Role of Interfacial Entropy in the Particle-Size Dependence of Thermophoretic Mobility
A. Arango-Restrepo
*,†
and J. M. Rubi
‡
Departament de Física de la Mat´ eria Condensada, Facultat de Física, Universitat de Barcelona,
Avinguda Diagonal 647, 08028 Barcelona, Spain
(Received 7 May 2019; accepted 5 July 2020; published 24 July 2020)
We show that changes in the surface tension of a particle due to the presence of nonionic surfactants and
impurities, which alter the interfacial entropy, have an impact on the value of the thermophoretic mobility.
We have found the existence of different behaviors of this quantity in terms of particle size which can be
summarized through a power law. For particles that are small enough, the thermophoretic mobility is a
constant, whereas for larger particles it is linear in the particle radius. These results show the important role
of the interfacial entropic effects on the behavior of the thermophoretic mobility.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.125.045901
Particles movement induced by temperature gradients [1]
known as the Soret effect has been the subject of many
experimental and theoretical studies in recent years [2–5] due
to its importance in areas as diverse as soft condensed matter,
biophysics, microgravity, and nanoscience. Thermophoresis
may, for example, be used for the control of colloids and
macromolecules [6] and to implement effective particle
separation methods [7] and focusing techniques [8].
Studies on thermophoresis have also shown their importance
in the deposition of micro- and nanoparticles [9] in laminar
[10] and turbulent [11] pipe flows, removing and collecting
aerosol particles [12] and in biotechnological applications
[13,14].
Crucial to the study of the motion of the particles is the
knowledge of the thermophoretic mobility D
T
, the propor-
tionality factor between the thermophoretic velocity ⃗ v
T
and
the temperature gradient ∇T : ⃗ v
T
¼ −D
T
∇T , and whether it
depends on the particle size or not. There is no general
consensus on this question [15]. Experiments performed
with polystyrene solid particles of sizes between 40 nm and
2 μm in Tris buffer solution, show a linear dependence of
the thermophoretic mobility on the particle radius a [16]
whereas others made with n-alkane liquid particles in water
or surfactant ranging from 5 to 16 nm support the fact that
the mobility does not depend on the particle radius [17,18].
An experiment carried out with latex particles in a solution
containing tetrabutylammonium perchlorate with particle
radius ranging from 100 to 400 nm [19], supported by
simulation results of rigid particles with radius in the
interval 36 to 154 nm [20] shows a decreasing behavior
of the thermophoretic mobility as a function of the particle
radius. These different behaviors of D
T
may be due to the
fact that more than just a single driving force determines the
thermophoretic force in experimental systems, each with a
different size dependence. The thermophoretic force may
result from the temperature response of the core material of
the particles relative to that of the solvent, the possible
presence of electrical double layers, and from the distri-
bution of surfactant and fluid molecules at the interface
which affects the interfacial entropy. To analyze the origin
and the role of the interfacial entropic effects in thermo-
phoresis is the main objective of this Letter.
The thermophoretic velocity can be obtained from
hydrodynamics by computing the force exerted by the
solvent on a particle moving with a given velocity in the
presence of a temperature gradient [21–24]. The force
contains a thermophoretic contribution proportional to the
temperature gradient [25]. A general expression valid when
the particle is a drop, a bubble, or a solid particle with a
monolayer of adsorbed solvent [26–28] was given in
Ref. [23]:
⃗
F ¼ −μ
−1
⃗ u þ D
T
μ
−1
∇T , where μ is the mobil-
ity. Under the hydrodynamic approach, D
T
is proportional
to the derivative of the surface tension with respect to the
temperature γ
T
≡ dγ =dT and to the particle radius (a) and
is a function of the viscosities and thermal conductivities of
the inner and outer fluids.
In our analysis, we show how the distribution of the
nonionic solvent and surfactant molecules adsorbed at the
interface may depend on the size of the particle. Since this
distribution affects the interfacial entropy, it may bring
about a dependence of the surface tension and, conse-
quently, of the γ
T
factor on particle size. We thus find that
for sufficiently large particles, the ratio between the
numbers of fluid and surfactant molecules on the particle
surface does not depend on the radius (a). Therefore, γ
T
does not depend on a and so the thermophoretic mobility is
a linear function of a. On the contrary, for small particles
that ratio may depend on the radius of the particle due to
entropic effects which lead to a different behavior of γ
T
as a
function of a.
To show how the distribution of fluid and surfactant
molecules at the interface affects the thermophoretic
velocity, we will consider the stationary movement of a
drop immersed in a fluid subjected to a temperature
PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 125, 045901 (2020)
0031-9007=20=125(4)=045901(6) 045901-1 © 2020 American Physical Society