Review
The influence of religion on the acceptance and
integration of immigrants: A multi-dimensional
perspective
Allon Vishkin
1
and Pazit Ben-Nun Bloom
2
Abstract
We review the role of religion in the acceptance and integration
of immigrants. Majority groups’ religion can exert both a posi-
tive and negative effect on tolerance and acceptance of im-
migrants, depending on the dimension of religiosity and
depending on whether immigrants do or do not share the same
religious affiliation. Immigrants’ religion can also exert both a
positive and negative effect on their integration, by providing a
social network and a system of meaning but also potentially
facilitating extremism, depending on value conflicts with the
majority group and acceptance by the majority group. We
conclude by highlighting avenues for future research, including
the study of manifestations of religion in the public sphere.
Addresses
1
Technion – Israel Institute of Technology, Israel
2
The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Israel
Corresponding author: Vishkin, Allon (allonv@technion.ac.il)
Current Opinion in Psychology 2022, 47:101421
This review comes from a themed issue on Immigration (2023)
Edited by Amanda Venta , Alfonso Mercado and Melanie
M. Domenech Rodríguez
For complete overview about the section, refer Immigration (2023)
Available online 7 July 2022
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.copsyc.2022.101421
2352-250X/© 2022 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords
Religion, Immigration, Integration, Motivation.
Religion functions as a belief system and as a potent social
identity by which people differentiate their ingroup from
the outgroups [1]. As a social identity, religion plays a
powerful role in shaping immigration attitudes of majority
groups as well as in the integration of immigrants. We
begin by presenting a multidimensional model of religion
which accounts for various motivations to be religious as
well as various ways religion is expressed. Next, we use this
model to review and integrate the literature on how reli-
gion shapes majority groups’ acceptance of immigrants
from diverse backgrounds and how immigrants’ religion
shapes their integration.
Religion can have complex and contradictory effects on
diverse outcomes, such as by both increasing and
decreasing prejudice towards outgroups [2], including
towards immigrants [3]. One resolution to explain such
contradictory findings is that religion is made up of
several types of expressions which can exert opposing
effects [4e8]. For instance, engaging in collective rituals
such as attendance at religious services is associated
with increased prejudice towards outgroups, while pri-
vate devotional practices and endorsement of religious
beliefs are not [5,6,9e11]. This distinction might
reflect how private devotional practices and religious
beliefs manifest an endorsement of a God who created a
universal moral order, whereas engaging in collective
rituals manifests a commitment to one’s religious group.
However, attendance at religious services is also some-
times associated with pro-immigration attitudes
[12e14], whereas fundamentalist beliefs are sometimes
tied to anti-immigration sentiment [15,16]. To resolve
why religious expressions may demonstrate such
inconsistent findings, we have recently suggested that
more than one motivation may underlie a particular
religious expression [17]. Furthermore, we have mapped
associations between religious motivations and religious
expressions among religious Christians in the United
Kingdom and religious Jews in Israel [18] (see Figure 1).
Specifically, an intrinsic motivation directed towards
connecting with the divine, searching for personal sig-
nificance, and seeking self-improvement is associated
with professed belief and with engaging in private reli-
gious behavior; an affiliative motivation directed towards
belonging to a community is associated with engaging in
religious social behavior such as communal prayer; a
motivation to maintain one’s religious tradition and
observe its rules is associated with professed belief; and
a motivation to socially enhance oneself by committing
to one’s religious ingroup and denigrating outgroups is
associated with both religious belief and social behavior.
We bear this two-layered multi-dimensional model in
mind, with several expressionsdthe observable ele-
ments of religiondbeing underlied by several different
motivations, when reviewing how religion might shape
the acceptance and integration of immigrants.
This research was supported by the European Research Council under
the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation
programme (#804031), awarded to the second author.
Available online at www.sciencedirect.com
ScienceDirect
www.sciencedirect.com Current Opinion in Psychology 2022, 47:101421