PHYSICAL REVIEW A 83, 032702 (2011)
Effects of polarization on laser-induced electron-ion recombination
T. Mohamed,
1,*
G. Andler,
2
M. Fogle,
1
E. Justiniano,
3
S. Madzunkov,
1
and R. Schuch
1,†
1
Department of Physics, Atomic Physics, Stockholm University, S-106 91 Stockholm, Sweden
2
Manne Siegbahn Laboratory, Stockholm University, S-10405 Stockholm, Sweden
3
Department of Physics, East Carolina University, Greenville, North Carolina 27858, USA
(Received 16 September 2010; published 3 March 2011)
The polarization dependence of laser-induced radiative recombination (LIR) to D
+
ions was investigated in
the electron cooler of the CRYRING storage ring. The LIR gain as a function of wavelength into n = 3 principal
quantum states of deuterium was measured at laser beam polarization angles of 0
◦
and 90
◦
with respect to the
direction of the motional electric field in the interaction region. For the case of the polarization vector parallel
to the external field, there is a double-peak structure in the gain curve that indicates a polarization effect in the
LIR process. The two polarization directions also reveal a different width for the respective gain curves, giving
additional evidence for the polarization effect, clearly seen by the behavior of a defined polarization parameter.
The obtained polarization effect indicates a high sensitivity in recombination processes to external fields.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevA.83.032702 PACS number(s): 34.80.Lx, 42.25.Ja
I. INTRODUCTION
In the universe, most matter exists in the plasma stage, i.e., it
consists of free ions and electrons. Recombination of electrons
with ions is balanced by electron-impact ionization processes
and the emission of electromagnetic radiation is controlled
by inelastic electron-ion collisions. When a free electron is
captured into a bound state in the ion, with the simultaneous
emission of a photon, it is called radiative recombination (RR).
This results in a continuum of photon energies determined
by the electron energy distribution and the final quantum
state. The basic theory of radiative transitions predicts that
the recombination rate can be enhanced by stimulated photon
emission using an external photon field such as that provided
by an intense, monochromatic laser. Such a process is referred
to as laser-induced recombination (LIR).
Considering the applied aspects and inherent fundamental
processes in nature, it is important to study the dynamic behav-
ior of recombination processes involving atomic constituents
of matter. An in-depth knowledge of the physics governing
these processes can also help us to prepare antimatter in the
laboratory, e.g., for studying antihydrogen with high precision
by recombining antiprotons with positrons [1]. In particular,
LIR can be used to enhance weak recombination rates [2]
by orders of magnitude compared to spontaneous RR [3] and
also to prepare antihydrogen atoms in well-defined quantum
states [4–6].
Heavy-ion storage rings equipped with electron coolers
are powerful tools for measuring recombination processes
at small relative energies. These electron coolers’ primary
function is to reduce the stored ion beam’s emittance with a
velocity-matched, cold-electron beam. The collinear electron
beam also serves as an electron scattering target for near-zero
energy electron-ion collisions for studies of recombination.
*
Permanent address: Physics Department, Faculty of Science, Beni-
Suef University, Egypt.
†
Author to whom correspondence should be addressed:
schuch@physto.se
A disadvantage of electron coolers is that recombination
photons are difficult to observe. This can, in part, be overcome
by LIR, as a specific final state can be selected by setting the
photon energy close to its binding energy. Stimulated photon
emission is a resonant process, because it will only occur if the
energy of the photons matches the energy difference E
e
− E
n
,
where E
e
and E
n
are the energy of the electron and the energy
of the bound state, respectively. The ratio between the induced
recombination rate to the total spontaneous recombination rate
over all final states n is referred to as the gain.
In the spontaneous recombination rate, close to zero relative
electron collision energy, an enhancement over the theoretical
predictions, has been observed in measurements at ion cooler
storage rings. This has drawn attention both theoretically
[7–11] and experimentally [12–16]. Such an enhancement
effect was also investigated for the LIR process and was
found by Schramm et al.[17] for C
6+
. There, LIR shows a
similar enhancement to that of spontaneous RR at low detuning
energies of the merged ion and electron beams. LIR, therefore,
represents an ideal tool to probe this effect with high resolution
and additional parameters, such as polarization properties and
energy detuning of a laser beam.
In fact, an additional effect that could be connected to
the enhancement is the large contribution below threshold
observed in LIR for specific laser tunings to defined principal
quantum states [18–21]. Three possibilities could cause this
below threshold gain: (1) the formation of quasibound Rydberg
states when the ions pass through the toroid magnet of the
electron cooler, which merges the electron beam with the ion
beam. There is a transverse motional electric field in this area
of the electron cooler that acts as a pulsed field (∼ns). This
field can induce electrons to be captured into high-lying states.
The effect of such a field pulse has been used to explain the
observed recombination enhancement [11,22]. Electrons in
the high-lying states could be driven by the laser to a lower
state and contribute thus to the below-threshold gain. A similar
process has been observed in pulsed field recombination [23].
(2) The external electric fields in the interaction region of the
electron cooler: The main sources of these external electric
fields are (a) the field owing to the electron-beam space
032702-1 1050-2947/2011/83(3)/032702(6) ©2011 American Physical Society