Single and multiple faults in system actuators and sensors for ethanol production
C.A. Aceves-Lara
1, 2, 3
, D. Fragkoulis
4
, G. Roux
5, 6
and B. Dahhou
5, 6
1
Université de Toulouse ; UPS, INSA, INP, LISBP ; F-31077 Toulouse, France
2
INRA, UMR792, Ingénierie des Systèmes Biologiques et des Procédés, Toulouse, France
3
CNRS, UMR5504, Toulouse, France 135 avenue de rangueil, Toulouse Cedex, F-31077
(Tel : 0561559444 ; e-mail : aceves@insa-toulouse.fr)
4
Halkis Institute of Technology, 34400,Psahna,Evia, Greece (dfragoulis@gmail.com).
5
CNRS ; LAAS ; 7 avenue du Colonel Roche, F-31077 Toulouse, France
6
Université de Toulouse ; UPS, INSA, INP, ISAE ; UT1, UTM, LAAS ; F-31077 Toulouse, France
(Tel : 0561559494 ; e-mail : [roux, dahhou]@laas.fr)
Abstract: This paper focuses on the study of a fault detection and isolation system strategy applied to an
ethanol production bioprocess that involves a two-stage bioreactor with a cell recycling loop to reach high
biomass concentrations. The various actuators and sensors of this type of bioprocess, impose to develop a
fault detection and isolation strategy. In this work, we study the case where multiple faults (with a small
delay between them) or simultaneous faults can occur. We assume that only one type of faults can occur at a
time and we will focus on the actuators and sensors faults. The sensor fault problem will be reformulated to
an actuator fault one by introducing a state variable transformation, so that an augmented system is
constructed. Thus we will design a nonlinear model based on an adaptive observer method, for detection,
isolation and identification of actuator and sensor single and multiple faults. These approaches use the
system model and the outputs of the adaptive observers to generate residuals. Residuals are defined in such
way to isolate the faulty instrument after detecting the fault. The validity of the method will be tested in
simulation in a nonlinear model of a two-stage ethanol bioprocess with a cell recycling loop.
Keywords: Bioprocess, Fault Detection, Fault Isolation, Fault Identification, Observers, Ethanol Production.
1 INTRODUCTION
The new century impose environmental challenges such as
water supply, global warming and new energy sources for
substitution of fossil fuels. These two last are closely
dependent. In our days ethanol is the main biofuel used in
Europe whose production is now based on old technology
with performance that requires innovative culture strategies to
optimize productivity. In order to overcome this challenge, an
innovative bioprocess has been studied by Aldiguier (2006)
and Ben Chaabane et al. (2006). A two-stage continuous
bioreactor with a cell recycling loop allowed a productivity of
41 kg.m
-3
.h
-1
to be reached with an ethanol titer of 8.3°GL in
the second bioreactor (Ben Chaabane et al. 2006).
The two previous works propose a static and a dynamic
optimizations of this two-stage continuous bioreactor. In the
first time, a steady-state optimization for ethanol production
was carried out using a mathematical model based on the
mass balance for a two-stage bioreactor. The volume ratio
(V
1
/V
2
) and substrate feed concentrations (S
f1
and S
f2
) were
varied during optimization in order to optimize process
design (Aceves-Lara et al. 2010a). In addition, an approach
of dynamic optimization of ethanol production by using an
optimal closed loop control was studied (Aceves-Lara et al.
2010b). Two algorithms were proposed for applied a model
predictive control (MPC); a Pattern Search algorithm (PS)
and an Interactive Ant Colony Algorithm (IACA).
The final objective of this work is to validate online the
method proposed in an experimental pilot. The various
actuators and sensors of this kind of bioprocess impose to
develop a fault detection and isolation system strategy.
Fault detection and isolation (FDI) techniques could prevent
from all the undesirable consequences of the faults and so it is
becoming an attractive topic. Stimulated by this growing
demand for improving the reliability many methods of FDI
have been developed during the last decades with the aim to
reduce the isolation time of the procedure. The various
research groups propose approaches of FDI based on the
expertise of their own field and/or experiment on a specific
class of systems. The diversity of the solutions was also
enriched by the growing interest of the industry. Model based
fault detection and diagnosis systems have found extensive
use because of the fast response to abrupt failure and the
implementation of the model based FDI in real-time
algorithms.
The most common methods for model based FDI are either
based on state or parameter estimation. A comprehensive
review of the different FDI methods and their applicability to
a given physical system has been presented in Isermann
(1994). The methods based on observers are rather well
developed, especially for the linear systems. Various types of
observers were created according to the nature of the
considered problem. More recent work treats theoretical
development for fault detection and isolation methods of
nonlinear systems (García and Frank, 1997; Frank et al.,
1999; Hammouri et al., 1999; Nijmeijer and Fossen, 1999;
8th IFAC Symposium on Fault Detection,
Supervision and Safety of Technical Processes (SAFEPROCESS)
August 29-31, 2012. Mexico City, Mexico
978-3-902823-09-0/12/$20.00 © 2012 IFAC 228 10.3182/20120829-3-MX-2028.00099