Original Research 157
© 2006 Schattauer GmbH
Received September 2, 2005
Accepted October 12, 2005 Vet Comp Orthop Traumatol 3/2006
The role of negative intra-articular pressure in
the maintenance of shoulder joint stability in
dogs
B. K. Sidaway
1
, R. M. McLaughlin
2
, S. H. Elder
4
, C. R. Boyle
3
, E. B. Silverman
2
1
Southwest Veterinary Surgery Service, Glendale, Arizona, USA
2
Departments of Clinical Sciences and
3
Basic Sciences, College of Veterinary Medicine; and the
4
Department of Agricultural and Biological Engineering, College of Agriculture and Life Sciences,
Mississippi State University, Mississippi State, MS, USA
Summary
The objective of this study was to evaluate the effect of
negative intra-articular pressure on shoulder joint sta-
bility in canine cadavers. Cadaver forelimbs from 12
mature dogs were used. The forelimbs were placed in a
testing frame and axially preloaded with 4 kg of
weight. Shoulder joint stability was tested in flexion,
extension, and neutral position before and after venting
of the joint capsule. Humeral translation relative to the
glenoid was induced by applying a 3 kg load in three
different directions (cranial, lateral, and medial) and
quantitatively measured by use of an electromagnetic
motion tracking system. Peak translational data were
compared in each joint position before and after vent-
ing of the joint capsule. After venting the shoulder joint
capsule, a significant increase in translation was ob-
served in the cranial direction with the joint in neutral
position and in the medial direction with the joint in
extension. The horizontal translations measured after
venting of the joint capsule were likely not clinically
relevant. Negative intra-articular pressure is not a
major contributor to shoulder stability in dogs during
weight-bearing.
Keywords
Shoulder joint, biomechanics, instability, intra-articular
pressure, canine
Vet Comp Orthop Traumatol 2006; 19: 157–61
Introduction
Shoulder stability in dogs is dependent on
both active and passive stabilizing mechan-
isms. Primarily, the joint capsule and gleno-
humeral ligaments prevent excessive trans-
lation and rotation of the glenoid and hum-
eral head (1, 2). In addition, the biceps ten-
don is an important passive stabilizer in sev-
eral joint positions (1). Numerous other
shoulder joint stabilizing mechanisms have
been investigated by researchers in human
orthopaedics, including the phenomenon of
negative intra-articular pressure. In the nor-
mal shoulder joint, a slight negative intra-ar-
ticular pressure is present and is created by
the synovium as it removes free fluid via os-
mosis (3, 4). Several researchers have inves-
tigated the effects of this negative intra-
articular pressure on the stability of the
human shoulder joint (5–8). This negative
pressure contributes to shoulder stability in
all directions by adding a slight resistance to
distraction when the humerus and scapula
are separated. The amount of resistance is
about 431 N/m
2
(3). Violation of the joint
can negate this stabilizing effect because of
the equilibration of the intra-articular press-
ure with atmospheric pressure. Venting of
the joint capsule in human shoulders re-
duces the force necessary to displace the
humeral head by an average of 50% (5). In
veterinary literature, the authors know of
only one study that has evaluated the role of
negative intra-articular pressure as a stabi-
lizer of the dog shoulder (9). In that study,
negative intra-articular pressure did not ap-
pear to be a major contributor to shoulder
stabilization. The goal of this study was to
provide additional objective, biomechanical
data regarding the effect of negative intra-ar-
ticular pressure on shoulder stability in dogs.
Material and methods
Testing frame
The testing frame has been described and
used in a previous biomechanical study of
shoulder joint stability (1) (Figs. 1, 2). To
summarize, the frame consisted of a foun-
dation, a locking plate, a loading platform,
and three horizontal loading bars. The lock-
ing plate anchors the antebrachium during
mechanical testing. Four stainless steel verti-
cal posts (height, 91.4 cm) were fixed to the
corners of the foundation (25.4 cm apart). A 4
kg loading platform was positioned on the
four posts and was used to axially load the
shoulder joints once they were positioned in
the frame. A braking device placed on one of
the vertical posts prevented loading of the
limbs during mounting of the specimens. A
metal brace projected from the loading plat-
form to rigidly fix the scapula during testing.
The scapular brace allowed for easy angular
adjustment of the shoulder joints. On three
sides of the testing frame, adjustable loading
bars were present that permitted loading of
the proximal portion of the humerus in the
cranial, lateral, and medial directions.
Data collection
An electromagnetic motion tracking system
(Fastrak, Polhemus, Inc., Colchester, VT)
For personal or educational use only. No other uses without permission. All rights reserved.
Downloaded from www.vcot-online.com on 2018-04-07 | ID: 1000333563 | IP: 54.70.40.11