This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON CONTROL SYSTEMS TECHNOLOGY 1
Modeling and Control of a Full-Scale Roller-Rig
for the Analysis of Railway Braking Under
Degraded Adhesion Conditions
Benedetto Allotta, Member, IEEE, Roberto Conti, Enrico Meli, and Alessandro Ridolfi
Abstract—Currently, braking on board subsystems such as
wheel slide protection (WSP) devices almost totally control the
longitudinal train dynamics. In particular, the vehicle safety
highly depends on the study and the development of these
systems, especially at high speeds and under degraded adhesion
conditions. Usually, to save time and to avoid expensive
on-track tests, the performances of braking subsystems are
tested on full-scale roller-rigs. Nevertheless, the analysis of the
subsystem behavior under degraded adhesion conditions is still
limited to a few applications on roller-rigs because large slidings
among the rollers and wheelsets produce severe wear of the
rolling surfaces. This circumstance is not acceptable due to
the effects on the maintenance costs (the rollers have to be
turned or substituted), on the system dynamical stability and
on the safety. In this paper, the modeling and control of an
innovative hardware in the loop (HIL) architecture to test
braking on board subsystems on full-scale roller-rigs is described.
The new approach permits to reproduce on the roller-rig a
generic wheel-rail adhesion pattern and, in particular, degraded
adhesion conditions. The presented strategy is also followed by
the innovative full-scale roller-rig of the Railway Research and
Approval Center of Firenze-Osmannoro (Italy); the new roller-
rig has been built by Trenitalia and is owned by SIMPRO. At this
initial phase of the research activity, to effectively validate the
proposed approach, a complete model of the HIL system has been
developed. The complete numerical model is based on the real
characteristics of the components provided by Trenitalia. The
results coming from the simulation model have been compared
with the experimental data provided by Trenitalia and relative
to on-track tests performed in Velim, Czech Republic, with a
UIC-Z1 coach equipped with a fully working WSP system. The
preliminary validation performed with the HIL model highlights
the good performance of the HIL strategy in reproducing on
the roller-rig, the complex interaction between the degraded
adhesion conditions and railway vehicle dynamics during the
braking maneuver.
Index Terms— Degraded adhesion conditions, hardware in the
loop (HIL), railway braking, roller-rigs.
I. I NTRODUCTION
N
OWADAYS, the longitudinal train dynamics is almost
totally controlled by on board subsystems, such as wheel
slide protection (WSP) braking devices. The study and the
Manuscript received January 4, 2014; accepted April 13, 2014. Manuscript
received in final form April 22, 2014. Recommended by Associate Editor
F. Caccavale.
The authors are with the Industrial Engineering Department, Florence
University, Florence 50139, Italy (e-mail: benedetto.allotta@unifi.it;
roberto.conti@unifi.it; enrico.meli@unifi.it; a.ridolfi@unifi.it).
Color versions of one or more of the figures in this paper are available
online at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org.
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TCST.2014.2320672
development of these systems are fundamental for the vehicle
safety, especially at high speeds and under degraded adhesion
conditions. On-track tests are currently quite expensive in
terms of infrastructure and vehicle management. Therefore,
to reduce these costs, full-scale roller-rigs are traditionally
employed to investigate the performances of braking subsys-
tems [1]–[4]. However, in the presence of degraded adhesion,
the use of roller-rigs is still limited to few applications (see,
for example, full-scale roller-rigs for the study of the wear [5],
hardware in the loop (HIL) systems for WSP tests [8] and
full-scale roller-rigs for locomotive tests [8]) because the high
slidings between the rollers and wheelsets produce wear of the
rolling surfaces. This circumstance is very dangerous and not
acceptable: the flange wear can lead to the vehicle derailment
while the tread wear can produce hunting instability of the
vehicle [27]. Furthermore, the wheel flats may generate unsafe
vibrations of the vehicle on the roller-rig. Finally, the wear of
the rolling surfaces deeply affects the maintenance costs: the
rollers have to be frequently turned or substituted.
In this paper, the modeling and control of an innovative
HIL architecture to test braking on board subsystems on
full-scale roller-rigs is presented by the authors. The new
strategy permits to reproduce on the roller-rig a generic wheel-
rail adhesion pattern and, in particular, degraded adhesion
conditions (characterized by adhesion coefficient values equal
or less than 0.10 [31]). The control architecture, based on
a robust sliding mode approach, performs a simulation of
mechanical impedance by properly controlling the roller-rig
motors (all the motors are independently controlled). More
particularly, the roller motors are controlled to recreate, on
the wheelsets, the same angular velocities, applied torques, and
tangential efforts exchanged between the wheelsets and rails in
the reality and calculated by a reference virtual railway vehicle
model. The new control architecture allows the achievement
of this goal by only controlling the roller motors and without
having sliding (and consequently wear) between the wheelsets
and rollers. In fact, since the real adhesion coefficient between
the rollers and wheelsets surfaces is far higher than the
simulated one (greater than 0.40), negligible sliding occurs
and almost pure rolling conditions are always present between
them.
Some initial and partial results have been obtained in [9].
The major novelties of the presented work mainly concern the
two following aspects.
1) The Motor Controllers (Able to Reproduce on the Roller-
Rig the Same Dynamical Behavior of the Virtual Train
1063-6536 © 2014 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission.
See http://www.ieee.org/publications_standards/publications/rights/index.html for more information.