PsycCRITIQUES
November 14, 2007, Vol. 52, No. 46, Article 9
© 2007 American Psychological Association
Plans for Completion, but Necessary
Imputations
A Review of
Missing Data: A Gentle Introduction
by Patrick E. McKnight, Katherine M. McKnight, Souraya Sidani, and
Aurelio José Figueredo
New York: Guilford Press, 2007. 266 pp. ISBN 978-1-59385-394-5
(hardcover); ISBN 978-1-59385-393-8 (paperback). $60.00,
hardcover; $38.00, paperback
http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/a0009824
Reviewed by
Francis C. Staskon
As Gerald van Belle (2002) stated in his book on rules of thumb in statistics “The best rule
is: Don't have any missing data. Unfortunately, that is unrealistic. Therefore, plan for
missing data and develop strategies to account for them. Do this before starting the study…”
(p. 146). These succinct sentences sum up the issue for missing data as detailed in the
reviewed book Missing Data: A Gentle Introduction, which presents the many approaches
developed to address missing data. Gentle, as in a simplified version, the book Missing Data
offers solutions and guides for the problem of missing data as it relates to research design
and statistical analyses, suited for a novice's understanding of the complexities inherent in
this topic. Although the chosen writing style is a rather redundant one of “tell them again
what was just told,” the book does succeed in providing a comprehensive and nuanced
discussion of the complexities and variety of solutions. It also offers approaches to reduce
the likelihood of obtaining missing data by considering research procedures or design.
This book serves as one of the better introductions to this topic for students and will be
useful for others seeking a more general overview of approaches for missing data. Having
taken a summer graduate-level course with Roderick Little and attended a number of local
chapter American Statistical Association presentations related to this topic, I appreciated
reviewing the book for its overview and synthesis of known statistical solutions, along with
the practical techniques suggested to prevent the occurrence of missing data. This book is
unique in addressing not only the statistical issues but also in its coverage on preventing the
occurrence of missing data as research is planned or conducted, and how missing data
should be presented in publications.
Missing Data is composed of 12 chapters that begin with the prevalence of missing data and
its impact. Unique to this book is the suggestion that a cost–benefit approach to missing
data be implemented to facilitate a more functional approach to the topic. The proposed
fourfold functional approach would address the origins of missing data in order to reduce its