0016-7622/2017-89-6-663/$ 1.00 © GEOL. SOC. INDIA
JOURNAL GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF INDIA
Vol.89, June 2017, pp.663-668
Assessment of Carcinogenic and Non-Carcinogenic Risk from
Exposure to Uranium in Groundwater from Western Haryana,
India
Vikas Duggal
1*
, Samriti Sharma
1
, Komal Saini
2
and Bikramjit Singh Bajwa
2
1
Department of Applied Sciences, Guru Kashi University, Talwandi Sabo-151302, Punjab, India
2
Department of Physics, Guru Nanak Dev University, Amritsar-143005, India
E-mail: vikasduggal86@gmail.com*; samritisharma2223@gmail.com; skomal2304@gmail.com; bsbajwa1@gmail.com
ABSTRACT
This study was carried out to assess the distribution of uranium
in groundwater by using LED fluorimeter LF-2a and chemical
and radiological risks associated with its consumption in Sirsa
district, Haryana, India. Uranium concentration ranged between
0.93 and 290μg l
-1
with an average value of 49 μg l
-1
. About 44%
of the groundwater samples had uranium concentration above the
maximum contamination level of 30 μg l
-1
prescribed by the World
Health Organization and United States Environmental Protection
Agency and 22% of the samples exceeded the permissible limit of
60 μgl
-1
prescribed by the Atomic Energy Regulatory Board,
India. The average cancer morbidity and mortality risks are
determined to be 1.10 × 10
-4
and 7.17 × 10
-5
respectively, indicating
the negligible carcinogenic risk. Hazard quotient for 44% samples
is greater than unity which indicates health risk due to chemical
toxicity of uranium in groundwater. The associated age-dependent
annual effective dose is estimated by taking the prescribed water
intake values of different age groups.
INTRODUCTION
Groundwater is the major source of drinking in both rural and
urban Haryana. Uranium prevails in the lithosphere, hydrosphere,
biosphere and atmosphere with wide variation in concentrations since
the inception of the earth (Sahoo et al. 2010; Duggal et al. 2016a).
According to an estimate, drinking water and food contributes 85%
and 15% of ingested uranium, respectively (Cothern and Lappenbusch,
1983). Uranium has dual effect on human health due to its radio-
active and chemical properties. Chemical toxicity of uranium may
cause damage to reproductive system, kidneys and liver (Singh et al.
2014; Duggal et al. 2016b). Several authors believe that the non-
carcinogenic risk of uranium is more than its deleterious carcinogenic
risk. To protect human health, the United States Environmental
Protection Agency (USEPA 2011) and World Health Organization
(WHO 2011) have developed guideline value of 30 μg l
-1
and Atomic
Energy Regulatory Board (AERB 2004) has developed standard
(60 μg l
-1
) for regulating the maximum contamination level of
uranium in water.
Few studies have investigated the occurrence of uranium in
groundwater of Haryana. Garg et al. (2014) have studied uranium
concentration in groundwater in Hisar city, Haryana and the results
showed that the concentration of uranium was above the permissible
limit. Singh et al. (2015) have determined the concentration of uranium
in groundwater of Fatehabad district, Haryana and results confirmed
that the groundwater is contaminated with uranium. The main objective
of this investigation is to study the distribution of uranium in
groundwater, to compute radiation doses for various age groups, and
to assess carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic risks to humans due to
intake of uranium through the ingestion of groundwater from Sirsa
district, Haryana.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Geology of the Study Area
The Haryana state is located between 27°39' and 30°35' N latitudes
and 74°28' and 77°36' E longitudes in north India. Figure 1 shows
the geographic location of Sirsa district on the map of Haryana, as
well as the location of the sampling sites in Sirsa district. The total
human population of the Sirsa district is 13 lakh (2011 census), and
geographical area of 4277 sq km. The Sirsa district has two types of
soils viz. sierozem and desert soils. The district has both confined and
unconfined aquifers. The unconfined aquifers occurs down to 60 m
depth below groundwater in the district and principal aquifer material
comprises fine to medium sand and sand mixed with kankar. Tubewells
are constructed up to the depth of 40 to 100 m for drinking as well as
for irrigation purpose. The major source of recharge to groundwater
in the district is rainfall, seepage from canals, return seepage through
irrigation and percolation from surface water bodies (Central
Groundwater Board, 2013). The study region is bounded by Mansa,
Bathinda and Muktsar districts of Punjab in the north, Hanumangarh
and Sri Ganganagar districts of Rajasthan in the south and west, Hisar
and Fatehabad districts of Haryana in the southeast and northeast
respectively.
Water Sampling and Physico-chemical Analysis
A total of 63 water samples were collected from Sirsa district,
Haryana. The sources of water comprise tube-wells, electric motors
and hand-pumps. The sampling sites were selected in such a manner
that the whole district has been covered.The position of each sampling
site was determined by using a portable global positioning system
(GPS). The water was left to run from the sources for about 5–10 min
until fresh water comes from deep. Prior to collection, the groundwater
samples were filtered using 0.45 μm Whatmann filter paper to remove
suspended matter/sediments, acidified with nitric acid (HNO
3
) for
preservation, and then stored in pre-cleaned acid-washed polyethylene
containers until analysis. Micro controller water analysis kit (NPC
362D) was used for the in situ measurement of electrical conductivity
(EC), total dissolved solids (TDS), and pH in groundwater (Rathore,
2013).
Analytical Procedure
Uranium analysis in groundwater was carried out in the
Environmental Radiation Research Laboratory of Guru Nanak Dev
University, Amritsar, India using LED fluorimeter LF-2a (Quantalase
Enterprises Private Limited, Indore, India). 0.5 mL of 5% sodium