market orientation—a shift that opened new
policy opportunities to local governments
susceptible to the threat of capital flight. The
driving-force behind that trend was the steady
growth in local service activities (including
finance, insurance and real estate; consumer
services; and business services) and relative
declines in manufacturing (Table 1). While
the shift away from manufacturing continues,
that shift no longer need imply increasing
Export Orientation and the Limits to
Local Sovereignty
Joseph J. Persky, Marc Doussard and Wim Wiewel
[Paper first received, February 2007; in final form, April 2008]
Abstract
The decade 1990–2000 marked a historical turnaround for large metropolitan areas in
the US. For the first time in the post-World-War-II period these metropolitan areas
experienced a reduction in the local share of economic activity relative to the export
share. The long-standing shift from manufacturing to services, while continuing
through the decade, was no longer sufficiently large to offset the increasing export
orientation of non-manufacturing industries, including many services. At first glance,
the increasing share of export activity in large metropolitan economies might suggest
that state and local governments will lose flexibility in determining economic policy.
However, the non-manufacturing industries with growing export shares are more
place-based than most of the manufacturing exports they are replacing. The paper
argues that state and local policy-makers thus continue to have considerable discretion
in their choice of economic agendas.
1. Introduction
From before 1950 to nearly the end of the
20th century, large metropolitan areas in
the US expanded their production for local
markets more rapidly than their export-
oriented activity.
1
They diversified their local
economies and increased their regional multi-
pliers. Decade after decade, metropolitan
economies thus became more local in their
0042-0980 Print/1360-063X Online
© 2009 Urban Studies Journal Limited
DOI: 10.1177/0042098008100993
Joseph J. Persky is in the Department of Economics (M/C 144), University of Illinois at Chicago, 601
South Morgan Street, Chicago, IL, 60607-7121, USA. E-mail: jpersky@uic.edu.
Marc Doussard is in the Institute for Policy Research, Northwestern University, 2040 Sheridan Road,
Evanston, IL 60208-4100, USA. E-mail: m-doussard@northwestern.edu.
Wim Wiewel is at Portland State University, Portland, Oregon, 97207-0751, USA. E-mail: wim@pdx.edu.
46(3) 519–536, March 2009