Bridge Structures 15 (2019) 197–205
DOI:10.3233/BRS-190159
IOS Press
197
Effect of railing deterioration on load
carrying capacity of concrete slab bridges
F. Darwich
a
, K. Tarhini
b
and M. Mabsout
a,∗
a
American University of Beirut, Beirut, Lebanon
b
U.S. Coast Guard Academy, New London, CT, USA
Abstract. Recent studies quantified the increase in load-carrying capacity of bridges by 45% due to the presence of concrete
railings. These railings are subject to deterioration due to accidents. This parametric study quantifies the effect of railing
deterioration and its impact on load-carrying capacity of bridges. A total of 112 bridge cases were analyzed using finite
element analysis (FEA). The FEA results for slab moments were calculated and compared to reference cases and AASHTO
procedures. FEA moments for bridge cases with one railing fully deteriorated compared well with AASHTO, with the
exception of one-lane bridges where the overestimation by AASHTO reaches 20% for 1 ft deteriorated length, and decreased
to 10% as the deterioration length increased to 8 ft. Railing deteriorations also changed FEA edge moments significantly by
underestimating moments by 40% for two-lane bridges. This research can help engineers quantify the effect of railings on
load carrying capacity of bridges.
Keywords: Concrete slab bridges, railing deterioration, finite-element analysis, AASHTO procedures, load-carrying capacity,
wheel load distribution
1. Introduction
The design of highway bridges in the United
States conforms to the American Association of State
Highway and Transportation Officials (AASHTO)
Standard Specifications for Highway Bridges
(AASHTO Specs 2002) or AASHTO Load and
Resistance Factor Design (LRFD) Bridge Design
Specifications (AASHTO LRFD 2012). The current
AASHTO procedures do not consider the effect of
railings that are built integrally with bridge deck in
the analysis and design or in evaluating the load-
carrying capacity of concrete slab bridges. These
railings have the effect of stiffening and attracting
load to the slab edge and therefore altering the lateral
wheel load distribution on concrete slab bridges.
Mabsout et al. (2004) investigated single-span,
simply-supported reinforced concrete slab bridges
using finite-element analysis (FEA). Results indica-
∗
Corresponding author. M. Mabsout, American University of
Beirut, Beirut, Lebanon. E-mail: mounir@aub.edu.lb.
ted that AASHTO Standard Specifications moments
overestimate the FEA moments for short spans and
one-lane bridges but agreed with FEA moments for
short-span bridges with two or more lanes. It was
also found that AASHTO Standard Specifications
underestimated the FEA moments for longer spans.
However, for AASHTO LRFD procedure, it overes-
timated the FEA moments for all bridge cases. In
addition, several published studies were conducted by
investigating the influence of sidewalks and railings
on wheel load distribution in steel and prestressed
girder bridges which was shown to increase the
stiffness of the superstructure and increase the load-
carrying capacity of these bridges (Akinci et al. 2008,
Chung et al. 2006, Conner & Huo 2006, Eamon &
Nowak 2002, Mabsout et al. 1997).
Previous studies have shown and quantified the
increase in the load-carrying capacity of bridges due
to the presence of railings, which tends to be sig-
nificant depending on the railing size and bridge
geometry. Recently, a parametric investigation by
1573-2487/19/$35.00 © 2019 – IOS Press and the authors. All rights reserved