PHYSICAL REVIEW B 84, 205314 (2011)
Ab initio study of the early stages of gas-phase water oxidation of the Si(100) (2 × 1):H surface
R. Lelis-Sousa
*
and M. J. Caldas
†
Instituto de F´ ısica, Universidade de S ˜ ao Paulo, Rua do Mat˜ ao, Travessa R 187, CEP 05508-900 S˜ ao Paulo, Brazil
(Received 28 June 2011; revised manuscript received 25 October 2011; published 16 November 2011)
We investigate different reaction mechanisms for the dissociation of a H
2
O molecule on the Si(100)(2 × 1):H
surface, through ab initio calculations within density functional theory, comparing results using local density
and generalized gradient approximations for the exchange-correlation potential. The reaction pathways were
obtained with the “climbing image–nudged elastic band” procedure. In all cases we present complete analysis
of the transition barriers and binding energies. Our results indicate that the oxidation route suggested by earlier
works, which entails full chemisorption of the water molecule, is not favorable, and we propose two alternative
routes with simultaneous release of one H
2
molecule.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevB.84.205314 PACS number(s): 68.43.Bc, 68.47.Fg, 82.20.Wt, 82.65.+r
I. INTRODUCTION
Oxidation of silicon surfaces has been a frequent object
of study since the beginning of device physics and continues
to receive careful attention,
1–3
especially due to the advances
in nanoscience and molecular electronics.
4–6
Oxidation can
come by exposure to molecular O
2
gas, to ambient air, or to
water, and in the last two cases it is important to understand the
initial reaction with water molecules. We are interested here in
water oxidation of the monohydrogenated Si(100)(2 × 1):H,
of relevance to hybrid organic-on-Si interfaces.
6,7
The reaction of water with Si(100) surfaces has long
been investigated, from the experimental and theoretical
points of view,
8–32
and despite these efforts, there are still
several open questions. For clean Si(100) surfaces it is agreed
from the experimental results that, after interaction with
water, almost 100% of the surface consists of very stable
HSi– SiOH species
11–25,33,34
and the dimer-row pattern is
maintained. In this case, theoretical studies find that the
reaction proceeds without barrier.
17,33,35
As for hydrogen
passivated Si(100):H surfaces, even though there are fewer
experimental or theoretical studies of wet oxidation, analyses
of infrared (IR) spectra confirm that they are more resistant to
oxidative damage.
18–20,36,37
Monohydrogenated Si(100)(2 ×
1):H reconstruction is very stable
38
and allows for the growth
of samples with a high degree of homogeneity, which makes it
an interesting substrate for applications in hybrid devices;
5–7
on the other hand, oxygen is known to be very important for
determining surface reactivity (in fact some techniques rely
specifically on using suboxides
4
), and since many approaches
to the assembling of organic layers are based on wet-chemistry
techniques, a thorough investigation of the early stages of
oxidation by water of this particular surface is, therefore, very
useful and motivates this work.
From a joint experimental and theoretical study
18–20
of the
Si(100):H surface, based on IR spectroscopy and ab initio
cluster-based simulations for vibrational modes, it has been
proposed that, in the initial stages of oxidation, insertion
of the water molecule occurs with dissociation as a silanol
(SiOH) group and dimer-bond breaking (HSi-SiH + H
2
O →
HSiH + HSiOH). It is well established that increasing the
water flux on a Si(100):H surface results in the disappearance
of the IR signal for the pure surface dimer HSi-SiH and
gives rise to vibrational peaks related to oxidized structures;
however, the silanol vibrational modes at 821 and 2081 cm
−1
,
present for oxidation of the clean surface, were not identified
in the experimental data. At advanced stages of wet oxidation,
the IR signal is dominated by peaks located at 962–979 and
2143 cm
−1
that, based on the calculations for the vibrational
frequencies, were attributed to the presence of neighbor
dihydrogenated surface groups, both clean HSiH and with
a back-bond oxygen HSi(O)H (here we label this structure
C
BB
). These results suggest that the back bond is the main
site for oxygen chemisorption.
18–20,26
Still according to this
experimental interpretation,
18–20,26
oxidation of the back bond
would follow from a HSiH + HSiOH precursor (we label this
complete structure C
Sil
).
An intriguing point is that at early stages of wet oxidation
(data for a water exposure of 100 L),
18–20
the IR spectrum
consists mainly of vibrational peaks in the ranges 803 to
≈870, ≈897 to 910, and 2120 cm
−1 20
, and the frequencies
for oxidized HSiH units (close to 962–979 cm
−1
) are not
identified. Indeed, the theoretical simulations
14,18–20
suggest
instead oxidized dimer species HSi-O-SiH or HSi-Si(O)H,
including multiply oxidized groups such as HSi-O-Si(O)H.
To our knowledge, issues related specifically to the inter-
action between a water molecule and HSi-SiH groups have
not yet been discussed in the literature. We present here a
theoretical investigation of energy barriers, transition states,
and reaction pathways related to oxygen insertion in the
Si(100)(2 × 1):H first subsurface region, at early stages of
wet oxidation. We show that the C
Sil
species will be formed
on the surface, but the energy barrier for conversion into
C
BB
is very high, implying that silanol is not an effective
route for oxygen insertion in subsurface sites. We propose
two efficient routes for initial oxidation without dimer-bond
breaking, one regarding oxidation of the back-bond site
and another for on-dimer oxidation, which have favorable
dissociation routes; both occur with simultaneous release
of a H
2
molecule, producing HSi-O-SiH + H
2
(C
OD
) and
HSi-Si(O)H + H
2
(C
BB+H2
) species. Again, to our knowledge,
these structures have never been previously considered. An
interesting result of our simulations is that silanol is actually
a precursor not of the back-bond configuration, but of the
on-dimer oxidation.
II. METHODOLOGY
The unit cell of the ideal Si(100)(2 × 1):H surface consists
of two Si atoms per layer, with the surface dimers saturated
205314-1 1098-0121/2011/84(20)/205314(8) ©2011 American Physical Society