A High Frame-rate and Low-cost Elastography System by Generating Shear
Waves through Continuous Vibration of the Ultrasound Transducer
Daniel C. Mellema
1
, Pengfei Song
1
, Armando Manduca
1
, Matthew W. Urban
1
,
Randall R. Kinnick, James F. Greenleaf
1
, Shigao Chen
1
1
Department of Physiology and Biomedical Engineering, Mayo Clinic College of Medicine, Rochester, MN, USA
Abstract— Ultrasound shear wave elastography (SWE)
utilizes the propagation of induced shear waves to characterize
the shear modulus of soft tissue. Many methods rely on an
acoustic radiation force (ARF) push beam to generate shear
waves. However, specialized hardware is required to generate the
push beams, and the thermal stress that is placed upon the
ultrasound system, transducer, and tissue by the push beams
currently limits the frame-rate to about 1 Hz. This paper
presents Probe Oscillation Shear Elastography (PROSE) as an
alternative method to measure tissue elasticity, by generating
shear waves using a continuous mechanical vibration of an
ultrasound transducer, while simultaneously detecting motion
with the same transducer under pulse-echo mode. Motion of the
transducer during detection produces a compression strain
artifact that is coupled with the observed shear waves. A novel
symmetric sampling scheme is proposed such that pulse-echo
detection events are acquired when the ultrasound transducer
returns to the same physical position, allowing the shear waves to
be decoupled from the compression artifact. Full field-of-view
(FOV) two-dimensional (2D) shear wave speed (SWS) images
were obtained by applying a local frequency estimation (LFE)
method, capable of generating a 2D map from a single frame of
shear wave motion, allowing for an imaging frame rate
comparable to the vibration frequency. PROSE was able to
produce smooth and accurate shear wave images from three
homogeneous phantoms with different moduli, with an effective
frame rate of 300Hz. An inclusion phantom study showed that
increased vibration frequencies improved the accuracy of
inclusion imaging, and allowed targets as small as 6.5 mm to be
resolved with good contrast (contrast-to-noise ratio ≥19 dB)
between the target and background.
Index Terms— Mechanical vibration, shear wave, ultrasound
elastography.
I. INTRODUCTION
Elasticity imaging has been developed to provide non-
invasive and objective quantification of the mechanical
properties of tissue [1]. Many of the techniques developed
utilize the propagation of induced shear waves as a surrogate
for, or to quantitatively estimate the shear modulus of soft
tissue. Assuming soft tissues are incompressible, isotropic,
linear, and elastic, the shear modulus (μ) can be related to
shear wave propagation speed, c
s
, by
ߩ=ߤ
௦
ଶ
, (1)
where ρ is density and can be assumed to be 1000 kg/cm
3
for
all soft tissues [2].
Acoustic radiation force (ARF) based techniques have been
successfully used to generate shear waves within soft tissue
[3-9]. However, these ARF-based shear wave elastography
(SWE) techniques suffer from two major drawbacks. The first
is that the high voltage push beam used to generate shear
waves requires upgraded hardware, which limits the
implementation of ARF-based SWE to high-tier ultrasound
systems [3, 10]. Secondly, the delivered push beams places
thermal stress on the hardware, ultrasound transducer, and
tissue, ultimately limiting the typical SWE frame-rate to about
1 Hz.
Sonoelastography methods are able to generate shear waves
through the mechanical coupling of an external vibration
source [2, 11], potentially providing higher imaging frame-
rates. However, these methods generally require separate
devices for the generation and the detection of shear waves,
which can cause difficulty when investigating certain tissues
due to physiological constraints. Transient elastography
methods, such as Fibroscan, have addressed this issue by
using a small single element transducer to deliver a
mechanical impulse to generate a longitudinally polarized
transient shear wave that can be detected by the same
ultrasound transducer [7]. This system is widely applied in
studying liver fibrosis; however, Fibroscan does not provide
two-dimensional (2D) imaging and is not suited for the
detection of local changes in tissue elasticity.
In this paper we propose Probe Oscillation Shear Wave
Elastography (PROSE) as a new method, which utilizes
continuous mechanical vibration of the ultrasound transducer
to produce harmonic longitudinally polarized shear waves that
are similar to those generated using TE. Different from TE,
PROSE is capable of 2D quantitative elastography by
simultaneously generating and acquiring the resulting shear
wave motion using the same transducer under pulse-echo
detection mode. Single frame shear wave motion was obtained
using a novel symmetric sampling scheme and 2D shear wave
speed (SWS) image were reconstructed from each single
frame shear wave motion using the Local Frequency
Estimation (LFE) method [12]. The efficacy of PROSE was
evaluated through homogeneous and inclusion phantom
studies.
II. METHODS
A. Shear Wave Generation and Detection
To generate shear wave motion, a custom vibration system
was created, by coaxially mounting a linear voice coil actuator
(BEI Kimco Magnetics, Vista, CA) to an L11-4v linear array
ultrasound transducer (Verasonics Inc., Kirkland, WA) for use
with a Verasonics Vantage Ultrasound system (Verasonics
Inc., Kirkland, WA). A function generator (Agilent 33250A,
978-1-4799-8182-3/15/$31.00 ©2015 IEEE 2015 IEEE International Ultrasonics Symposium Proceedings
10.1109/ULTSYM.2015.0203