Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Sustainable Cities and Society
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/scs
Energy and environmental performance based decision support process for
early design stages of residential buildings under climate change
Mumine Gercek
⁎
, Zeynep Durmuş Arsan
Department of Architecture, Izmir Institute of Technology, Urla, Izmir, Turkey
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Residential buildings
Building energy and environmental
performance
Sensitivity analysis
Design decision support
Climate change
ABSTRACT
Building design decisions have high impacts on energy and environmental performance of buildings. Especially,
conscious decisions in earlier design stages are more significant due to lifespan impact of buildings. Deficiencies
in systematic approach for design decision support to increase energy and environmental performance of
buildings are projected as the major problems of this study. Decisions for performance-based design should be
made in terms of the most effective design parameters peculiar for each project. This study exemplifies the act of
design decision support in early design stage of a residential building in Turkey. The relation between design
parameters and annual energy consumption for heating, cooling and annual operational CO
2
emissions is ex-
amined by global sensitivity analyses for the present, 2020s, 2050s and 2080s weather conditions. Design
process requires the assessment of the uncertainties in building performance caused both by design parameters
and climate change. The results indicate that the decisions about solar heat gain coefficients (SHGC), and heat
transfer coefficients (U) of transparent surfaces on building envelope have the highest impacts on energy and
environmental performance of residential buildings in hot-humid climatic conditions.
1. Introduction
Increasing energy demand together with environmental problems
resulting from global warming and climate change have accelerated the
global attraction about energy and environmental issues. These pro-
blems are mainly solved by decreasing energy consumption and
greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. Therefore, significant consideration is
given to the building sector to diminish the global problems. For in-
stance, residential buildings are accounted for 35.11% of energy con-
sumption in Turkey (The Ministry of Energy & Natural Resources,
2014). Moreover, the total CO
2
equivalent GHG emissions increased
122% from 1990 to 2015, while energy consumption covers 71.6% of
total releases (Turkish Statistical Institute, 2017). It is emphasized that
the decisions in earlier stages of design are even more significant to
reach projected performance goals (US Energy Information
Administration, 2011).
The concept of sustainable design has become a global medium, by
which architects aim to meet human needs while preserving the en-
vironment. Accordingly, many countries have already established laws
and institutions towards reducing the effects of climate change, in-
creasing energy savings and reducing CO
2
emissions. However, archi-
tects, in practice, may not have full of knowledge, or comprehend all
parameters simultaneously, since the design and construction are
imperfect processes with a variety of inherent uncertainties. Hence, the
importance of design decision support arises, as well.
The realities of global warming and increasing energy demand have
revealed the need for holistic environmental solutions. Building design
is a complex process; including not only aesthetical issues but also
many factors to be thought to meet physical, environmental and user-
centered requirements. The quality criteria for sustainable building
design has a wide range from conventional performance indicators to
the most recent subjects such as nearly zero energy consumption, en-
ergy plus structuring and carbon zero buildings/cities. Many legislative
regulations exist to increase the building performance of already ex-
isting and new buildings (European Union [EU], 2002). In this sense,
there are plenty of very recent studies scrutinizing energy performance
assessment. The design decision support approaches are also one of the
intensive topics related to the improvement of building energy perfor-
mance, especially for early design stages (Tavares & Martins, 2007;
Vullo, Passera, & Lollini, 2018).
The recent literature on design decision support for architects fo-
cuses on the link between two main study areas: professional experi-
ences gained from previous works and decision support information
provided by the digital analysis tools. Hence, creating a link between
professionals and systematic knowledge received from building per-
formance simulations has become significant for building design stages
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scs.2019.101580
Received 21 September 2018; Received in revised form 24 February 2019; Accepted 29 April 2019
⁎
Corresponding author at: Izmir Institute of Technology, Department of Architecture, Block A, Room: 323, 35430, Urla, Izmir, Turkey.
E-mail addresses: muminegercek@iyte.edu.tr (M. Gercek), zeynepdurmus@iyte.edu.tr (Z. Durmuş Arsan).
Sustainable Cities and Society 48 (2019) 101580
Available online 04 May 2019
2210-6707/ © 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
T