Architecture Research 2018, 8(1): 12-18
DOI: 10.5923/j.arch.20180801.02
Challenges of the Urban Boundary Wall: The Case of
Two Neighbourhoods in Accra, Ghana
Ninnette Quaofio
1,*
, J. G. K. Abankwa
1
, S. O. Afram
2
1
Central University, Miotso, Accra, Ghana
2
Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology, Kumasi, Ghana
Abstract Boundary walls are constructed for safety, privacy, security, territory demarcation, among other reasons. Their
construction is however raising concerns with social interaction, integration and crime control etc. in many African cities.
This research is aimed at studying two neighbourhoods to ascertain the veracity of these assertions and to explore the
possibilities of using the design of walls to enhance them in addition to improving the aesthetic appeal of streetscapes. The
study employed the mixed method approach to gather data using survey questionnaires and face-to-face interviews with
relevant stakeholders. Some key findings indicated that walls hamper social interaction and integration and do not guarantee
safety and security. Recommendations made included the formation of neighbourhood watchdog associations, installation of
CCTV cameras, adoption of standardized boundary wall designs and front walls that allow for views into residences.
Keywords Walls, Boundary wall, Neighbourliness, Cityscapes, Urban degeneration, Social interaction
1. Introduction
Throughout history, cities have used walls to demarcate
boundaries, provide safety, security and protection from
enemies (Weizman, 2007). Boundaries including walls for
privacy, boundary marking wall and city walls in general, are
commonly identified in many known societies as a barrier to
prevent progress or entry. The barrier separating Israel and
Palestine, known also as the separation wall, the security
measure, the fence, or a myriad of other terms was
constructed as an obstruction to the intrusion of terrorists
entering into Israel from the West Bank (Weizman, 2007).
The reason for building the Great Wall of China for
example, was to protect the Chinese Empire from Mongolian
invaders as well others but for a long time it was an object of
fascination for foreigners (Li, X., & Wang, Y, 2011). The
wall is now a revered national symbol and a famous tourist
destination. Similarly, The Kano city ancient wall, a historic
structure as well as a monumental edifice built to guard the
dwellers of the city at that time (Akinade, 2005).
The great Zimbabwean wall built in the 14th century is
another fascinating quest for city protection and authority but
all that remains are ruins of which spread over a terrain of
270,000 square miles found in the region (Pikirayi &
Chirikure, 2011). City walls, just like other historic buildings,
revealed the aspirations, traditions and culture of the
* Corresponding author:
ninnetteq@gmail.com (Ninnette Quaofio)
Published online at http://journal.sapub.org/arch
Copyright © 2018 Scientific & Academic Publishing. All Rights Reserved
forefathers; these are inspired works of people who were
never forced to conform to standard and are seen today
therefore as ruins of their former glory (Adeyemi and
Bappah, 2011). People have always found it important to
guard themselves against the elements of their environment
and from potential adversaries (people and animals) as well
as to separate and pull away from the broader group. The
idea of privacy as a component of the built environment has
been around since the beginnings of humankind (Riley,
1999). Demarcation by clearly defining territory by groups
of people has been one of the primary instinctive concerns of
the early occupants of the earth to protect themselves from
their enemies. Martin (2014) emphasized this when it
identified that, residential walling fulfils several functions
especially a form of security.
To form a visible barrier for unwanted onlookers, it is also
important that the walling distinguishes a home from its
visible feature and give privacy.
In the past decade, walls in the City of Accra have become
taller, thicker, opaquer, fortified with metal barricades and
security electric fence wires with very little supervision by
appropriate professionals. The study explores the possibility
of using the design of walls to enhance integration, safety,
reduce crime and effect change to the urban environment
through social interaction while maintaining aesthetically
appealing streetscapes.
2. Literature Review
When an exterior structure is made of wires, it is generally
termed a fence whereas when it is made of masonry it is