Copyright © 2016 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved.
C
URRENT
O
PINION
Vaccine-associated inflammatory diseases of the
central nervous system: from signals to causation
Xuan-Hung Nguyen
a,b,c
, Abdelhadi Saoudi
a,b,c
, and Roland S. Liblau
a,b,c,d
Purpose of review
As the most cost-effective intervention in preventive medicine and as a crucial element of any public health
program, vaccination is used extensively with over 90% coverage in many countries. As approximately
5–8% of the population in developed countries suffer from an autoimmune disorder, people with an
autoimmune disease are most likely to be exposed to some vaccines before or after the disease onset. In
fact, a number of inflammatory disorders of the central nervous system have been associated with the
administration of various vaccines. These adverse events, be they spurious associations or genuine
reactions to the vaccine, may lead to difficulties in obtaining public trust in mass vaccination programs.
There is, thus, an urgent need to understand whether vaccination triggers or enhances autoimmune
responses.
Recent findings
By reviewing vaccine-associated inflammatory diseases of the central nervous system, this study describes
the current knowledge on whether the safety signal was coincidental, as in the case of multiple sclerosis
with several vaccines, or truly reflected a causal link, as in narcolepsy with cataplexy following pandemic
H1N1 influenza virus vaccination.
Summary
The lessons learnt emphasize a central role of thorough, ideally prospective, epidemiological studies
followed, if the signal is deemed plausible or real, by immunological investigations.
Keywords
autoimmunity, central nervous system, multiple sclerosis, narcolepsy, vaccination
INTRODUCTION
Vaccination may be followed by central neurologi-
cal manifestations, giving rise to safety signals.
Regardless of whether these signals reflect a causal
link or are coincidental associations, they have the
potential to undermine the public confidence
in vaccines as a whole. It is, therefore, crucial to
understand whether an association between a given
vaccine and a given central nervous system (CNS)
autoimmune disease is a ‘chance’ observation or
reveals a causal link, which needs to be further
explored. Here, based on the basic principles of
vaccination, we analyze two very distinct situations.
In the first one, the claimed associations of two
vaccines with onset of multiple sclerosis (MS) were
not confirmed by large-scale epidemiological stud-
ies. In the second one, a vaccine, namely Pandemrix,
was convincingly associated with onset of narco-
lepsy with cataplexy, providing a unique window
into the immunopathogenesis of this rare disease.
Further immunological studies should therefore
be performed to understand the mechanisms under-
lying such an association and, thereby, hopefully
increase vaccine safety.
IMMUNOLOGICAL PRINCIPLES OF
VACCINATION
Human beings are exposed to a great variety of
infectious agents, which can cause disease or be
lethal if they multiply in uncontrolled manner.
Thanks to the immune system, most infections in
healthy individuals are short-lived leaving little
a
INSERM, U1043,
b
CNRS, U5282,
c
Centre de Physiopathologie Tou-
louse-Purpan (CPTP), Universite ´ de Toulouse and
d
De ´ partement d’Immu-
nologie, Ho ˆpital Purpan, CHU Toulouse, Toulouse, France
Correspondence to Professor Roland S. Liblau, MD, PhD, INSERM
UMR1043-CNRS U5282, Ho ˆ pital Purpan, BP 3028, 31024 Toulouse,
France. E-mail: roland.liblau@inserm.fr
Curr Opin Neurol 2016, 29:362–371
DOI:10.1097/WCO.0000000000000318
www.co-neurology.com Volume 29 Number 3 June 2016
REVIEW