© 2008 The Author
Journal Compilation © 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
Literature Compass 5/2 (2008): 174–194, 10.1111/j.1741-4113.2007.00513.x
Restoration and Eighteenth-Century Drama:
New Directions in the Field
Laura J. Rosenthal*
University of Maryland
Abstract
This essay offers an overview of recent critical books published on Restoration
and eighteenth-century drama, with a glance back to the critical history of this
field. The essay emphasizes critical explorations of the earlier part of the period
and provides a bibliography for further reading.
If the novel still to some extent dominates eighteenth-century studies, in
recent years the drama has emerged as a genre of considerable interest. Much
innovative scholarship lately has revived interest in plays of this period by
exploring their complex constructions of the gender, subjectivity, class,
authorship, nationalism, ideology, and imperial relations, revealing that they
differ in key ways from the period’s fiction. Taken traditionally as a weakness
but in more recent work as a point of interest, the drama often confronts
head-on certain issues that the novel tends to raise only obliquely or
implicitly. In The London Merchant (1731), for example, Thorowgood makes
an explicit case for the worthiness of the merchant class; in The Way of
the World (1700), Millamant negotiates up front her position as a wife; in
Inkle and Yarico (1787), the young merchant tries to sell into slavery the
Native American women who rescued him and carries his child; in The
Man of Mode (1676), Dorimant argues that the acceptable transgressions
of the elite should be forbidden to shoemakers; in Cato (1713), the hero
pronounces on the relationship between skin color and virtue (there is
none); in the late-century pantomime Omai (1785), Captain Cook literally
becomes a god. Readers of Samuel Richardson may come to believe that
this period equated female virtue with virginity, but in Robert Dodsley’s
popular The King and the Miller of Mansfield (1737) the heroine, after having
been seduced by a rakish courtier, happily marries her sweetheart. The plays
do not necessarily confront the period’s pressing social changes with a more
progressive vision than other genres; nevertheless, they tend to address
certain issues more openly and more confrontationally.
Until the last thirty years or so, however, most Restoration and eighteenth-
century plays met with one of two critical fates: neglect or scandal. Many,