, RN, NEA-BC(r), FACHE, FAAN
Luc R. Pelletier, MSN, APRN, PMHCNS-BC, FAAN
Tanna Thomason, PhD, RN-BC, CNS
OBJECTIVE: This study explored the experiences,
perceptions and emotional state of nurse leaders
during union activities to understand the impact on
their personal and professional lives.
BACKGROUND: Other than anecdotal stories shared
during union negotiations and strike preparations,
very little evidence exists in nursing and healthcare
literature about nursing unions and their impact on
nurse leaders and their organizational priorities.
METHODS: This study used an exploratory, descrip-
tive design with a convenience and snowball sample of
Association of California Nurse Leaders members.
RESULTS: The findings indicate nurse leaders expe-
rience a range of emotional states in response to
union activities with perceptions of increased work-
load, job stress, and constrained and deliberate com-
munications with their staff.
CONCLUSION: This study adds to the body of
knowledge about nurse leader experiences and feel-
ings during union activities.
We know very little as to how union activities (nego-
tiations, strike preparations, or actual strikes) affect
the personal and professional experiences of nurse
leaders. Little evidence exists in nursing and health-
care literature about nursing unions and their impact
on patient outcomes, nurse leaders, Magnet
A
journeys
or designation, nurse satisfaction, or other relative
variables. Most articles regarding the union and pa-
tient, provider, or organizational outcomes have been
published in non-peer-reviewed, labor relations, or
union journals. Because of the paucity of previous liter-
ature on the topic, it seemed necessary to conduct an
exploratory study to describe how union activities affect
nurse leaders’ personal and professional work expe-
riences. The purpose of this study was to explore the
personal and professional experiences of nurse leaders
during union negotiations and strike preparations and
to understand the impact on lives of nurse leaders.
There were 2 research questions for the study: 1) What
are the perceptions of nurse leaders about union nego-
tiations, strike preparation, or actual strikes on personal,
professional, and organizational outcomes? And 2)
what is the effect of union negotiations and strike
preparations on nurse leaders in a healthcare system?
Review of the Literature
A literature search was conducted for the past 5 years
using PubMed, CINAHL, and Google Scholar search
42 JONA
Vol. 49, No. 1
January 2019
Author Affiliations: Consultant Research & Professional Devel-
opment (Dr Stichler), Center of Nursing Excellence Sharp HealthCare,
San Diego, California, and Coeditor, HERD Journal , Thousand
Oaks, California; Senior Specialist, Nursing (Mr Pelletier), Sharp
Mesa Vista Hospital, San Diego, California; Adjunct Faculty (Mr
Pelletier and Dr Thomason), University of San Diego Hahn School
of Nursing and Health Science, California; Core Adjunct Faculty
(Mr Pelletier), National University, San Diego, California; Clinical
Nurse Specialist (Dr Thomason), Sharp Memorial Hospital, San
Diego, California; Adjunct Faculty (Dr Thomason), Point Loma
Nazarene University School of Nursing, San Diego, California.
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Correspondence: Dr Stichler, 7930 Frost Street, Suite 307,
San Diego, CA 92123 (jan.stichler@sharp.com).
Supplemental digital content is available for this article. Direct
URL citations appear in the printed text and are provided in the
HTML and PDF versions of this article on the journal_s Web site
(www.jonajournal.com).
DOI: 10.1097/NNA.0000000000000706
Copyright © 2018 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved.