Covert negation in Israeli Hebrew: Evidence from co-speech
gestures
Anna Inbar
a, *, 1
, Leon Shor
b, 1
a
Tel Aviv University, Amnon VeTamar 10/3, Shoshanat HaAmaqim, 4298400, Israel
b
Tel Aviv University, HaMatmid 30/4, Ramat Gan, 5250148, Israel
article info
Article history:
Received 10 December 2018
Received in revised form 19 February 2019
Accepted 19 February 2019
abstract
The present study examines various uses of the gestures that are usually associated with
explicitly expressed negation (overt negation) in spoken Israeli Hebrew. The analysis of
such uses uncovers hidden negative structures (covert negation) at different levels, such as
lexical, propositional, or discursive. For example, the study reveals that the gestural pat-
terns that are usually coordinated with grammatical markers of negation may co-occur
with various lexemes that have a negative component as part of their meaning (such as
absence, bad, and the like), or with discourse markers that imply negation or restriction as
part of their procedural meaning. The fact that the same gestural patterns are used in all
these contexts suggests that the gestures indicate a higher abstract notion d namely,
‘negativity’ d rather than negation. Grammatical negation, therefore, should be consid-
ered one of the expressions of negativity. Moreover, the findings contribute to the claim
that there is a conceptual affiliation between speech and gesture that goes beyond indi-
vidual linguistic segments.
© 2019 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Negation is commonly defined as a process or construction in grammatical and semantic analysis that typically expresses
the contradiction of some or all of a sentence's meaning (Crystal, 2008: 323). Every human language seems to have some
morphosyntactic means at its disposal to express negation, suggesting that negation is possibly one of the universal features
of human language (Miestamo, 2007 : 553; Horn, 2010a,b: 1). From a variety of perspectives, linguistic research has long been
attempting to describe the different aspects of negation d its functional and structural properties, its role in language
acquisition, its typological manifestations, and its neurological underpinnings (Giv on, 1978; Dahl, 2010; Horn, 2010a,b;
Haspelmath, 2013; Serratrice and Allen, 2015; among many others). In recent years, however, the gestural realization of
negation and its interface with the corresponding verbal negation have begun to receive scholarly attention.
The interaction of certain gestures with verbal negation, the etymology of such gestures, and their functional description
have recently been studied in several languages, such as Italian (Kendon, 2004: 248e264), English (Kendon, 2004: 248e264;
* Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: inbara9@gmail.com (A. Inbar), shor.leon@gmail.com (L. Shor).
1
Both authors have contributed equally to this work.
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Journal of Pragmatics
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/pragma
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pragma.2019.02.011
0378-2166/© 2019 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Journal of Pragmatics 143 (2019) 85e95