https://doi.org/10.1177/0022219419866645
Journal of Learning Disabilities
1–12
© Hammill Institute on Disabilities 2019
Article reuse guidelines:
sagepub.com/journals-permissions
DOI: 10.1177/0022219419866645
journaloflearningdisabilities.sagepub.com
Article
Language impairments are associated with poor academic
achievement and require sensitive and timely identifica-
tion and provision of relevant intervention and accom-
modation. Language impairments typically persist across
the lifespan, although their expression may change over
time (American Speech-Language-Hearing Association
[ASHA], 2017; Farnia, 2018). Individuals with develop-
mental language disorders (DLD) “have difficulties in the
acquisition and use of language components such as pho-
nology, morphology, syntax, semantics, and pragmatics
across different modalities” (ASHA, 2017; Bishop,
Snowling, Thompson, Greenhalgh, & The CATALISE
Consortium, 2017). These general observations about
DLD have been made in relation to both monolingual
(e.g., Rice & Hoffman, 2015) and bilingual children (e.g.,
Kohnert, 2010). Research on DLD has shown that lan-
guage problems that persist into adolescence impact neg-
atively not only academic achievement but also
interpersonal relations, friendship-making, and socio-
emotional problems (Beitchman et al., 1999; Conti-
Ramsden & Botting, 2008).
DLD in First and Second Language
Learners
Studies involving DLD in children whose home language is
the societal language, hereafter L1, have demonstrated rela-
tionships between difficulties in syntactic and semantic
skills and underlying cognitive processes such as auditory
perception and working memory (Bishop, 2004; Van Daal,
Verhoeven, & van Balkom, 2004). In addition, research
involving first language (L1) learners has documented the
relationship between deficits in vocabulary and DLD (e.g.,
Archibald & Gathercole, 2006; Jackson, Leitao, & Claessen,
2016), as well as between deficits in syntax and DLD (e.g.,
Joanisse & Seidenberg, 2003). In addition, evidence for the
866645LDX XX X 10.1177/0022219419866645Journal of Learning DisabilitiesFarnia and Geva
research-article 2019
University of Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Corresponding Author:
Fataneh Farnia, Department of Psychiatry and Department of Applied
Psychology and Human Development, Ontario Institute for Studies
in Education, University of Toronto, 252 Bloor St. West, Toronto,
Ontario, Canada M5S 1V6.
Email: fataneh.farnia@utoronto.ca
Late-Emerging Developmental
Language Disorders in English-Speaking
Monolinguals and English-Language
Learners: A Longitudinal Perspective
Fataneh Farnia, PhD and Esther Geva, PhD
Abstract
Research involving monolinguals has demonstrated that language impairment can be noticed in the early years and tends
to persist into adolescence. More recently, research has begun to address the challenges of identifying and treating
Developmental Language Disorders (DLD) in English Language Learners (ELLs). Developmental patterns of DLD are
not necessarily consistent over time, and we hypothesized that some monolinguals and ELLs go “under the radar” in
lower grades but their language difficulties become more pronounced in later years, as syntactic demands increase, hence
“late-emerging DLD”. This longitudinal study examined (a) the existence of late-emerging DLD in Grades 4-6 in English-
speaking monolinguals and ELLs, and (b) the Grade 1 and 3 cognitive and language profiles that predict late-emerging
DLD. This study involved monolinguals (n = 149), and ELLs (n = 402) coming from diverse home language backgrounds.
Cognitive (working memory, phonological short-term memory, processing speed), language (vocabulary and syntax), and
word reading skills were assessed annually from grades 1 to 6. Separate parallel analyses in the monolingual and ELL
samples confirmed that late-emerging DLD exists in both groups. In comparison with their typically developing peers,
late-emerging DLD can be identified as early as Grade 1 based on poorer performance on phonological awareness, naming
speed, and working memory.
Keywords
disorders, language, identification/classification, English-language learners, second language learners