RESEARCH
Effect of cyclopentolate versus tropicamide on anterior segment
angle parameters in three refractive groups
Clin Exp Optom 2020 DOI:10.1111/cxo.13103
Nasrin Moghadas Sharif*
†
MSc
Nasser Shoeibi
‡
MD
Maryam Heydari
†
MSc
Negareh Yazdani*
†
MSc
Somayeh Ghasemi-moghaddam
†
MSc
Asieh Ehsaei
†§
PhD
*Student Research Committee, Mashhad University of
Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran
†
Department of Optometry, School of Paramedical
Sciences, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences,
Mashhad, Iran
‡
Eye Research Centre, Mashhad University of Medical
Sciences, Mashhad, Iran
§
Refractive Errors Research Centre, Mashhad
University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran
Email: ehsaeia@mums.ac.ir
Submitted: 28 February 2020
Revised: 7 May 2020
Accepted for publication: 12 May 2020
Clinical relevance: Frequent clinical application of cycloplegia in clinical practice makes it
essential to assess how this condition influences anterior segment angle parameters.
Background: This study aims to compare the effects of cyclopentolate and tropicamide on
anterior segment angle parameters in three adult refractive groups.
Methods: Sixty healthy individuals were recruited and assigned into three refractive groups
according to inclusion criteria. At baseline visit, anterior segment angle parameters were
measured using anterior segment optical coherence tomography in the right eye. All mea-
surements were repeated at two separate visits, one week apart, after administration of
tropicamide 1% and cyclopentolate 1% at similar conditions. Main outcome measures were
angle-opening distance, trabecular iris angle, trabecular iris space area and anterior cham-
ber depth. Anterior segment angle parameters were recorded at temporal areas
(180 degrees).
Results: Sixty participants (29 men and 31 women, age: 27.82 4.71 years) completed the
experiment. Baseline mean spherical equivalents were +1.52 1.20 D, -0.04 0.33 D and
-1.91 0.91 D in hyperopic, emmetropic and myopic groups, respectively. No statistically
significant differences were found between tropicamide and cyclopentolate for all angle
parameters in three refractive groups. Both drops induced an increase in all parameters in
three refractive groups. Analysis between refractive groups revealed that a more hyperopic
refraction was associated with less trabecular iris angle, angle-opening distance and ante-
rior chamber depth parameters in baseline, after tropicamide and cyclopentolate
instillations.
Conclusions: Topical application of cycloplegic eye drops in healthy individuals leads to
small but significant changes in anterior chamber depth and anterior segment angle param-
eters, regardless of refractive status. Moreover, lower values of anterior chamber depth
and anterior segment angle parameters in hyperopic individuals after administration of
cycloplegic drops should be taken into account during biometric measurement and phakic
intraocular lens implantation. Due to shorter effect and recovery time and less ocular/sys-
temic reaction of tropicamide versus cyclopentolate, tropicamide could be a recommended
cycloplegic agent for diagnostic and therapeutic procedures.
Key words: anterior segment angle, cyclopentolate, optical coherence tomography, tropicamide
Topical eye drops inducing both mydriasis
and cycloplegia are primarily used for
comprehensive ocular examinations in
outpatient clinics and during surgery,
refraction, and in treatment of some ocu-
lar diseases including amblyopia and cor-
neal traumas. Furthermore, they may be
used in the management of uveitis to pre-
vent synechia.
1
Atropine, cyclopentolate and tropicamide
are the most commonly used cycloplegic
drops. These anticholinergic drops block the
action of the sphincter muscle of the iris
and the ciliary muscles of the crystalline lens
to cholinergic stimulation.
2,3
After adminis-
tration, many changes occur in anterior
chamber angle, anterior chamber depth, iris
thickness/volume and pupil dilation, hence
causing accommodation inhibition.
4,5
Atropine is the gold standard for complete
cycloplegia; however, a long duration of
action and severe side effects limit its clinical
application. In contrast, cyclopentolate and
tropicamide provide temporary cycloplegia
and mydriasis with shorter duration of action
compared with atropine and are widely used
in clinical practice.
6
Cyclopentolate has an
onset of action of 30–45 minutes and dura-
tion of action of 24 hours. Tropicamide is
another short-acting cycloplegic agent with
an onset of action of 15–30 minutes that per-
sists for up to four to six hours.
2
The assessment of anterior segment
parameters is an important part of ophthal-
mic practice. Slitlamp biomicroscopy with
Goldman 3-mirror lens attachment has
been traditionally employed for anterior
chamber angle assessment. However, newly
developed devices such as swept-source
© 2020 Optometry Australia Clinical and Experimental Optometry 2020
1
CLINICAL AND EXPERIMENTAL